Suryaprakash-Shreyas-MAS-EMS@PS High School on Sept 05th,200

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Post by rajeshnat »

Suryaprakash - mannargudi shreyas-MAS-EMS@PS High School on Sept 05th,2009
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Laya LaavanyA , the trust started by doyen shri UKS , one of the greatest mrudangam artist has been doing a fanta fabulous job of bringing more and more mrudangam artists to the kutcheri pandal. Few years back I have witnessed where 2 sishyas of UKS ,ammangudi ??narayanan(little old in 20's ;) ) and sudarsan (perhaps a 9th or 10th std then), yesterday it was shreyas who is perhaps a year or two younger than sudarsan, he was more a 14 year old complan boy.

mannargudi V shreyas in mrudangam was accompanied by suryaprakash in vocal, MA sundareswaran in violin and EM Subramaniam in ghatam

Having said that ,there was an intense collaboration by all to bring the best of this shreyas. The collaboration and little assistance was only given at few touch points to shreyas certainly this boy swam most of the time on his own.

1. Each of the other 3 artists had their share of attention to shreyas. The vocalist and violinist played a shade slower (usually both of them pass the baton as quickly as a 4 X 100 m olympic relay) , but never cut short any sangathis so that shreyas plays less.

2. There was a right spacing of songs giving young shreyas the right rest . The ruggedness of varnam in kalyani, minimal alApanai of nAttai with a round of lots of full toss swaras in aadi thAlam. The UKS school's perhaps most favourite krithi in mmgowlai where only neraval was sung giving an ample rounds of quick strokes being rupaka talam, wow I get goose pimples when I hear "jAtharoopa nibhaCelA "neraval and more importantly the rigorous onslaught of strokes just after neraval in that brilliant line "ditijALi vidaLana dInabandhO" . A quick well rounded athanA(dont know that tAlam) gave shreyas an oppurtunity to excel in very fast tempo. Then a first round of rest for shreyas

3. The submain was made more closer to main ,the MV krithi in simm madhyamam gave the mridangist to excel in mishra chApu which I think UKS is the greatest mridangist to play mishra chApu. Shreyas sparkled in both the krithi and swaras. Bringing submain closer to main was a nice move as it gives right spacing.

4. The fast sprint to main was sarasa sAma DhAnA clearly a darling krithi for any one ,shreyas played beautifully incidentally it was a smart move of the vocalist not to sing fast swaras , particularly stopped at few sangathis like hatamu jEsitivi.... that spacing gave an oppurtunity for shreyas to steal more strokes. Then a second round of rest.

5. The main was a big uphill climb, may be the tAlam is just easy as it is aadhibut the krithi is very difficult .This SS krithi and infact all song selections were chosen by UKS and Suryaprakash. This SS krithi starts in samam and shreyas had to watch for lakshyam with both vocalist and violinist ,having mastered for years in lakshanam with UKS. The neraval and swaras were beautifully structured giving lots of oppurtunities for the man of the match shreyas to dazzle. Infact MAS gave sweet returns and EMS decided to jump only at few places but it was mostly shreyas. The krithi post alApana was sung for 25 full minutes.

6. What a thunderous tani it was , this boy played for full 30 minutes ,the first round itself was for 5 minutes , like that it went for atleast 6 rounds, ems kept it very short and then the usual finish back to the krithi, the tani and main was for 55 minutes and there was very sound sound.

7. 40 minutes speech and garlanding , UKS took half of the time to speak and then psn spoke . The garlanding by PSN (for suryaprakash),M Chandrasekaran (for MAS),Srinivasan (mridangist sishya of PMI who is a teacher , he is 80 +, for shreyas) , to top it all MS anantharaman blessed the 4th garland and handed over to PSN who in turn garlanded EMS. In short elders above 75 + blessed this kid a lot and appreciated all the artists.

8. THere was just a 15 to 20 minute tukkada covering the evergreen sindhubhairavi and dhanashri tillana.
Last edited by rajeshnat on 08 Sep 2009, 21:47, edited 1 time in total.

rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Post by rajeshnat »

1. vanajAkshi - kalyANi- aadhi (not ata talam )varnam- poochi ???
2. mahaganapathim (R S) - nAttai -aadhi - MD
3 mins alapana ,1 min violin and 6 minutes of swaram

3. deva deva kalayAmithE(N) - mAyamA layA glowing - roopakam - ST
neraval in "jAtharoopa nibhachEla" for 4 mins
4. anupama gUNAmbhuthi (R) - atAnA -??? -T
3 mins alapanai and 2 mins violin


5. ninnE nammithi(R S) - simmhendra madhyamam - mishra chApu - MV
7 mins alapanai, 4 mins violin and 4 mins swaras
6. sarasa sAma dhAnA - kapi narAyani - deshaadi - T

7A.sarojadhalanEtri (R N S T)- shankarabharanam - aadhi - SS
14 mins alapani , 5 mins violin return
7 mins neraval in "kOri verchina " and 11 minutes of swaram

7B . 30 minutes of tani

8. No thamizh krithis only thamizh speech by UKS and PSN , speech and garland went on for 40 minutes

9. venkatachala nilayam(R) - sindhubhairavi - PD
10.tillAnA - dhanashri - ST
11. pavamana - sowrashtram + madhyamAvati


In short mannArgudi shreyas rocked, nAdham of UKS was always there , just very few shortcomings

1. shreyas gets the sound and nAdham beautifully and Shri UKS has trained him exceptionally well in endurance .But in few krithis the kalapramanam is generally there a lot in pallavi and anupallavi , but just drops slightly in charanam. Nevertheless the violinist and vocalist were aware of that and did a very excellent job. Nevertheless for a 14 year old ,this speed itself was exceptionally high

2.Shri UKS spoke wonderfully but the speech and garlanding was too long .

The 3 artists particularly suryaprakash was praised sky high by both uks and psn , but none of the 3 coartists spoke a single word and thanked and returned the praise to UKS. The collaboration for shreyas was not just with vidwans and vidushis but a battery of sishyas inclusive of rams, also when the
tani was played I was seeing atleast 40% of crowd keeping adhi talam during tani.

Overall the weighty pAdantaram and sangathi weight of suryaprakash was forcing shreyas to excel. There was thunderous applause , in short it was an unanimous mega hit arangetram of shreyas.

Overall all 4 in the stage lent and shared their excel , overall an excel-lent concert for 2 hours and 20 minutes exclusive of 40 mins break.

Note:
------
THere is just lot to write about UKS and PSN and the speech by UKS I will write it later . This thread is for shreyas , dont want to hijack it with UKS references.
Last edited by rajeshnat on 08 Sep 2009, 21:57, edited 1 time in total.

rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Post by rajeshnat »

Just forgot to mention , atleast 40 to 50% of the crowd was below 15 :) . For the first time I felt I was old :rolleyes:

I sat next to a 9 or 10 year old boy,he said he is learning from sir (perhaps he meant UKS), I asked him the rAgam name during sub main, the boy asked his father and they both did not know,in hindsight I thought that was a difficult ragam to know and more importantly for a 9 year old boy to answer even if he know simmhendra madhayamam (phew...) .

Then I asked the main rAgam, this time this boy answered I have only very recently joined and taking classes with sir. ;) . But that boy was keeping talam for almost all songs. :)
Last edited by rajeshnat on 06 Sep 2009, 12:09, edited 1 time in total.

srikant1987
Posts: 2246
Joined: 10 Jun 2007, 12:23

Post by srikant1987 »

His father should've known shankarabharanam, at least! :| :)

abitakucalamba
Posts: 17
Joined: 17 Sep 2006, 04:32

Post by abitakucalamba »

--
Last edited by abitakucalamba on 06 Sep 2009, 14:09, edited 1 time in total.

bilahari
Posts: 2631
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:02

Post by bilahari »

Wow, comprehensive review. Thanks, Rajesh!

srinivasrgvn
Posts: 1013
Joined: 30 Nov 2008, 07:46

Post by srinivasrgvn »

-
Last edited by srinivasrgvn on 28 Dec 2009, 08:28, edited 1 time in total.

srikant1987
Posts: 2246
Joined: 10 Jun 2007, 12:23

Post by srikant1987 »

You could have offset this embarrassment by asking a few more questions, about what his name was, what class he studied, in which school, etc. :)

rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Post by rajeshnat »

srinivasrgvn wrote:Well, the review seems to be a bit of exaggeration, but anyway, you wrote a nice review, as always!
srinivasrgvn,
There was no exaggeration , shreyas indeed played exceptionally well . Could you point out which lines were indeed exagerration in a private mail if you still feel so? .

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Post by sureshvv »

Anupama Gunambudhi feels like khanda chapu to me.

srinivasrgvn
Posts: 1013
Joined: 30 Nov 2008, 07:46

Post by srinivasrgvn »

-
Last edited by srinivasrgvn on 28 Dec 2009, 08:27, edited 1 time in total.

rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Post by rajeshnat »

srinivasrgvn wrote:Well, rajesh! I never expected that you would take the comment this seriously! I just thought this review was a bit of an exaggeration(mind you, a bit!) compared to your usual reviews! That's all! There's nothing to point out individually and send it privately to you. If you felt my comment was hurting, I apologize. Different people have different views, you know.
srinivasrgvn,
Thanks ,no need for apologies in this case, I just wanted to clarify if anything is indeed required. Shreya of your storyline and shreyas of mannargudi are indeed gifted.

srikant1987
Posts: 2246
Joined: 10 Jun 2007, 12:23

Post by srikant1987 »

rajeshnat,

Can you please include MAS's name (the initials would suffice, as he's well-known to most of us) in the title? You can dock off the 2009 if you need space. :)
Last edited by srikant1987 on 07 Sep 2009, 07:40, edited 1 time in total.

ram
Posts: 705
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:48

Post by ram »

rajeshnat wrote: I sat next to a 9 or 10 year old boy,he said he is learning from sir (perhaps he meant UKS), I asked him the rAgam name during sub main, the boy asked his father and they both did not know
rajeshnat wrote:Just forgot to mention , atleast 40 to 50% of the crowd was below 15 :) . For the first time I felt I was old :rolleyes:
Now I know why youngsters abstain from concerts ;) The day is not far when their fathers will also think twice before coming to concerts :)

Just kidding

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Post by vasanthakokilam »

>Now I know why youngsters abstain from concerts ;)

Oh, ram, you beat me to that juicy line ;)

Rajesh reminds me of one of my uncles who used to bother my friends with questions on English grammar. They would turn and go in a different direction if they saw him coming down the street ;)

Nick H
Posts: 9472
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 02:03

Post by Nick H »

I sat next to a little gir who, sadly, had no interest in music at all.

It wasn't too bad; she spent most of the time out of the hall!

The only slight exaggeration of the evening, and it was only slight was the amplification of the mridangam. Perhaps always a temptation for a mridangam arangetram. It was so slight that most people would not have noticed, but for my fussy hearing it took away from the clarity of the mridangam strokes, and put Suryaprakash just a little in the background.
Rajesh reminds me of one of my uncles who used to bother my friends with questions on English grammar.
I used to sometimes meet a man around Mylapore and Royapettah who used to "accost" me with enquiries concerning English grammar and pronunciation. The last time I saw him, he ran up to me in the street, asking if the English ponounced Zebra with a long, or a short, "e". One of your uncles maybe? :) He spoke English with a slightly old-fashioned, but very correct, accent that he had learnt from listening to the BBC in its long-since-gone better days.

Err, I digress...

(as usual).

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Post by vasanthakokilam »

:) That uncle passed away quite a while back but Mylapore/Royapettah area was his hang out. He loved that area, may be he still does not want to let go :lol:

erode14
Posts: 726
Joined: 21 Jan 2007, 21:43

Post by erode14 »

raoyal carpet - karnAtik says...

# Vanajaksha ni anupama (tv) - Vedandagamana - Adi - Mysore Venkatagiriappa
# Vanajaksha ni pai (tv) - Ritigaula - Adi - R.N.Doresvami
# Vanajaksha nikai valachi vacciyunnanura (tv) - Behag - Adi - R.Venugopal
# Vanajaksha ninne kori marulu konnanura (tv) - Ritigaula - Adi - R.N.Doresvami
# Vanajaksha ninne kori valaci vaccitini (tv) - Mandari - Adi - Mysore Vasudevacharya
# Vanajaksha ninne nammiti na mida kripa judara (tv) - Hindustanibehag - Adi - Vinai Kuppier
# Vanajaksha ninne nammiti na mida kripa judara (tv) - Behag - Adi - T.R.Subramaniam
# Vanajaksha ninne nammiyunna vanitapai (pv) - Saveri - K/Ata - Svati Tirunal
# Vanajaksha ninne nammiyunna vanitapai (pv) - Saveri - K/Ata - Vadivelu

and

# Vanajakshi (tv) - Chakravaka - Adi - Patnam Subramania Iyer
# Vanajakshi kamakshi vame shyame (tv) - Janaranjani - Adi - R.Venugopal
# Vanajakshi ni anupama katakshi (tv) - Vedandagamana - Adi - Vina VEnkatagiriappa
# Vanajakshi nikai valachi vachchiyunnanura (tv) - Behag - Adi - R.Venugopal
# Vanajakshi ninne (tv) - Shri - Ata - ?
# Vanajakshi ninne (tv) - Kedaragaula - Ata - M.D.Ramanathan
# Vanajakshi ninne kori valachi vachchiyunnadira (tv) - Kalyani - Ata - Pallavi Gopala Iyer
# Vanajakshi ninne kori valachi yunnadira sami (tv) - Dhanyasi - Adi - Tiruvettiyur Tyagayya
# Vanajakshi ninne korinanu vesata dirchi brova (tv) - Ritigaula - Ata - Vinai Kuppier
# Vanajakshi ninne koritini manasulo (tv) - Mohanakaishiki - K/Triputa - Gurukrupa
# Vanajakshi ninnu juchi chala valachiyunnadira (tv) - Todi - K/Ata - Vinai Kuppier
# Vanajakshi nive gatiyani ninnu (tv) - Varali - C/Ata - Poochi Shrinivasa Iyengar
# Vanajakshiro brihadishude navaddaki rammanave (tv) - Lalita - Adi - Ponniah
# Vanajakshiro i virahamorvane vasu (tv) - Kalyani - Adi - Poochi Shrinivasa Iyengar
# Vanajakshiro i virahamorvane vasu (tv) - Kalyani - Adi - N.Virasami Pillai
# Vanajakshiro na sami rammanave (tv) - Bhairavi - Adi -
# Vanajakshiro vibhuni navaddaki rammanave (tv) - Lalita - Adi - Ponniah Pillai
# Vanajakshiro vibhuni navaddaki rammanave (tv) - Vasanta - Adi - Ponniah Pillai
# Vanajaksi vani sarasaku rammanave (pv) - Shankarabharana - T/Eka - Tanjavur Quartette

Post Reply