A question about Rishabham [ri] and Nishadam [ni].

Miscellaneous topics on Carnatic music
Post Reply
Vardhaman
Posts: 11
Joined: 12 May 2016, 18:17

A question about Rishabham [ri] and Nishadam [ni].

Post by Vardhaman »

I have been studying about shrutis for some time now and I noticed a few differences in both systems.
I have noticed that Hindustanis use Rishabham at 10/9 while carnatic musicians use 9/8 one.
Same with Nishadam, ie 15/8 vs 243/128.

Now in Natya Shastra it is stated that Ri is of 4 shruti which would mean 9/8 is the right one.
Ni is one shruti lower than the Sa so 243/128 should be right.
But hindustani musicians use it differently and even in carnatic music notes vary according to the raagam.
Could anyone knowledgeable provide some insight?

Thank you.

Post Reply