MS Amma & Kulasekara Alwar

Carnatic Musicians
Post Reply
alwar_dasan
Posts: 1
Joined: 25 Mar 2009, 08:42

Post by alwar_dasan »

All:
Does anyone has the recording of Mannu Pugazh kosalai by Kulasekara Alwar?
Bombay Jayashree has sung manu pugazh, but she is missing a few pasurams (If I understood correctly, Alwar, wants us to sing all the 10, not a few or some! Plus, to my knowledge, MS & DK Pattammal has sung and the MS Amma's song is THE best.
If anyone has it can you please post the audio?
Thanks very much,
Regards,
Srini

ksrimech
Posts: 1050
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 04:25

Post by ksrimech »

Smt MS has sung only cediyAy val vinaigal tIrkkum tirumAlE.... and that to it is only by Smt RV (her daughter) voice in most of the recordings we have. I don't think we have heard Smt MS/DKP singing mannupugazh. Smt MS has sung a few pasurams of periyAzhvAr (mudi onRi muvugangaLum padigam-4 pasurams), tonDaraDippoDi AzhvAr (tirumAlai pAsurams-pacchai mAmalai, vanDinam muralum, gangaiyir punidamAya), nammAzhvAr (oodum attInkuzhargkE uyyEn yAn pasuram), thirumazhisai azhvAr (thirucchanda viruttam pAsuram - kaDainda pArkadal kiDandu) and AnDAL (mAlE maNivaNNA). Apart from that we have heard Smt DKP sing a tiruppAnzhvAr pAsuram (AlamAmarattin ilai mEL) and some tiruppAvai pAsurams (kIzhvAnam, tUmaNi mADattu). If you could point out which kulashEkarAzhvAr pAsurams (other than cEdiyAy val vinagal) you are refering to, it would be easier to find. We could also ask Smt RV.

baboosh
Posts: 140
Joined: 12 Aug 2006, 17:34

Post by baboosh »

ksrimech wrote:Smt MS has sung only cediyAy val vinaigal tIrkkum tirumAlE.... and that to it is only by Smt RV (her daughter) voice in most of the recordings we have. I don't think we have heard Smt MS/DKP singing mannupugazh. Smt MS has sung a few pasurams of periyAzhvAr (mudi onRi muvugangaLum padigam-4 pasurams), tonDaraDippoDi AzhvAr (tirumAlai pAsurams-pacchai mAmalai, vanDinam muralum, gangaiyir punidamAya), nammAzhvAr (oodum attInkuzhargkE uyyEn yAn pasuram), thirumazhisai azhvAr (thirucchanda viruttam pAsuram - kaDainda pArkadal kiDandu) and AnDAL (mAlE maNivaNNA). Apart from that we have heard Smt DKP sing a tiruppAnzhvAr pAsuram (AlamAmarattin ilai mEL) and some tiruppAvai pAsurams (kIzhvAnam, tUmaNi mADattu). If you could point out which kulashEkarAzhvAr pAsurams (other than cEdiyAy val vinagal) you are refering to, it would be easier to find. We could also ask Smt RV.
Mannu pughazh was sung by BV Raman and Lakshmanan brothers.Even a commercial recording is available

Post Reply