Triloka Maata Nannu

Tālam & Layam related topics
Post Reply
SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#1 Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

I've heard two versions of Triloka Maata nannu - one by MDR in Mishra Chaapu and another (simpler) Adi Tala version. Now I have heard somewhere that a few of Shyama Sastri's krithis have got themselves simplified to Adi talam over time, nevertheless in this case I have a real problem.

The trouble is that MDR being MDR, his version is nearly impossible to follow on the talam, though I believe I've finally figured it out after slowing down the recording and physically counting how many notes each syllable stretches and seeing how that pattern would fit into the tala, but I still have doubts. And now I've heard another version with a totally different eduppu and splitting in the same Mishra Chaapu -- can anyone give me a video to clarify?

bhakthim dehi
Posts: 496
Joined: 24 Feb 2014, 21:28
x 24

#2 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by bhakthim dehi »

This kind of discrepancy in talam is also seen with Himachala tanaya, ananda bairavi. You can also do a research in this krithi.

Rsachi
Posts: 5039
Joined: 31 Aug 2009, 13:54
x 2

#3 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by Rsachi »

Srinath
I was reading y'day that some MChapu compositions of Shyama Shastri employ 1234123 and not 1231234

Rsachi
Posts: 5039
Joined: 31 Aug 2009, 13:54
x 2

#4 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by Rsachi »

Srinath,
i checked in the book of notations of Shyama Shastri kritis written by Prof Nagamani Srinath
She has notated using Viloma Chapu= 1234123

SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#5 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

@Rsachi, thanks. This is almost equivalent to a Mishra Chaapu on a 3/7 eduppu (if the cycle is 7 beats) - so the pattern is -- t, t, t t , || This is what I have also concluded after listening to the syllable and melodic splitting. The difference is that in a Mishra Chaapu, regardless of eduppu, the tala and by extension the mridangist would end like t t , t, t, || (at the ||), but in a viloma chaapu it would end on t, t, t t , || (no wonder I never cracked that ending part) . Have I got it?

Now that you have told me of this, I need to go back and check how my viloma chaapu's I have accidentally labelled as Mishra chaapus in Shyama Shastris compositions in my list. And by extension I think all Shyama Shastri krithis are trickier with the tala (often what you think is a Roopakam turns out to be a Tisra Adi), so @bhaktimdehi it looks I've got to do more research. :roll:

Plus, it's a bit annoying isn't it when a tala for a composition is simply labelled "Chaapu" around the web when it could be any one of several chaapu talas? :geek:

Also I would like it very much if anyone could list out all the chaapu talas out for me.

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10929
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01
x 11

#6 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by vasanthakokilam »

Srinath, I will read through this more carefully in a few days but you are talking about issues that interest me very much.

In this context, I observed a while back that 'kripaya palaya chowrE' can be fit on to a couple of different starting points on top of MC. It will all feel natural. Our member Mohan from Australia who is a keyboard player and music teacher opined that that is the nature of Misra chapu itself and in that sense we have to give it separate considerations from the traditional saptha thalas. This is something we can pursue here.

Even within the saptha talas, while they are used to define cycle lengths, there is no consistency on the rules on how the internal laya of the song is overlaid on the tala. Because of that the same song can be overlaid on top of different talas of the same cycle count. To align the stress points one can always move the eduppu.

keerthi
Posts: 1309
Joined: 12 Oct 2008, 14:10

#7 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by keerthi »

SrinathK,

0. Trilokamata nannu [Paras], HimAcala Tanaya brOcuTaku [as Bhaktim dehi pointed out], KaruNa jUDu [srIrAgam] and Ninnu vinAga mari [pUrvakalyANi] all have two prevalent versions of singing. There is another example, but it is so obscure that I will come to it in the end. All the songs in this above list have settings in Adi tAla samagraham, as well as a mishrA chApu/ viloma chApu setting [with different graham in each case]. You can find examples from the repertoires of artistes of the last three generations.

1. Subbarama DIkSitar whose honesty and integrity matched or even surpassed his erudition; gives the Pharas song as Caturashra Eka, and not Adi [as he was wont to do for Adi tAla songs, especially those with a vishama graha, like the deshAdi songs of tyAgarAja]. Similarly he gives the mAnji song 'brovavamma' as being in a 'Misra Laghuvu'. Please note, not triputa or Misra Ekam, but Misra Laghuvu.

2. This Misra Laghu(vu) is the term also used by the DhanammAL descendants to designate the tAla setting of many songs that they sang - including KaruNa jUDu [Sri], taruNamidamma [gauLipantu] and ninnu vinAga [PUrvakalyAni] . Other significant examples are their family heirloom prANasakhuDiTu, the janjUTi jAvaLi; which they sang] and nI mAtalEmAyenu rA- the pUrvakalyANi jAvaLi [both notated in Brindamma’s book JavaLigaL, published by Music Academy].

Most people have never heard of the Misra Laghuvu setting, and some of the few who have been exposed to it, don't understand how it is supposed to be. Palghat Mani Iyer and AriyakuDi were two people outside the Dhanam family who understood it perfectly. I have encountered several Kathakali singers, (including some of barely average quality) who have grasped this somewhat difficult idea.

3. The Mishra Laghuvu is a leisurely paced beat, which like Prof SRJ's Mishra Eka for many of dIksitar's 14 beat masterpieces, consists only of one ghAta [beat/ taTTU] follwed by noiseless finger counts of the remaining akSaras, followed by another beat to mark the next Avarta.

4. So much for the tAla structure. The superlative brilliance of the Mishra Laghuvu composition, is that like the interchangeable tautomeric forms seen in Organic chemistry, the krti will appear at the same time to be a song in Mishra NadaI and Adi tAlam or Cat. Eka tAlam; or Caturashra NaDai Mishra Ekam/ChApu.

Like the garbha-padya trick verses, wherein one verse in x metre is found embedded within another verse in another (bigger) metre Y; the Mishra Laghuvu songs will have sections that seem to be textbook aditAlam or 4-fold naDai, sections that are almost a stiff beat-to-beat archetype for Mishra nadai (or even Mishra chApu) and sections that fit equally well in both, with a delicious, tantalizing ambiguity.

While it is tempting to attribute this bit of laya brilliance to ShyAma shAstri, [seeing how he demonstrates this also in his Adi talam Tryashra NaDai songs that tautomerise with a Caturashra NaDai rUpaka chApu setting]; I feel it is older. Many of the daruvu-s from old yakSagAnams and Koravanjis, many padams, particularly those of sArangapAni; and many compositions of the haridAsas from KarnATaka demonstrate similar laya versatility in a most natural, un-laboured fashion.

This, is most likely a feature of laya in music of a different vintage, that we have mostly lost now. What we have got in stead is a crude parody of the most rudimentary in-your-face laya.

5. Many people end up singing the songs either in a vanilla flavour Adi talam or 7 beat chApu, thereby completely ignoring this somewhat complex aspect of the song’s internal rhythm. All the syncopated sections end up as landing on the beat in a predictable setting that is bland and insipid. For instance most people sing nI mATalemAyenu in Adi, while very few people (Like suguna Varadachari) sing it in M.chApu.


Last Point - DhanammAL's remarkable recording of nannu brOvu [lalita] which those razor sharp sphuritam immediately followed by mellow melting melodious meeTTu-less sancAras is the clinching evidence for the family's superior command over rhythm, keeping it as an undercurrent, and not as a coarse foreground that obscures the melodic structure of the song. This last point is ample illustrated in their handling of padams and even some other compositions in the chApu setting.

keerthi
Posts: 1309
Joined: 12 Oct 2008, 14:10

#8 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by keerthi »

After that indigestible stuff, a couple of light weight asides.

VK -

It is kRpaya pAlaya shaurE!, wherein the last word is a name of kRSNa - shauri [since he was born in shUrasena's lineage]. 'chaure' will make it a supplication for protection from any of these options -

1. son/daughter-of-a-thief [somewhat similar to the telugu expletive donga- na-koD(u)kA!] if you take it as a Sanskrt word.

2. wig [in Tamil, kannaDa]

3. the furry white fans waved at the sides of deities [and kings], supposed made out of yaks' tails, if we are speaking in the Edwardian English favored by the Maharashran Indologists that have translated many Sanskrt Kavyas into (ahem)English.


Rsachi,

Prof Nagamani Srinath's Volume of Shyama Shastri compositions is very poorly put together, and is ridden with mistakes - both in the sAhitya and musical setting. I would encourage you to not refer to it.

kvchellappa
Posts: 3592
Joined: 04 Aug 2011, 13:54
x 1005

#9 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by kvchellappa »

Shakespeare used to introduce a light scene (humourous) before a graver one like the grave-diggers' scene in Hamlet. Here it comes after!
I read both with rapt attention, understanding somewhat the lighter one.

bhakthim dehi
Posts: 496
Joined: 24 Feb 2014, 21:28
x 24

#10 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by bhakthim dehi »

Can we take then that misra laghuvu and misra ekam are one and the same. If it is so, why did Sri Subbarama dikshithar used two different terms? If it is different, what is the difference. An additional piece of information: Even kamashi svarajathis in bhairavi and yadukula kambhodhi were notated in misra ekam by Subbarama dikshithar.

harimau
Posts: 1819
Joined: 06 Feb 2007, 21:43
x 42

#11 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by harimau »

keerthi wrote:
This, is most likely a feature of laya in music of a different vintage, that we have mostly lost now. What we have got in stead is a crude parody of the most rudimentary in-your-face laya.

...............

Last Point - DhanammAL's remarkable recording of nannu brOvu [lalita] which those razor sharp sphuritam immediately followed by mellow melting melodious meeTTu-less sancAras is the clinching evidence for the family's superior command over rhythm, keeping it as an undercurrent, and not as a coarse foreground that obscures the melodic structure of the song. This last point is ample illustrated in their handling of padams and even some other compositions in the chApu setting.
I wish I could give you 20 thumbs-up votes for your post; unfortunately I am limited to 1.

The first of the two points I have quoted above should be kept in mind by listeners as they walk into an auditorium. What we have today is stridency in music which people perceive as energetic singing and applaud heartily.

The second point I have quoted shows this has been pretty much the case for several decades. Very few people liked the Dhanammal style of music as evidenced by the poor turn-out for her descendants' concerts.

Thanks. You have summed up brilliantly what ails our music today.

Rsachi
Posts: 5039
Joined: 31 Aug 2009, 13:54
x 2

#12 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by Rsachi »

Can I please get a link to Nannu brovu lalitha by Dhanammal?

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10929
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01
x 11

#13 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by vasanthakokilam »

keerthi, thanks for the gyan on 'shaurE' vs 'chaure'. Did not really know and that too where 'shaurE' came from. Of course, I wrote it as 'Chaure' because that is how it sounded to me when people sing it. Gotten curious, I just went to youtube and sampled a few renditions. You have a lot of work cut out for you ;) I hear most of them singing it with more of the 'cau' sound rather than 'shau' sound.

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10929
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01
x 11

#14 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by vasanthakokilam »

Keerthi: On the laya part, awesome stuff. Let me digest that some more and reflect on it. I do relate to the basic concept that having that 'undistinguished' 7 beats give the right playground for singing padams and javalis that enable the composer to have a lot of freedom in structuring the internal laya to suit the mood of the song rather than artificially taking a tala with an internal anga structure and feel weird about violating them or feel constrained by them.

What pleased me is what you pointed out about SD marking Desadi tala songs as Chathusra Eka. That makes a lot of sense for a whole variety of such desadi tala songs. If I just listen to those songs without thinking about any CM conditioning, that is how the laya comes across to me. ( thought not all, I will make exceptions for songs like mA jAnaki). The laya is symmetrical between the pUrvAngA and uttarAngA which itself gives rise to the notion it is really a 4 beat structure. In addition the internal laya for most of such songs can be reasonably approximated without loss of too much data to an alternating heavy and light beat ( down and up beat, if I may, which is the most universal of beat structures ).

SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#15 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

Here it is : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TADuRovnmZg

Use Easy Youtube downloader addon in Firefox and get videos in HD with 192 kbps mp4.

SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#16 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

@keerthi, Wow, that's fascinating. I have never heard of this concept before. I need a demonstration of this Mishra Laghuvu -- to me it sounds like a Mishra Ekam with a Mishra Nadai subbeat running inside of it. A similar idea I had in mind was that many M.Chaapu and Khanda Chaapu pieces in Chatushra nadai may be considered as Mishra Nadai or Khanda Nadai Eka Tala compositions in a 2 kalai - if you count the number of avartanams each line runs for.

Indeed we have superimposed the chaapu talas on to the main beats as a solution to "simplify" more complex nadais like tisra (1+2), khanda (2+1+2), divya sankeerna (2+4), mishra (1+2+2+2), sankeerna (1+2+2+2+2), etc. into a "pseudo" chatushra nadai.

The Dhannamal school as far as I have heard them has a speciality in the matter of the rubato - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempo_rubato
Only their variation is something like a "rubber band time" -- instead of every syllable exactly on the beat, they would at certain points pause for a breath and then sing the next syllable slightly off the beat -- causing the passage before the syllable to stretch and the passage after it to compress -- it will still be in sync with the tala. Even if you do listen to the Dhannamal recording above you might find the opposite effect in the very first line, sing a syllable short to compress the prior phrase and stretch the following one.

The same thing happens even in gamakas, one swara is stretched a little in the kampitas while the next anuswara is glanced at and compressed. It gives an impression of "dragging the music" but in reality the mind is much better at noticing what happens in the 1st half of the variation and doesn't immediately grasp how the following phrase is adjusting to keep things in line with the tala -- the stretch of the band is more noticeable than the "snap" that follows -- interestingly one of the very few people who could do this to create unique aesthetic effects even at faster tempos was Palghat Mani Iyer. Among modern singers, TMK (my request not to get worked up :lol: ) is one example who still does this.

These sort of rhythmic subtleties were probably made possible by the lack of playing around with "metronome" percussion accompaniments (though it does make it hard to put the tala for us who're used to hearing evenly spaced notes everywhere). Chowka kala music and the wide spacing between the syllables in varnams and padams made those subtleties with the gamakas and syllables possible. The rise of Madhayama Kala music has made it pretty much impossible to do this today.

varsha
Posts: 1978
Joined: 24 Aug 2011, 15:06
x 2

#17 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by varsha »


SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#18 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

Whoa! That I believe is T Vishwanathan, correct? Now I can see a little bit of how it goes, unlike most Mishra Chaapu krithis where the words fall on the downbeats and the pattern is so obvious, this one looks like it better fits a Mishra Ekam rendered at 1/2 kalai, though just a little adjustment of the syllable placements at some points and suddenly it sounds like you are listening to M. Chaapu again -- as @keerthi put it, deliciously ambigious.

But I want to see how this Mishra Laghuvu is really rendered. I consider this to actually be a Mishra Ekam in 1/2 kalai, instead of playing the M.Chapu pattern of tt,t,t, -- you are in fact counting all the 7 beats. Is that why it's called a Laghuvu? If I am off the mark, please do show me a demonstration.

Reminds me of Oothukadu Venkata Kavi's "Aadum Varai" in Huseni which as far as I have heard it can fit pefectly onto both a Roopakam in Chatushra nadai and an Adi in Tishra Nadai.

Ah, the tragedies of the past where we have lost most of the Dikshitar school's handling of their ragas, some of the laya genius of Shyama Sastri, many vivadi krithis of Thyagaraja (and one Pancharatnam's original form) ... that is one place where innovation and superstition was truly the enemy of tradition.

varsha
Posts: 1978
Joined: 24 Aug 2011, 15:06
x 2

#19 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by varsha »

Whoa! That I believe is T Vishwanathan, correct?
Let there be no doubt !!! :lol:
Spent the better part of an afternoon to get this gem ready
http://www.mediafire.com/watch/1zr418bd ... _vsiva.mp4

keerthi
Posts: 1309
Joined: 12 Oct 2008, 14:10

#20 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by keerthi »

Bhaktim dehi : Can we take then that misra laghuvu and misra ekam are one and the same. If it is so, why did Sri Subbarama dikshithar used two different terms? If it is different, what is the difference
.

All good questions. I don’t have any substantial answers as of yet. You could maybe recommend it to some of those talented music graduate students who waste their time, energy and paper writing analytically bankrupt MA , M.Phil and Ph.D dissertations on ‘The esoteric, exoteric and psalteric content of the kamalAmbA navAvaranams’, or ‘A textual and melodic analysis of post-taniavartanam pieces in the 20th century’ and other such profound gibberish.
I’m sure, given such useful topics [like the Misra Laghuvu and Mishra Eka one] most of those students are clever, competent and motivated enough to accomplish such small projects, and probably just suffer from a lack of ideas.


Varsha, thanks for the precious upload. Didn't know it existed. Will listen and get back. Not having heard it yet, I suspect Viswa may have learnt this from Sri TiruppAmburam Swaminatha Pillai, and not Dhanam.


Harimau, I am glad you appreciate and agree with those things I said.

SrinathK,

Firstly, Thanks for introducing the concept of Rubato. Yes, it is a paradigmatic feature of the music of this family, [and of many other talented past masters]. You are right in pointing out that TMK is one of few who do it. Another dark horse in this category is Prof T.R.Subrahmanyam, who used it both in krti sangatis and in neraval to good effect.

Unfortunately most modern artistes who interpret the compositions of Diksitar do not consider this possibility, and if we listen to their versions of Diksitar’s compositions; there is a very rudimentary geetam style of singing, where every sAhityakSara lands on a beat. However, the Dhanammal family’s repertoire of Diksitar krti-s all have the same boneless grace that their padam interpretations did. And in the case of dikSitar’s songs, almost all of it came from Pancanada Iyer, through Dhanammal, and her hand in preserving/lending this fine polish and elegance is evident.

Most of this has little to do with your original discussion. Nonetheless it is of some general value.

These sort of rhythmic subtleties were probably made possible by the lack of playing around with "metronome" percussion accompaniments (though it does make it hard to put the tala for us who're used to hearing evenly spaced notes everywhere). Chowka kala music and the wide spacing between the syllables in varnams and padams made those subtleties with the gamakas and syllables possible.

- I think it is a wrong belief that training in metronome-level tAla makes it difficult to learn the syncopated and irregularly spaced versions. It is only when our understanding of laya and tAla stagnates at the learners level.

- We learn the varase-s but do not (hopefully) sing svara-kalpana that sounds like the varase exercises. Similarly we learn the metronome type tAla in the varasai-alankAra gItam stage; and unfortunately our conception of laya doesn’t progress beyond this level. Like I pointed out, Kathakali singers are able to grasp this effortlessly since it is a prominent aspect of the kathakaLi padam singing style. I have felt the same about the 'SopAnam' style recitation of songs from the gIta-gOvinda.

- Cauka kAla – Yes. Learning the concept and developing a ruci for it while practising in Cauka kAla; will ensure that one is also able to pull it off in the madhyama and druta tempi.

varsha
Posts: 1978
Joined: 24 Aug 2011, 15:06
x 2

#21 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by varsha »

Didn't know it existed
sent you a mail on this .

SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#22 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

@varsha, Thanks a lot for taking the time to share these all with us. In the video, he renders it in a Mishra Chaapu only.

As for the video of Dhannamal (and the collections of Brinda and Mukta I have), what is most astonishing is that the family played their repertoire with such intricate gamakas and fine polishing back then in an era when others (especially male singers) were singing with a rawness seen in today's kids just out of geetham level and newly exposed to gamakas (if those gramaphone records are to be believed).

uday_shankar
Posts: 1410
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:37
x 45
x 2

#23 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by uday_shankar »

An absolutely delightful discussion.
keerthi wrote:Unfortunately most modern artistes who interpret the compositions of Diksitar do not consider this possibility, and if we listen to their versions of Diksitar’s compositions; there is a very rudimentary geetam style of singing
Perhaps the problem is that neither the oral tradition nor written works (say SSP) give any line by line indication of tempo. In western classical compositions, especially late romatic to modern era, the score contains many tempo cues on the bars as needed. In CM it is left to the discretion of the individual interpreter and in the absence of any cues from the original composer the less inspired performers stick to metronomic rhythm. Conscious rubato which adds character, depth and flavor to the music is desirable but unconscious "ottal" perhaps not.

In WCM conducting, there are conductors who stick to tempo like a metronome (say the late Georg Solti) and there are conductors who stretch and compress effortlessly and build a soundscape that is magnificent (such as the late Herbert von Karajan). In general I've preferred listening to the non-metronomic conductors but I am sure the orchestra hated them. Imagine an ensemble trying to read, play and at the same time follow the vague movements of a baton swinging to stretchable rhythm.
SrinathK wrote:played their repertoire with such intricate gamakas and fine polishing back then in an era when others (especially male singers) were singing with a rawness seen in today's kids just out of geetham level and newly exposed to gamakas (if those gramaphone records are to be believed).
The reason is that those old male singers were singing to outdoor audiences under a pandal and only simple shouting carried. The nagasvaram alone was able to propagate some gamakams in the outdoors. The Dhanammal family were chamber musicians. However, this does not explain a similar "rawness" in those early vina players, given that they too were chamber musicians. In general I believe gamakas have increased greatly in the post-amplification era including the Dhanammal family. Vina Dhanammal herself was far less gamakamfied than Brindamma.

mahavishnu
Posts: 3333
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 21:56
x 7
x 2

#24 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by mahavishnu »


SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#25 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

Here's the video of the MDR recording. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sihdy0EgHGc

-5 stars for the wretched camera work -- that cameraman must have been the musical ignoramus of the century. I am not sure how MDR renders the talam in the few seconds where the camera remembers to focus on him...it's almost like an abhinayam at times. I would not be surprised at all if MDR stopped in the middle to give a lec dem explaining the song and resuming singing (which I have read he did, the meandering Ganga he was). Can anyone help?

There's an audio recording on Sangeethapriya's Shyama Sastri tribute page.

Ranganayaki
Posts: 1656
Joined: 02 Jan 2011, 06:23
x 166
x 28

#26 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by Ranganayaki »

It is not clear whether it is the original video or the youtube video that has some cuts. There is a distinct cut at exactly 1:30, where a good chunk of the anupallavi is lost. But at that point, you hear a clear takita taka dhimi on the mridangam, which should guide you through the anupallavi and then the pallavi too, this goes on for at least a full minute when even if the mridangam is not completely clear, you can maintain the rhythm heard at 1: 30. And you can use the reprise of the pallavi to know how he sings the pallavi. It seems at one point as though he does a veechu at samam (the Ta of takita) of two successive avartanams - I could be wrong. Does he use a rubberband-time style of singing in the charanam that was described earlier? I think you could try maintaining the takita taka dhimi.. and you find the motions of the mridangist coinciding.. But I am not 100 pc sure.

Again all of your knowledge levels are so high, I may be stating the obvious, but still this aspect has not been mentioned yet, so here I am.

Ranganayaki
Posts: 1656
Joined: 02 Jan 2011, 06:23
x 166
x 28

#27 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by Ranganayaki »


shankarank
Posts: 3282
Joined: 15 Jun 2009, 07:16
x 3
x 8

#28 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by shankarank »

Best way I have observed to keep tALam for such a flow is to do two taps and two waves alternating between the pairs. Whenever changing from tap to wave or wave to tap - leave 4 mAtras - ta-ka-di-mi . Between the taps and waves it will be the takita. It becomes sukam without any teeth nashing..

I have seen Vidushi Smt. M.S Sheela do this in a concert with a miSra nadai song - some dAsara kriti I think.

That works as well for kanDa nadai as in tIrAta viLayATTu piLLai - even though it is less of a problem for kanDa nadai due to the closeness of the beats 2-3.
Last edited by shankarank on 01 Sep 2015, 23:49, edited 1 time in total.

shankarank
Posts: 3282
Joined: 15 Jun 2009, 07:16
x 3
x 8

#29 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by shankarank »

In the video UKS is resisting the flow with takadimi-takita kind of sollus - that is what makes it tough to follow. In the Audio only version, the percussion hugs the normal flow of takita-takadimi where the syllables are positioned.

Can we call that viSama laghuvu? :lol:

SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#30 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

Vishama laghuvu indeed ! Actually in the audio recording, MDR is rendering in Viloma Chapu while UKS is playing the Mishra Chapu pattern at many places ! That was why I was fooled in the beginning.

Actually I was hoping to see from MDR's rendition what tala he was rendering (Dhanammal --- Tiger Varadachariar -- MDR ????) -- maybe now we have to ask some Kathakali dancers to demonstrate this mishra laghuvu (assuming it isn't telugu for the laghu in a usual mishra ekam). But alas my hopes were dashed by the cameraman, God, that camera! Image

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10929
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01
x 11

#31 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by vasanthakokilam »

shankarank wrote:Best way I have observed to keep tALam for such a flow is to do two taps and two waves alternating between the pairs. Whenever changing from tap to wave or wave to tap - leave 4 mAtras - ta-ka-di-mi . Between the taps and waves it will be the takita. It becomes sukam without any teeth nashing..

I have seen Vidushi Smt. M.S Sheela do this in a concert with a miSra nadai song - some dAsara kriti I think.

That works as well for kanDa nadai as in tIrAta viLayATTu piLLai - even though it is less of a problem for kanDa nadai due to the closeness of the beats 2-3.
read this thread after a long time, it got referenced in another thread. Shankarank, I am not sure if I got the tALa keeping method you describe above. Can you elaborate please? Thx

shankarank
Posts: 3282
Joined: 15 Jun 2009, 07:16
x 3
x 8

#32 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by shankarank »

Let me see if this clarifies a bit what I was trying to say.

For a tiSra nadai song like cinnanciru kiLiyE you can handle it without turning the hand - but do two taps at ta-ki positions of the ta-ki-Ta sollus. You can even do just one tap for each beat and get away if you can keep the flow of 3s in your mind.

Lets progress to a kanDa nadai song like tIrAda viLayATTu piLLai. You still don't have to turn the hand - you can tap at "ta" and the second "ta" of the ta-ka-ta-ki-Ta as long as you correctly leave two mAtras after the second "ta" instead of 1 mAtra after the first "ta".

For miSra nadai however you can see the issue. ta-ki-Ta-ta-ka-di-mi are the positions. If you keep tAlam like miSra capu - you may do two taps with palm down or palm facing up ( as it does in a wave) at ta-ki position and then a tap at second "ta" and another tap at the "di". This is unwieldy for a fast flowing (relatively) miSra nadai song. Two close taps at ta-ki positions are hard to do. Then lets say we reduce it to just one at the first "ta" to begin with and do the rest as is - this is done sometimes even in slow miSra cApu for those who are confident that the first tap represents 3 mAtrAs - which its "ta" itself plus 2 mAtras gap. the rest of the two taps are 2 mAtras ( 1+1) reach. Even this is hard in a fast miSra nadai as the perceptible difference between 3 mAtras and 2 mAtras is hard to sense and things can slip.

So we devise a way to reduce further to just two taps at the first "ta" 3 mAtras and second "ta" 4 mAtras. Now 4 is just a wee bit longer and still there may be a confusion whether it is 4 or 3 and after which tap. To make that distinction I think some musicians made it more convenient by doing once cycle with two taps palm facing down and the next cycle with same two taps with palm facing up - with the palm changing direction always after the 4 mAtra section.

MDR ofcourse may just get by, by doing just one tap for the whole cycle and perceive the miSra nadai upto himself - which is what he is doing and many times he may not even do that. :roll:

It is like panca pAndDavAl kaTTil kAl polE mUnRu ( pAndavAs are like the legs in a cot are 3 in number) said some one - showed two fingers and wrote 1 and rubbed that also. :lol:

As someone said to SSI I think about his dEvagAndhAri once - avA manusulE ninaittal maTTum pOrAtu! ellArum ariyumpadi pADaNum! :lol:
Last edited by shankarank on 01 Feb 2016, 06:19, edited 1 time in total.

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10929
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01
x 11

#33 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by vasanthakokilam »

shankarank, thanks, got it.

shankarank
Posts: 3282
Joined: 15 Jun 2009, 07:16
x 3
x 8

#34 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by shankarank »

Here is the miSra nadai song by Vid. Thanmayi Krishnamurthy a disciple of TMK.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ryrWLB0_X9g

I think one such song of Puradaradasa is how Smt. M. S Sheela did the tALam as mentioned in my Post #28 and explained further in #32.

Here is another one by Dr BMK at 5:30 minutes as part if this Album :https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uxUHIlbSsLw

SmaraNE ondE sAladE - usually sung in Adi is sung in MiSra nadai instead.

Syama Sastri - of course is not a soft candy like Purandara Dasa - he is a KaRkanDu ( Crystallized sugar pellets).

SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#35 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

@shankarank, So you reduced the Mishra chApu pattern from -- a) tt,t,t, | to b) t,,t,t, || and then even further to t,,t,,,

You'd be a laya god if you pulled off the t,,,,,, |

The thing is that counting notes and beats (the sollus) is not too hard -- it's the PAUSES (karvais) that are very hard to estimate. On an unrelated note, that's what made Flute Mali such a terror.

shankarank
Posts: 3282
Joined: 15 Jun 2009, 07:16
x 3
x 8

#36 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by shankarank »

SrinathK wrote: You'd be a laya god if you pulled off the t,,,,,, |
SrinathK wrote: >> SrinathK from the "CM Drifting away from Bhakti" - thread ( Gen. Disc.)

If anyone has an issue that the music is not abstract enough, then one can just keep stripping at it until it reaches the highest form of universal abstraction --- silence. :lol: I think the real problem is not with the composed music, it's actually an urge to indulge more in manodharma sangeetham that isn't getting fulfilled to it's heart's content.
I am not anywhere near even to start in the direction of the nirvAna state of abstract silence yet. I am more interested examining the middle ground between hugging the beats and the abstract silence - i.e. "ordered silence" that are bounded by sensible kriyas.

5 and 7 get interesting because of the fact that they have long and shorts ( cinnadu - perisu) - (2+3) , (3+4). You get the Darshan of Ambal and Swamy's pAdams.

Depending on the speed - as kriyas are reduced to the sensible minimum - that affords opportunities for making music around them. Unleash kArvais across them. With two taps "t,,t,,," you get scope for that more.

That works for musicians who are neither kriya agnostic ( like the light-y smootheners) - nor kriya centric (the strictly kalpita musician) - but transcendental enough to acknowledge their presence - still able to make them subtle.

MDR of course does what you mention - pulls off the t,,,,,, - but NOT without help. He has a person of conviction in UKS that is able to sync and aid with his laya.

shankarank
Posts: 3282
Joined: 15 Jun 2009, 07:16
x 3
x 8

#37 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by shankarank »

keerthi wrote: . This Misra Laghu(vu) is the term also used by the DhanammAL descendants to designate the tAla setting of many songs that they sang - including KaruNa jUDu [Sri], taruNamidamma [gauLipantu] and ninnu vinAga [PUrvakalyAni] . Other significant examples are their family heirloom prANasakhuDiTu, the janjUTi jAvaLi; which they sang] and nI mAtalEmAyenu rA- the pUrvakalyANi jAvaLi [both notated in Brindamma’s book JavaLigaL, published by Music Academy].
Prof SRJ - in the year - I think when Sri T.N Krishnan was awarded Sangita Ratnakara in Cleveland ( around 2003 or 2004) - had performed nI mAtalEmAyenu rA in miSra laghu with Sri Mannargudi Easwaran as accompaniment. Ashwin / Rohin his disciples were singing with him. Prof TRS was also in attendance.

SRJ did mention that he learnt this from Brindamma.

I am stating maximum detail so people can use it to locate possible recordings. If anybody have recordings (video/audio) that will help rasikas.

SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#38 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

@keethi, I am certain that karuNa jUDu is in Chatushra Chapu and the recording of Mukta singing nI mAtalEmAyenu rA which I have was in Adi.

I am now beginning to wonder if that was another name for viloma chApu.

keerthi
Posts: 1309
Joined: 12 Oct 2008, 14:10

#39 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by keerthi »

Chatushra Chapu
???


Suguna Varadachari sings the Misra Laghuvu version of the purvakalyANi jAvaLi.
Ritha Rajan discusses the two versions of nI mATalemayenu.

SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#40 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

Technically that's what I think ought to be called -- T,TT |T, TT|T, TT|T,TT|T, -- It's the same beat used in Bhajana Sampradayas. I had to resort to it as when I was trying to expand my repertoire, I keep coming up with "Chapu" listed as the tala when it could be Chatushram, Khandam or Mishram, much to my annoyance.

It was when you mentioned karuNa juDu when I started thinking if this mishra laghuvu is really another name for a viloma chApu as I knew that Brindamma's rendition of it was in chatushra chApu.

Going back to the old description of the Mishra Laghuvu, it sounds very similar to what happens when you sing a song in khaNDa chApu which gives a very chatushram like feel to it, and then realize it can perfectly fit into an Adi tala in khaNDa naDai. I always used to feel that the nadai beats were meant to create a "pseudo-chatushram" feel to make it easier to help count those more complex numbers.

And now that you posted this rendition of nI mATale , I declare that my hunch about what this mishra laghuvu could be was indeed correct ...

It IS viloma chApu all along. :mrgreen: @keerthi, Thank you.

:ugeek:

Ananth
Posts: 131
Joined: 14 Feb 2006, 14:04
x 26

#41 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by Ananth »

Excellent thread, thanks to laya experts here, I have moved some of my "don't know that I don't know" concepts towards "starting to know".

Probably the topic can be renamed as, say chapu talas? Rubato?
In any case, with the current topic name, there is the risk of many rasikas missing it.

SrinathK
Posts: 2274
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10
x 165
x 9

#42 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by SrinathK »

I think it can be renamed as Shyama Sastri Compositions and Chaapu talas

keerthi
Posts: 1309
Joined: 12 Oct 2008, 14:10

#43 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by keerthi »

A minor correction. In an earlier post,I had said -
This Misra Laghu(vu) is the term also used by the DhanammAL descendants to designate the tAla setting of many songs that they sang ....
Other significant examples are their family heirloom prANasakhuDiTu, the janjUTi jAvaLi; which they sang] and nI mAtalEmAyenu rA- the pUrvakalyANi jAvaLi [both notated in Brindamma’s book JavaLigaL, published by Music Academy].
prANasakhuDiTu is given as being in deshAdi in the book, and the pUrvakalyANi jAvaLi is not printed in this volume.

It was a case of faulty memory. However, I can vouch for the two versions of the pUrvakalyANi jAvali from within the family, based on many other sources, including my teacher's pAthantaram.

I am grateful to Ravi(Sri) for pointing me to the error in my post.

sankark
Posts: 1981
Joined: 16 Dec 2008, 09:10
x 98
x 27

#44 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by sankark »

SrinathK wrote:Technically that's what I think ought to be called -- T,TT |T, TT|T, TT|T,TT|T, -- It's the same beat used in Bhajana Sampradayas. I had to resort to it as when I was trying to expand my repertoire, I keep coming up with "Chapu" listed as the tala when it could be Chatushram, Khandam or Mishram, much to my annoyance.
May be whoever notated couldn't identify c/k/m and so just cApu. I thought the convention is that when just written cApu it is m cApu and triputai is t triputai.

A laya/tALa novice question. T,TT - isn't that a fancy c Ekam with one T omitted. Extending, it could also be T,,T|T,,T or T,,,|T,,,.

shankarank
Posts: 3282
Joined: 15 Jun 2009, 07:16
x 3
x 8

#45 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by shankarank »

T,TT is the Usi talam done in Bhajans - the Abhang Marathi tradition does it with one count offset which feels like ,TTT - that is counter intuitive to us deep southerners :lol:. First time I heard it was when a Bank transferee from up in Maharashtra sang in our Bhajan group - very evocative.

That count offset will instead be played by the likes of PMI and PR typically down south - if they had accompanied any veethi Bhajans in Palghat ever.

That is possibly a relic in the Mridangam's memory lane down from Maratha country into Tanjore?

shankarank
Posts: 3282
Joined: 15 Jun 2009, 07:16
x 3
x 8

#46 Re: Triloka Maata Nannu

Post by shankarank »

What the hell is this? :o , a damaged recording - or another cApufication!!! If so what cApu??

https://youtu.be/UC96MoQlSps?t=478 :lol:

Post Reply