Raaga of Nanena Madideno

[Asha Adiga]

I was looking for Puranadara Dasaru song " Nanena Madideno" and I see many version. Debating on Raaga. Please clarify ?

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I0WVMmfdMcw- Looks like Desh or Brindavani ?

2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QFwA3WPFkZ8 - Which Raaga ?

[Lakshman]

Song # 1 is in brndAvanasArangA. video for song # 2 is not available on the net.

[Sachi_R]

#2https://youtu.be/QFwA3WPFkZ8 Mohana Kalyani.
#1The track does switch between Brindavani and Desh.

[Asha Adiga]

Song # 1 is in brndAvanasArangA. video for song # 2 is not available on the net.

Thanks..!

2nd version by M S Sheela : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QFwA3WPFkZ8

[Asha Adiga]

#2https://youtu.be/QFwA3WPFkZ8 Mohana Kalyani.
#1The track does switch between Brindavani and Desh.

Thanks.

I know the 1st version is sung by Hindustani singer Puttur Narasimhanayak : Wondering can it fit in one raaga in Carnatic music ?

[Asha Adiga]

1st version :

Brindavana Saaranga : A: S R2 M1 P N3 S - Av: S N2 P M1 R2 G2 R2 S

Brindavani A: S R2 M1 P N3 S - Av: S N2 P M1 R2 S

Desh : Aa: S R2 M1 P N3 S - Av: S N2 D2 P M1 G3 R2 S

No doubt the Arohanam is happening S R2 M1 P N3 S. Avaroohanam is the confusing.

I was going over this like also...! viewtopic.php?t=2222

[Sachi_R]

I like the M S Sheela version. Perhaps you can go with it.

[Asha Adiga]

I like the M S Sheela version. Perhaps you can go with it.

Thanks