Post (or peri) Mortem: Season 2008

Miscellaneous topics on Carnatic music
Post Reply
bilahari
Posts: 2631
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:02

Post by bilahari »

As the season dies down in the new year, let us analyse the high and low points of each of our season experiences (music and even non-music related). It would also be more meaningful if any best/worst lists are supplemented or justified by comments (however brief). I'll go first:

i. Best Concerts
1. Sanjay at Vani Mahal
By far and away the season highlight for me. I will remember this concert for its spectacularly massive outpouring of imagination, especially evidenced by Sanjay and Nagaraj's efforts in the Charukesi RTP, though the Kharaharapriya was excellent as well. I know Sanjay generally does concerts with Varadarajan/ Nagai Muralidharan, but I would love to see him team up with Mysore Nagaraj more often.
2. Vijay Siva at KGS
My first time listening to this artiste and I was blown away by his excellently clean krithi renditions (I'm not a regular follower of DKP/DKJ, so a lot of the songs he rendered were very rare for me), and his bhava-laden music. I have officially become a fan. I will remember his Abhayamba in Kalyani and his superb Dhanyasi for some time to come.
3 (tie): Neyveli Santhanagopalan at MA
What sowkhyam! This is the single most important reason for my fascination with his music (and I have been listening to him right from the start of my CM interest two to three years ago). That Kalyani alapanai filled with imagination yet retaining the bhavam of the raga, the Saveri RTP, his style with Kedaram. His music is so rich in aesthetics.
3 (tie): Malladi Brothers at MA
The Kamboji presentation (Mari Mari Ninne) was just outstanding. The brothers rarely disappoint me. There is bhavam in their music, their enunciation is flawless, they frequently dust off rarer compositions... All their strengths were on display during their MA concert. My first time at the Academy, I now see in hindsight why Vijay and others have kept advocating for the Academy because it is indeed the place where artistes seem to put their best foot forward.

i (b). Forgettable Concert of the Season
TMK at YGP
It was by no means a bad concert, or even average, but there was just very little about this concert (except the rendition of Dakshinamurthi) that I will remember same time next year. Serves me right for missing what seems like an excellent rasikas.org meet at the chamber concert to remain faithful to my meticulously planned schedule I'd rather have died than abandon.

ii. Best Singular Renditions
1. Sanjay's RTP in Charukesi at Vani Mahal
Can I rave much more about this RTP? A lot of reasons added up to my enjoyment of this piece. I had really missed RTP's the first few days of my season and when a full-fledged one hour RTP was sung, I was immediately drawn to it. But less superficially, an RTP is all about displaying an artiste's manodharmam capabilities, and boy did Sanjay and Nagaraj pull out all their tricks. I was literally at the edge of my seat midway through Nagaraj's alapanai. It was amazing stuff. It is interesting that months or years after a concert, I will not remember a piece for its technical content but for the feelings I remember experiencing when the piece was sung. I will always remember the thrill I had listening to this RTP.
2. Mari Mari Ninne by Malladi Brothers at MA
Everything there is to know about Kamboji was rolled out that evening. A majestic performance of a majestic ragam.
3. Mariveragathi by TNK trio at Parthasarathy Swami Sabha
I cannot count the number of times I have heard this krithi by TNK alone, let alone by other artistes, but there is just something extra special about a TNK Marivera. The sowkhyam that carried the alapanai, the soft delicateness of the krithi and the swaras that ensued, all made for a sublime listening experience.
4. Bhairavi Ragam by GJR at MA
I didn't hear much Bhairavi, one of my top three favourite ragas, this season, but GJR more than made up for my disappointment by playing a richly imaginative Bhairavi with a soul stirring mandra sthayi exploration. Even LGJ would've been proud of this alapanai.

ii (b). Forgettable Renditions
Too many to list and I've mostly forgotten them already.

iii. Best Violin Accompaniment
1. Mysore Nagaraj for Sanjay at Vani Mahal
His raga alapanai for Charukesi set off a whole stream of ideas in Sanjay. He was supportive without being intrusive, he remained chaste to Sanjay's ideas while adding an imaginative flourish or two of his own, and was generally just all that an accompanist should be.
2. Padma Shankar for Gayathri V at KGS
I still remember some Dhanyasi touches she used in reproducing GV's sangathis during kalpanaswaras. I heard her three years ago and was really impressed. Now I'm extremely impressed. She really personifies the Lalgudi Bani.
3. Embar Kannan for Malladi Brothers at MA
His strong and full use of the bow I can still visualise and hear as I type this. Razor sharp responses to the brothers and a Kamboji of the highest order. Excellent, excellent stuff.

There were NO ordinary violin accompaniments for me this season.

iv. Best Mrudangam Accompaniment
1. Karaikudi Mani for Hyderabad Brothers at Parthasarathy Swami Sabha
Even Harimau would not grudge KRM of praise for his performance that afternoon. Electrifying stuff and probably produced one of the two best thanis of the season in my books.
2. KV Prasad for TNK Trio at MFAC
What sowkhyam. TNK was more in ARI mode this season, high on energy and a little less on sowkhyam, and KV Prasad was an excellent foil at MFAC, providing delicate accompaniment and playing the sowkhyamest thani I heard all season.
3. Mannargudi Easwaran for NSG at MA
Sowkhyam again. Nothing else can describe his play.

I thought Neyveli Narayanan wasn't all that great for Sowmya at MA, but am laya illiterate and thus will completely refrain from referring to his performance as ordinary. I was most probably mistaken.

Special Recognition for Best Ghatam/ Khanjira Player:
N Amrith on the Khanjira (heard him twice I believe). He plays with so much azhuttham one could even mistake some of his strokes for mrudangam! And he played very appropriately as well, not just banging hard at the khanjira and hoping to get his instrument heard over the mrudangam. BS Purushothaman was also excellent.

v. Congeniality Prize for Most Popular Ragam of the Season
Dhanyasi. Heard it three or four times this season and it still wasn't enough. Outstanding rendition was by Vijay Siva, with Sowmya pulling in second.

v (b). Raga I Missed the Most during the Season
My namesake, Bilahari. Was unfortunate to not even hear one alapanai in the raga. :(

vi. Concerts I Wish I had Attended
1. TMK at MA
After all the brouhaha, I wanted to be there live to hear the RTV.
2. Sanjay at YGP
Haven't heard a nice Saramathi for a whole year (not even on the internet) since TNK's rendition at Raga Sudha last year.
3. Abhishek Raghuram at MA
Did Neelambari live or die? I wanted to be there to call it for myself.

vii. Best Sabha Food (limited choices because I hate Dosai/Vadai/Idli)
MA Ponggal for breakfast

vii (b). Worst Sabha Food
NO FOOD at KGS two days in a row and not even tea one evening.

viii. Best Listening Environment
1. Music Academy by far
Good sound system, adequate view of the stage from most balcony rows, artistes singing their best, OK priced tickets, what more can one ask for?
None of the others impressed

viii (b). Worst Listening Environment
1. Parthasarathy Swami Sabha
Horrible acoustics; music sounds like noise. Only positive is quite good view of the stage from middle rows.
2. KGS
Real let down in so many ways. Can hardly see anything from the back rows, distracting switching on and off of fans.
3. MFAC
More like a noisy kalyANa maNdapam than a kutcheri hall.

ix. Word/ Name of the Season:
Sanjay

vijay
Posts: 2522
Joined: 27 Feb 2006, 16:06

Post by vijay »

Wow that's a comprehensive awards ceremony Bilahari! Let me join in too:

1) Best Concert - Unfair since I have not even heard Vijay Siva yet but I will stick my neck out and pick Sanjay at Academy although it was far from consistent.
2) Best Singular Rendition - Rasa Vilasa in the above concert - Malladi's Charukeshi RTP at BGS comes very close as does Sanjay's own Darbari. I must also mention SRJ's brilliant Abhayama in his lec dem at PSS
3) Violin Accompaniment - Did not really keep track
4) Tani - KRM for Hyd Bros at BVB, Patri for Sanjay at NGS and Trichy Sankaran for Malladis. Unfortunately the only concert if UKS (with OST) I heard was marred by power cuts and I could not enjoy it much.
5) Most heard raga(s) - Thodi and Sankarabharanam...also enjoyed DArbari and Charukeshi although heard both only once
5 b) Least Heard Ragas - As usual, lots of my favourites were missing. Among major ragas, did not hear enough of Kambhoji (only 1) or Bhairavi (2) and Madhyamavati, not at all.
6) Concerts I wish....Malladis singing Mari Mari Ninne, Vijay Siva in general, TMK and OST at Academy (which I heard got the best concert award), Veena concerts
7) Best Sabha Food - I refuse to vote on this one! My vote goes to Marris for best meals (do I hear an uproar!) and Sangeetha on TTK Road for coffe
7 b) Worst Sabha Food - Pretty much all of them this time - no imagination at all - same old idli vada everyday, everywhere - it was a gastronomic disaster...
8) Best listening environment - the Academy but other close contenders include Carnatica and BGS
8b) Worst listening environment - MFAC, no question about it...
9) Would like to add an award for lec dem - Sriram Parasuram at Academy and SRJ at Carnatica. I enjoyed two others immensely - another SRJ and Rithvik Sanyal on Dhrupad - but more for the singing.

Please keep 'em coming guys...

kedharam
Posts: 419
Joined: 28 Sep 2008, 23:07

Post by kedharam »

deleted
Last edited by kedharam on 23 Dec 2009, 15:47, edited 1 time in total.

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Post by vasanthakokilam »

[quote]AththAdi pAvAdai kAththAda, nenju kooththAda"

rajeshnat
Posts: 10123
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Post by rajeshnat »

The sabha concert season is yet not over, I will wait for few more days to post.

mahesh_narayan
Posts: 228
Joined: 22 Aug 2006, 20:51

Post by mahesh_narayan »

How many sangatis did the Malladis have in Mari mari's pallavi? Alathur bros used to sing a lot of sangatis. Was the Malladi version similar?

bilahari
Posts: 2631
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:02

Post by bilahari »

Mahesh, I heard no more than five or six I believe.

kedharam
Posts: 419
Joined: 28 Sep 2008, 23:07

Post by kedharam »

"And arudhi at 'da' of kAthtAda? "

Nice one VK! I guess the ragam is close to kEravAni, from the oscillating note da ma Re, if i recall it correctly.

shadjam
Posts: 202
Joined: 06 Apr 2007, 05:45

Post by shadjam »

kedharam wrote:I guess the ragam is close to kEravAni, from the oscillating note da ma Re, if i recall it correctly.
Not to digress from the main topic but the ragam of this song is lavanthikA according to this source:

http://www.geocities.com/ilaiyaragam/index.html

vijay
Posts: 2522
Joined: 27 Feb 2006, 16:06

Post by vijay »

Thanks Kedharam. Sanjay really has been the flavour of the season since 2006....I request others to join in as well....although Rajesh is right, the season never really ends in Chennai - Rasika Ranjani have started their fest and soon Hamsadhwani will begin theirs. My definition of the season is: Beginning of the Academy's Festival to the first Sunday after Jan 1st (which was yesterday).

coolkarni
Posts: 1729
Joined: 22 Nov 2007, 06:42

Post by coolkarni »

.
Last edited by coolkarni on 29 Nov 2009, 16:14, edited 1 time in total.

coolkapali
Posts: 179
Joined: 03 May 2007, 14:32

Post by coolkapali »

Well...i had a terrific experience this season, where for the first time in my life I stuck to my plans quite diligently. Just mentioning the highlights here...Season started off listening to the Malladis at MFAC....what a Darbar i was treated to....then came Seshu at NCA......heard a nice crisp Saveri Pallavi and the evergreen Enthugupeddala.....Sheshu also made some wise cracks on the stage......there were audio problems and Guruvayoor Dorai was searching for the sound guys and Seshu exclaimed, " Dont bother, they will come only after the concert is over" and then during thani avarthanam when Dorai played for Samam instead of 1/2 edam for Endhukku peddala....Seshu said, " Chamatha Samathukku Vashikkarel", for which Dorai replied, "Enakku avalo Jasthi Kanakku Theriyathu".......hehehe...and then I listened to Hyderabad brothers....and was quite amused at the way Seshachari behaved on stage. Poor Raghavachari was never permitted to sing......but they treated us with a nice pallavi in Hamsavinodhini.....also atended a disappointing show from Sudha at the academy...amongst the youngsters Trchur Brothers sang an amazing RTP in Rag Jog at BGS which I will cherish for a long time...Saketharaman's pallavi at Academy was very pleasing......did not get a chance to listen to Pattabiram pandit.
and now for best concert......for me it was definitely Sanjay at Academy, what a thoroughly enjoyable concert, from the word go, it had me enthralled.....and Thanam singing at its best....will remeber it for a long time to come......Regrets: Missed Vijay Siva at Academy, Pantula Rama who got the award for the best pallavi..OST also. Amongst younsters missed listening to Abhishek, Kunnakudi BMK, Nisha Rajagopal.

Canteen: best was Narada Gana Sabha.............

Now a long wait before the next season.
Last edited by coolkapali on 05 Jan 2009, 16:00, edited 1 time in total.

sarigama
Posts: 2
Joined: 31 Dec 2007, 14:19

Post by sarigama »

I attended few junior concerts as well. Some are really very good. They have good future.


Prasanna Venkataraman - MA
Hyderabad N Subbulakshmi - Narada Gana Sabha
Srirannjani Santhanagopalan -- forgot the sabha

Anyone attended more ?

kedharam
Posts: 419
Joined: 28 Sep 2008, 23:07

Post by kedharam »

Shadjam, thanks a lot for the correction.
Last edited by kedharam on 04 Apr 2009, 21:27, edited 1 time in total.

rbharath
Posts: 2333
Joined: 05 Feb 2010, 10:50

Post by rbharath »

Period taken into consideration: 29th November to 5th January
Number of concerts sampled ~ 50

i. Best Concerts (in no particular order)
Alamelu Mani at Raga Sudha
Mysore Balakrishna at Music Academy
R Vedavalli at Raga Sudha
Rama Ravi at Raga Sudha

ii. Best Singular Renditions (in no particular order)
1. nAgasvaram AlApanai of AbhOgi and a tAnam which followed, with the accompaniment of thavil at Nanganallur Anjaneyar Temple, on 2nd January preceeding the evening deeparadhanai.
2. chAyA ranjani RTP by D Vardhini for Chennai Fine Arts.
3. ravichandrikA AlApanai with niravati sukhadA by Chingleput Ranganathan at Raga Sudha Hall.

ii (b). Forgettable Renditions
many many...

iii. Best Violin Accompaniment (in no particular order)
Vittal Ramamurthy for Rama Ravi & Chingleput Ranganathan
RK Shriram Kumar for R Vedavalli & T K Govinda Rao
(all the above at Raga Sudha)
Ambika Prasad for D Vardhini for Chennai Fine Arts
N C Madhav for Manda Sudharani at Nanganallur Maruthi Bhaktha Samaj

iv. Best Mrudangam Accompaniment
Vellore Ramabadran for Rama Ravi at Nada Inbam

iv (c). Best tani: Guruvayur Dorai & Thirupunitura Radhakrishnan in the concert of Trivandrum Venkataraman at Raga Sudha Hall.

Special Recognition for Best Ghatam/ Khanjira Player:
KV Gopalakrishnan for the tani he played with Shertalai Sivakumar in the concert of Chingleput Ranganathan at Raga Sudha Hall

v. Congeniality Prize for Most Popular Ragam of the Season
pUrvikalyANi - 18 times. i m soon going to define carnatic music at 'pUrvikalyANi'
(accounted only if there was some manOdarmam part attached to the kriti. not included are tukkaDas and the number of times just a kriti in pUrvikalyANi rendered)

v (b). Raga I Missed the Most during the Season
shankarAbharaNam - heard it just twice
bhairavi

vi. Concerts I Wish I had Attended
TNS at Mudhra, for the Ahiri RTP he had sung there.

vi (c). People i wish i had heard atleast once during the season.
Sanjay, TNS, Sowmya, R K Srikantan, Parassala Ponnammal, Nedunuri Krishnamurthy

vii. Best Sabha Food
usili sEvai at Vani Mahal GnanambikA Stall.
ashOka halwa at MFAC canteen

viii. Best Listening Environment
First (tie): Raga Sudha Hall & Music Academy Main Hall (downstairs)
a distant Second: Tattvaloka

viii (b). Worst Listening Environment
MFAC (too noisy), German Hall - IFAS (acoustically not so great)

ix. Word/ Name of the Season:
pUrvikalyANi.


I pretty much ended up at Raga Sudha Hall on many days and enjoyed almost all the concerts there.


I cant take any more of pUrvikalyANi. Wherever i went, pUrvikalyANi chased me and hit me hard.

sbala
Posts: 629
Joined: 30 Jul 2006, 08:56

Post by sbala »

I attended only a few concerts. Anyways, here are my ratings for whatever it's worth.

Best Concerts
1. Sanjay at KGS
2. Neyveli at KGS
3. Shashank at KGS

Best singular renditions
1. Vardhini's pallavi at Gokhale hall
2. Salem Shriram's kalpanaswaras at Naadha Inbam

Best Violin Accompaniment
1. Mysore Manjunath for Sanjay
2. Vittal Ramamurthy for Neyveli

People i wish i had heard atleast once during the season.
Sowmya, Vijay Siva, Nedunuri Krishnamurthy, Kalpagam Swaminathan

Raga overdose: Varali

mohan
Posts: 2808
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 16:52

Post by mohan »

coolkarni wrote: What could have been.....
I could have reserved a few more slots in my schedule for Mohan Ayyar. After All that I owed to him and his site at the beginning of this internet era in CM. At the fag end I can only apologise.
No apologies needed. I too was tied up with so many things that I couldn't make it to many concerts this time!

I enjoyed the Sri OST concert with Sri TKVR and Sri UKS at the Academy a lot and apparently this has been rated as the best Academy concert this season.

Was great meeting so many of you and this will make the rasika.org experience much more realistic in the future for me.

sramaswamy
Posts: 366
Joined: 24 May 2006, 22:29

Post by sramaswamy »

rbharath

Kudos to you for being a rasika of lesser "popular" - if I may use such a term - artistes.

bilahari
Posts: 2631
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:02

Post by bilahari »

Indeed, bharath, your choice of artistes is very interesting and educative!

rbharath
Posts: 2333
Joined: 05 Feb 2010, 10:50

Post by rbharath »

after posting on this thread y'day afternoon, i happen to sit thro' 3 concerts. all of them having shankarAbaraNam as main. :)

And yes, there was another pUrvikalyANi too! :P

bilahari
Posts: 2631
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:02

Post by bilahari »

Incidentally, bharath, is pUrvikalyANi a raga you like? I myself am not a big fan and it would be a nightmare for me to sit through as many renditions as you have! No offense to the ragam.

coolkarni
Posts: 1729
Joined: 22 Nov 2007, 06:42

Post by coolkarni »

.
Last edited by coolkarni on 29 Nov 2009, 16:11, edited 1 time in total.

rbharath
Posts: 2333
Joined: 05 Feb 2010, 10:50

Post by rbharath »

bilahari, i m not a big fan of it either.
had it been bhairavi or bilahari or shankarAbaraNam 20 times, probably i wouldn't have complained :P
well, an age old saying in tamil says 'aLavukku mIrinAl amudamum viDam'. anything beyond a limit is not enjoyable or good...

cool, ;)

rajeshnat
Posts: 10123
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Post by rajeshnat »

Little late post, this 2008-2009 concert season was atleast two notches better than the previous 2 years. Attended atleast 25 to 30 concerts there was just one that was mediocre all the musicians were in fine form.

Misses of the concert season
# Wanted to hear salem shriram ,sandeep narAyanan,sangeetha swaminathan, (actually went to hear her during pongal time at RK swamy's hall , but the concert got cancelled) and also one subjunior artists erode anantharAman, but could not make it .

# did only hear tns and vijayashiva only once and heard GV only in early Dec/Nov 2008.

Dislikes of the concert season
# quite a few sabhas like Academy, ngs and skgs are all selling the tickets in bulk to sponsors , most of the times the seats are empty and hence rasikas like me who decide at the last minute do not get tickets.
Last edited by rajeshnat on 15 Mar 2009, 23:15, edited 1 time in total.

rajeshnat
Posts: 10123
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Post by rajeshnat »

Here is a different take representing the best of best concert :

Best Varnam:
Neyveli santhAnagOpAlan@PSBB (KK Nagar) on Dec 25th,2008 - evari bOdhana - AbhOgi -patnam by NSG was the top pick

best #2 :
maharAjapuram RAmachandran@Music Academy on Dec 22nd ,2008
cAla kallalADu (N,S)- Arabi -T with nerval in "ilalO sarivAralalO" , simply brilliant

best submain:
Sanjay Subrahmanyan at Sri Parthasarathy Swami Sabha - 28/12/2008
niravadhi sukhadA(R S) - ravichandrikA - T, for his long breath controlled sangathis

and

SuryaprakAsh@mudhrA on Dec 08th,2008
The sub main was paahi jagajjanani(R N S) -hamsAnandi- ST with neraval in "saarasakrutanilayE paramasadayE", simply top class the neraval and swaras were just awesome with a tinge of hindustani rAga to start with

best no between submain and main

sikkil gurucharan@kalAkshetra on Dec 23rd,2008
ANandanatana prakAsam (RS,N) -kEdAram - MD
neraval in "Sangeetha vaadhya vinodha thandava"
gurucharan's has a very soothing voice and he sang this kedaram beautifully.

best main number
Tadepally Lokanadha sarma@Kalakruthi on Dec 9th,2008

nAnAti baduku nAtakamu (R N S T)- subhapantuvarAli - AnnamAcharya
neraval in "eguvanE SrI vENkaTESvaruDElika"
Hearing a detailed subhapantuvarAli and a fine neraval where there is only distraction that was SRJ shedding tears during this brilliant rendition in a sabha where there were just 15 of us.

Best Tani and Accompanist support
SuryaprakAsh@mudhrA on Dec 08th,2008
KumbakOnama M R GopinAth in violin , the stunning srimushnam Raja Rao - mridangam and SV ramani in ghatam.Finest team work close to 3 hours , especially the way rAjarao and sv ramani gelled and played the tani, controlled aggression at its best.

best single rAga RTP

paNtula ramA@tattvalokA on Dec 27,2008
6. RTP in shankarAbharanam
pallavi in "nee bhajana shree rAma anudinamu daturA varada jESE vAriki??" , her alAPana and tAnam was stunning

RTP with rAgamAliga pallavi
SuryaprakAsh@mudhrA on Dec 08th,2008
SuryaprakAsh's RTP in revati, pallavi line in "mAmava sadA janani mAnini shri mAthangi" with swaras in revati + behAg+ and that long swaras in kedaragowlai

and
Sanjay Subrahmanyan's concert on Dec 16th at Mudra
Maduvanthi-RTP
Pallavi - Kuzhal inithu YAzh inithu enbAr Mazhalai chol KelA Thavar
Swararagamalia in shivaranjani, priyadarshini, Sindu bairavi and Maduvanthi

Best viruththam
ranjani gAyatri@BGS on Dec 12th,2008
8A. viruththam "ullagellAm UNarNdhu ODarkku ariyavan" - Arabi
+ "thirunAma anjezhuthum" - sAveri + "thirunAma anjezhuthum" - kamAs - thevAram (appar ??)

Best Slokham
rAji gOpAlakrishnan@ParthasArathy swami sabha on Dec 28,2008
8A. slOkham kastUri tilakam lalATaphalakE - kanadA+ hamsAnandi + revati + neelAmbari - Leela sukar

Best tukkada
bangalore shankar@mantras house on Jan 4th 2009
sakala kalai aRuLum shree saraswathiyE nanmaiyum yeLLam tArum nalinAkAnthiyE - saraswati + nalinakANthi + amrithavarshini + Anandabhairavi + kalyAni + bhAgeshri + sAveri + keeravani - T srinivAsan

Concert of the season
For the all round excellence it was
SuryaprakAsh@mudhrA on Dec 08th,2008
KumbakOnama M R GopinAth in violin , the stunning srimushnam Raja Rao - mridangam and SV ramani in ghatam.
Last edited by rajeshnat on 15 Mar 2009, 23:17, edited 1 time in total.

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Post by rshankar »

Great, and detailed post Rajesh...I am impressed that you remember these details nearly 3 months after!!
A very minor correction:
rajeshnat wrote:Pallavi - Kuzhal inithu YAzh inithu enbAr Mazhalai chol KelA Thavar
'kuzhal inidu, yAzh inidu enbAr, mazhalai col/Sol kELAdavar'

Nick H
Posts: 9472
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 02:03

Post by Nick H »

I am impressed that you remember these details nearly 3 months after!!
I am absolutely astonished.

Even with the benefit of a diary it is amazing to be able to single out, with feeling, so many different item.

You really have an amazing brain, Rajesh :)

vijay
Posts: 2522
Joined: 27 Feb 2006, 16:06

Post by vijay »

He has an amazing brain, no doubt... but an amazing diary as well ;-)

I've always felt my sense of propriety stretched a little when Rajesh moves on to the 3rd or 4th page of concert jottings!

bilahari
Posts: 2631
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:02

Post by bilahari »

Given his highly meticulous and astute reviews, I was hardly surprised to read his summation of the season! And what a variety of artistes featured too, and even a prize for best varnam!

rbharath
Posts: 2333
Joined: 05 Feb 2010, 10:50

Post by rbharath »

rajeshnat wrote: best submain:
Sanjay Subrahmanyan at Sri Parthasarathy Swami Sabha - 28/12/2008
niravadhi sukhadA(R S) - ravichandrikA - T, for his long breath controlled sangathis

and

SuryaprakAsh@mudhrA on Dec 08th,2008
The sub main was paahi jagajjanani(R N S) -hamsAnandi- ST with neraval in "saarasakrutanilayE paramasadayE", simply top class the neraval and swaras were just awesome with a tinge of hindustani rAga to start with

ravicandrikA should have been interesting.

and this hamsAnandi kriti, i will never forget. Years ago, at Swamy's Hall (before it was a/c-ed) Sanjay sang it as main during season. Probably 2003 or 2004.

rajeshnat wrote: best main number
Tadepally Lokanadha sarma@Kalakruthi on Dec 9th,2008

nAnAti baduku nAtakamu (R N S T)- subhapantuvarAli - AnnamAcharya
neraval in "eguvanE SrI vENkaTESvaruDElika"
Hearing a detailed subhapantuvarAli and a fine neraval where there is only distraction that was SRJ shedding tears during this brilliant rendition in a sabha where there were just 15 of us.
Wow! nice to see Sri T Lokanatha Sarma being mentioned. a truely underrated artist.

rajeshnat
Posts: 10123
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Post by rajeshnat »

For the record, I did not remember everything and typed it again , though when this post was initially put by bilahari , I roughly chalked out then during Jan 2009 that these numbers were the best . I had referred to all my posts before in the site by giving a search with my name and then posted my long post #25.

Bharath
There is already my review of Tadepalli in concert review section , he is truly 100% musician who is not just underrated but also totally unpretending . Hoping to hear him more...

cienu
Posts: 2392
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 11:40

Post by cienu »

And best Analytical Reviews -

Rajeshnat,bilahari & rbharat :)
Last edited by cienu on 16 Mar 2009, 23:14, edited 1 time in total.

Post Reply