Smt Ranjani and Smt Gayatri @ Hickman Hall, Rutgers, NJ

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Post by rshankar »

DISCLAIMER: THIS IS NOT A REVIEW, BUT JUST MY VIEW (well, and some musings as well!). I will leave the technical details to the experts and just present some rasAnubhava.

After nearly a year in NJ, I finally got to attend a live concert. :) Smts. Ranjani and Gayatri treated us to one of their trademark concerts, their singing ably supported and excellently enhanced by Sri HN Bhaskar on the violin and Delhi Sri Sairam on the mrudangam. I found the experience to be somewhat mixed, but enjoyable overall, especially towards the end. Smt. Gayatri announced at the start that they were dedicating this concert to Semmangudi Sri Srinivasa Iyer on the event of his 100th birth anniversary (as they were part of his illustrious SiSya paramparA).

The afternoon started slowly, with many of us fighting the post-lunch torpor that usually besets us on what was sure to be one of the last warm Sundays of this season!

#1 They opened the concert with a varNam in the maNgaLa rAgam, SrI (I think it had the mudra - garbhapurivAsa). It was well rendered, but I did not appreciate the electric spark that was certainly going to be needed to ignite us out of our languor.
#2 The next was a melodiously rendered kEdAram - paramAnanda naTana - of Maharaja Swati Tirunal, with a brief outline preceding it, and swarAs at the pallavi in the last iteration.
#3 was a new one for me - sarasijanAbha sOdari of MD's in nAgagAndhArI
#4 The first alApanA of the concert - hari kAmbhOjI by Smt. Ranjani - followed by entarA nItana of Sri tyAgarAja - embellished with nereval and swaras very nicely for/at the phrase 'sESuDu Sivuniki bhUshuDu lakSmaNA', but the meaning of that caraNa was sacrificed in the process.
#5 A very lovely rendition of Sri Periasami Thooran's sAvEri kriti - murugA, murugA...

Until this point, the concert, while replete in sowkhyam was, IMO lacking in oomph!

#6 A fabulous bharavi AlApana by Smt. Gayatri woke me up fully! I thought that the SSI stamped 'E nAti nOmu phalamO?' would follow, but what followed was a beautiful 'rakSa b(p)eTTarE doraku' - and in the last iteration of the pallavi, a lovely suite of swaras were rendered - towards the end of this set of swaras, Sri Sairam started to play so, so, so sharply - the concert was elevated to a new plane, and the oomph was in! :P And this was carried into the tani that followed.
#7 An extremely lively (and, to me, new) composition of Sri Muttaiah Bhagavatar followed - SaravaNa bhava in paSupatipriya - the ciTTaswaras were delightful, and were delectably rendered.
#8 This was the highlight of the concert for me - RTP in ranjani - awesome AlApana, great tAnam, and the pallavi was superb - 'ranjani kanjadaLa lOcanI brovavammA talli ni' set in tiSra jAti tripuTa tAlam, khaNDa naDai. The pallavi was very emotively rendered by both sisters - Smt. Ranjani's lower pitch, and Smt. Gayatri's thinner and higher pitch at times separate, and together at times, but blending perfectly at all times. A lovely set of swarams in ranjani capped the first segment of the pallavi rendition, and what followed was a ranjani mAla of rAgamAlika swarams - starting with a beautiful SrIranjani by Smt. Ranjani, followed by a very popular janaranjani by Smt Gayatri, a mEgharanjani that floated by on delicate swaras, a manOranjani, followed by a haunting Sivaranjani, topped off with an almost ethereal sumanEsa ranjanI. The pallavi line was appropriately modified with the last 'ni' changed to SrI, jana, mEgha etc. Then, Sri Sairam played a few avartanas (like a micro mini tani), after which Smt. Gayatri sang the (1 Avartana each?) swaras in the rAgas already sung, but now in the reverse order, to end in ranjani, after which the pallavi was repeated and the RTP ended to well deserved, thunderous applause. Even if the cognoscenti find technical flaws in it, IMO, my cup of rasAnubhava was veritably brimming over.
#9 The sisters sang a viruttam (another trademark, in addition to the abhangas they sing) - very nice, but I do not remember the words - did not catch the first rAga, followed by hamsAnandI and ending with jOnpuri - segueing seamlessly into "eppO varuvArO?" of SrI GKB.
#10 An impassioned request to krishNa to come quickly rendered in a very slow pace :P- krishNA nI bEganE bArO in yaman kalyAN. It may have been a misperception on my part, but I felt that Smt. Ranjani (purposely) sang half a beat after Smt. Gayatri giving the feeling of an echo in some places - experts can set me right here, if I have got this one wrong....

After the pallavi, the sisters were deluged with requests - they were the very epitome of grace, as they excused themselves from singing most of the requested songs!
#11 Since the audience seemed to be divided on whether they wanted to hear a new abhanga, or a repeat of 'panDarica bhUta' they decided to indulge us with 2 abahangas - fortunately for me, they sang the newer one first - bOlO viTThala - Smt. Gayatri explained that in this compostion, Sant Tukaram exhorts us to chant, think of, and in general become one with viTThala - he recommends it because, in that state of exalted bliss all earthly sins (like greed, lust and anger), and bondage will disappear. The sisters have tuned this in the hindustani bhaTiyAr. It was rendered with their characteristic flair and impeccable maraThi diction.

At this point, the concert was well into the 4th hour, and I had other engagements/obligations beckoning me and a LONG haul back north to boot, so I had to leave. If anyone else who was fortunate enough to have stayed back can complete the list, I will be curious to know what I missed. But, all in all, it was a very nice experience and I am still enveloped by that lovely, yet indescribable feeling that one gets after attending an uplifting performance.

Sri HN Bhaskar has accompanied the sisters on numerous occasions and the rapport they share is very obvious. He played very well, and very appropriately. I have already expressed my pleasure with Sri Sairam's playing - it was awesome (BTW, although I still remain woefully laya-challenged, I thank our laya-ful members for making me begin to appreciate the rhythm aspects).

Experts can please take stab at a review. (Will be educational for me!)
Last edited by rshankar on 23 Sep 2008, 03:07, edited 1 time in total.

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Post by vasanthakokilam »

rshankar: Thanks for the write up. Wonderful rasAnubhava varNana. Enjoyed reading and partaking in your experience..

vijay
Posts: 2522
Joined: 27 Feb 2006, 16:06

Post by vijay »

Thanks Ravi - you should be attending concerts more often than once a year!

cienu
Posts: 2392
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 11:40

Post by cienu »

rshankar,

What an expert review. It was wonderful reading the same :)

prashant
Posts: 1658
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:01

Post by prashant »

Wonderful review Ravi. I hope you get to hear more live concerts so that we can see more reviews from you!!! :-)

gobilalitha
Posts: 2056
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 07:12

Post by gobilalitha »

Your disclaimer is really a disclaimer. you have given a wonderful , graceful review. What else could be expected from jambawans of the review field, other than what you have so meticulously posted.'?gobilalitha

s_hari
Posts: 872
Joined: 20 May 2007, 18:45

Post by s_hari »

rshankar - nice review.. you pretty much captured all details... please attend more concerts, and keep your (re)views coming..

-hari

jananee
Posts: 272
Joined: 30 Jun 2007, 12:27

Post by jananee »

That was a very nice review shankar...hope to hear more from you !!!! I like your style of writing reviews!

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Post by rshankar »

Thanks for the encouragement - VK/Sri Cienu/Vijay/Prashant/s_hari/Sri gobilalitha (vasiSTar vAyAle?? :P) - and a special thanks to jananee!

When I meant that this was not a true review, I meant it was not in the impeccable style of our other veteran reviewers, who give such intricate details as the eDuppus, the swaras/phrases around which an AlApana is built on, or the swara around which kalpanA swarAs are anchored. I look forward to, and enjoy reading their reviews immensely. But, alas, I can't match them, even if I tried! So, I settled for describing the rasAnubhava, which, although intensely personal, is but an overall gestalt.

As to attending more music concerts, I have been retained for my skills as sArathi for a bunch of dance performances in the next couple of months!
Last edited by rshankar on 22 Sep 2008, 18:29, edited 1 time in total.

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Post by arasi »

relished
ravi's
rasAnubhava varNanA
wish
the 'frequency'
of his concert-going
gets upgraded...

Sathej
Posts: 586
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:23

Post by Sathej »

The Shri Raga Varnam with Garbhapuri Mudra is the standard Adi Tala Varnam Sami Ninne if I remember right.
Sathej

PUNARVASU
Posts: 2498
Joined: 06 Feb 2010, 05:42

Post by PUNARVASU »

rshankar,
the ultimate is what one enjoys;if one can convey it and make the readers enjoy as much as one did,one has done it. And you have done it.
Now we can expect more dance reviews from you-when you do the sArathyam,obviously you will be doing the rasikatvam also.

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Post by rshankar »

Sathej, you are correct.

Punarvasu wrote:Now we can expect more dance reviews from you-when you do the sArathyam,obviously you will be doing the rasikatvam also.
LOL! Yes, you are correct (and thank you!).

Ramaprasad
Posts: 94
Joined: 12 Jun 2006, 08:43

Post by Ramaprasad »

To complete the playlist given by Shankar, Ranjani and Gayatri sang a Tillana before mangalam. It was Poochi Srinivasa Iyengar's Tillana in Paras, a fitting final to a very enjoyable concert.

cmlover
Posts: 11498
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:36

Post by cmlover »

Shankar
You bought into another avocation :) Your inimitable ingenuous style has endeared you to our friends. So from now on less of clinics and more of concerts :)

By the by why are folks so crazy about the paNDarika bhUt ! You should have asked for a Tulsi from the Ramcharit which would have shown that the sisters are equally versatile in khaDi boli as much as in marathi :)

rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Post by rajeshnat »

our bhAi ravi, after hearing a bhairavi ,skipped his most famous dance composition thillAnA , what a pity that his friends had to say bye ravi a bit too early.

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Post by rshankar »

Rajesh,

You just put into words what I was feeling - As I was driving to the concert venue, I was wondering why we hear so few tillAnas from the sisters - and just my luck - I had to leave before they sang one!

BTW, my respect for our reviewers has gone up several fold - because they must all be taking such detailed notes and more than anything else, have this selfless need to share their experience (TAm peTra inbam, ivvayagam peruga - :P). I am not sure I can do it as regularly as these otherwise busy people do! :) But I will try to write about the dance performances I attend.

PUNARVASU
Posts: 2498
Joined: 06 Feb 2010, 05:42

Post by PUNARVASU »

rshankar,
on reading about yor'sArathyam', I remembere this incident which I read somewhere(may not be a fact, only fiction).
It seems, the chaffeur of a famous scientist who used to attend every lecture of his,boasted to him that he also can deliver such lectures.So, the next time the scientist was called to deliver a lecture, tey reversed roles and the chaffeur gave a beautiful talk on the subejct and the scientist(who acted as the chaffeur for the occassion) was in the audience. It was then question time and a member of the audience put a tricky question to the speaker(chaffeur).The scientist ,who was in the audience, thought the cat is out of the bag. But the speaker just looked at the audience and said 'even my chaffeur sitting here will be able to answer you question'' and sat down.:)

cmlover
Posts: 11498
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:36

Post by cmlover »

The story is attributed to Albert Einstein as well as many other celebrities!

fuddyduddy
Posts: 206
Joined: 19 May 2006, 19:45

Post by fuddyduddy »

rshankar - very nice review.
i felt they were very very pleasant to hear to. melody was at its fullest but for the most part, I dint feel the 'oomph' either. they dint make me jump in the chair the way i felt like in last weeks sanjays concert! i guess its a matter of taste. overall i could'nt pinpoint any flaws either!
the renditions in saveri and bhairavi had the traditional touch to it and was rendered very well.
i had more expectations though since they are PSN's students. Especially having heard Master BMK (or Kunnakudi BMK as he is called lately) who seems to have a more traditional touch and more 'math' in his music.

arunk
Posts: 3424
Joined: 07 Feb 2010, 21:41

Post by arunk »

The mridangist is/should-be Delhi Sairam

Arun

bilahari
Posts: 2631
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:02

Post by bilahari »

rshankar, I wish I could articulate myself half as well as you! Keep 'em coming.

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Post by rshankar »

fuddyduddy wrote:rshankar - very nice review.
i felt they were very very pleasant to hear to. melody was at its fullest but for the most part, I dint feel the 'oomph' either. they dint make me jump in the chair the way i felt like in last weeks sanjays concert! i guess its a matter of taste. overall i could'nt pinpoint any flaws either!.
Thanks. Were you able to catch the first rAga of the viruttam?
arunk wrote:The mridangist is/should-be Delhi Sairam

Arun
Arun,
mea culpa. Thanks for pointing that out. I have edited my post to replace 'Sriram' with 'Sairam'!

bilahari wrote:rshankar, I wish I could articulate myself half as well as you! Keep 'em coming.
Bilahari, you are pretty articulate yourself! No need to apologize. :)

newtocm
Posts: 6
Joined: 23 Sep 2008, 07:01

Post by newtocm »

fuddyduddy wrote:
rshankar - very nice review.
i felt they were very very pleasant to hear to. melody was at its fullest but for the most part, I dint feel the 'oomph' either. they dint make me jump in the chair the way i felt like in last weeks sanjays concert! i guess its a matter of taste. overall i could'nt pinpoint any flaws either!.

> Agree that the sisters are more about melody and less like Sanjay and TMK where each song has their unique touch. But still, can't argue the fact (judging by the audience and their reactions) that they have a very good stage presence and know how to connect to the audience. With so many good singers around, my guess is that to get to the top, singers need to have something unique, not just talent. Unfortunate in some ways.

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Post by arasi »

Yes, Bilahari. A good one. You must have been jet-lagged too at that time!

Ravi,
Bilahari is a good singer as well. So is his mother, if I recall correctly the Singapore RasikAs Meet thread...
Your R&G concert review was refreshing. Every single person who writes a review brings his own brand of rasikatvA to it. Among the established ones, many of them know a lot about CM and they have their own way of reporting--Vijay, Rajesh, Bharat and others have different ways of conveying their thoughts about their musical experience. They have their own sense of humor as well.

Rajesh,
Loved your bhairavi take on Ravi.

Yes, hats off to Rasikas team! They take a lot of trouble and include us in their enjoyment of a concert with their write ups. Believe me, it is no easy task. I have tried it a few times and my respect for the lot has grown too after my few attempts at reviewing!.

fuddyduddy
Posts: 206
Joined: 19 May 2006, 19:45

Post by fuddyduddy »

newtocm wrote:With so many good singers around, my guess is that to get to the top, singers need to have something unique, not just talent. Unfortunate in some ways.
i believe that the 'talent' itself is unique and will help bring a person to the top! why try something just to get to the top? it will automatically happen when there is purity in the music and as long as there are rasikas looking for that purity!

arunk
Posts: 3424
Joined: 07 Feb 2010, 21:41

Post by arunk »

ravi - no problem. I am usually not so attentive - it is just that the same troupe performed in Chicago last weekend, and Delhi Sairam and Bhaskar were the judges for a competition :)

btw, nice review !

Arun

Vocalist
Posts: 1030
Joined: 19 Feb 2006, 18:53

Post by Vocalist »

Very nice review - I enjoyed reading it, as well as the other post that said bye-ravi. :)

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Post by arasi »

You mean, by 'RajOsh'? The one who writes with 'jOsh'?

newtocm
Posts: 6
Joined: 23 Sep 2008, 07:01

Post by newtocm »

fuddyduddy wrote:
i believe that the 'talent' itself is unique and will help bring a person to the top! why try something just to get to the top? it will automatically happen when there is purity in the music and as long as there are rasikas looking for that purity!

> I am not disagreeing, just saying that if artistes are looking for commercial success (which since it is their primary careers, maybe a reasonable number are), they need to stand out somehow. It will be great if everyone can be like Sanjay - pure and commercially succesful.

By the way, I am new to this site, how do you post a reply with the original note highlighted automatically like some of you do? Thanks.

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Post by vasanthakokilam »

By the way, I am new to this site, how do you post a reply with the original note highlighted automatically like some of you do?
Use the quote button and then please make sure to edit away the text you do not want to be included in the quote.

Post Reply