Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
Enna_Solven
Posts: 827
Joined: 18 Jan 2008, 02:45

Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by Enna_Solven »

Malladi Sreeramprasad , Malladi Ravikumar
Ganesh Prasad - Violin
Patri Satishkumar - Mridangam
Jones auditorium, St. Edwards University Oct 16, 2010

Duration: ~3 hours 30 minutes

Song list:
1. gajAnanayutam - chakrAvaham (R)
2. neemadi callagA - Ananda bhairavi (R,Ss)
3. gaTTigAnu nanu ceyi - begadA (R)
4. srI vidyAm siva vAma bhAga nilayAm followed by
mAmava meenAkshi - varAli (r) - sub-main
5. kaNNAra kaNDEnE - mukhari (brief R)
6. vara rAgalya - chenchu kAmbhoji
7. pAlinchu kAmakshi - madhyamAvathi (R, admonition, N, S)
neraval at 'rAjamukhi syAmakrishna nuta'
8. heccharikagA rArA - YK
9. RTP-Saraswathi (r,tT with mridangam)
'saraswati namostutE paradEvatE saradindu sama vadanE'
swarams in mOhanam, dhanyasi, Arabhi and hindOlam (S, s, S, s)
10. molari javvanamuna pUvaka-khamas? - I could neither get the words nor the rAgam
11. smariso sarvada hariya - HK
12. takkuvemi-?
13. patiki hArateerE - surutti
devi narayani nomOstutE - madhyamAvathi

(RNST - elder brother, rnst - younger brother)

Let me get this out of my system first. Austin audience is rank bad. We have two CM concerts this fall. Why CM, we don't have any Hindustani concerts, so only 2 Indian classical music concerts. A whopping two concerts! And what do they do? They keep getting up all through the concert, paying no heed either to the other people or to the artists. And the stupid heavy double doors bang shut each time one enters or leaves. They don't even hold it and close it gently. Indians are clueless people, clueless as to what they hold in their hand.

This got so bad that Sreeramprasad stopped Ganesh Prasad from starting violin return after his (SP's) alapana, and said "Please don't get up during alapana or krithi singing. It distracts us. Please change your habit!" Ouch!

Knowing our tendency, they will anyway do it again next concert. I am not talking about elderly people. Everyone knows they cannot sit for long. It is the 0-60 crowd.

Concert:
It was an awesome experience. Both were in full flow and gave a wholesome concert. Patri was loud compared to his usual sensitive playing. I thought the brothers didn't get full support from the violinist. He didn't shadow them or reply them adequately (I recognized it in spite of my meager knowledge); but his solo essays were very nice.

Highlights of the concert were varali sub-main, madhyamavathi main and the RTP. The brothers started the concert with a brisk gajananayutam after a brief alapana by Sreeramprasad. They followed it with neemadi callaga. The first three items were good but they really warmed up during the varAli. Ravikumar's alapana was very touching in the way varAli does. Violin return was equally pleasing. The neraval at 'syAme Sankari' was fantastic. Sreeramprasad's upper sthAyi reaches were mesmerizing and very melodious.

The mukhAri and chenjukAmbhOji pieces followed. I wish they had taken up mukhAri for main. Are there any devi songs in mukhAri? The chitta swarams (?) in vara ragA laya were sung in many delightful variations.

The madhyamAvathi alapana was very soothing. I think SP would have done better had he not been irritated by banging doors. They did neraval at a new place, at rAjamukhi instead of usual kAntamagu pEru. This showed as SP faltered twice. After thani, he joined back with kAntamagu and stopped realizing his mistake :$ Ravikumar continued nonchalantly.

Ravikumar's Saraswathi alApana was excellent. I wonder how he could pack so much into this rare rAgam. Violin return was equally good. I like this rAgam though there are not many songs in it. The intricacies of the pallavi structure are lost on layam-less me. I concentrated on getting/enjoying the ragams in the ragamalika swarams and I think I got them all right this time.

A fine concert. :clap:

rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by rajeshnat »

Enna_Solven wrote: I wish they had taken up mukhAri for main. Are there any devi songs in mukhAri?
Sivakama Sundari Jagadhamba by papanAsam sivan in mukhAri

grsastrigal
Posts: 884
Joined: 27 Dec 2006, 10:52

Re: Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by grsastrigal »

MB duo are always awesome. Taking different ragas and different kritis. If you observe in the last ten concerts, rarely they repeat same ragas or kritis. They plan very well. One of the postitive effects of Gurubhakti which I could see on the occassion of Sri.Nedanuri's DVD release at Petachi Auditorium at Alwarpet a month back.

There are at least a dozen duos singing in various concerts. No one could come near to Malladi Bs at execution, perfection and
devotion which they imbibed from Sri. Nedanuri. I felt bad that they are not here at chennai during Navrathri utsav.

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Re: Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by rshankar »

Enna_Solven - liked both the review and the rant!! You can always hope that with repeated such advice, audience behavior will change - rasari Avat jAt tai sil pai parat nisAn (even mighty stones are etched by the continuous flow of water over them)...
Looks like it was a lovely concert - GRS is correct that they are an awesome duo, and have what appears to be a healthy respect for each other on stage.
#7 - they actually sang the caraNam with the mudra - wow!
#12 - seems like takkuvEmi namaku rAmuDu okkAduNDu varaku - a lovely bhadrAcala rAmadAsa's composition that is sung in at least 2 different rAgas.
rajeshnat wrote:Sivakama Sundari Jagadhamba by papanAsam sivan in mukhAri
Not to be confused with the jaganmOhini kRti of Sri GKB with the same words in the pallavi...

Enna_Solven
Posts: 827
Joined: 18 Jan 2008, 02:45

Re: Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by Enna_Solven »

rshankar,

#7 Yes, they did sing the whole pAlinchu kAmAkshi krithi. I have 14 versions from Ariyakkudi to Sanjay. None of them sang the mudra caraNam.

#12 Yes, it was takkuvEmi manaku by BRD. The brothers sang four caraNams. I couldn't place the rAgam. I have this by BMK. He sings it suryakAntam. I couldn't tell if it was the same rAgam.

rshankar/rajeshnat,
I have many versions of sivakama sundari jagadamba. The longest ones are by OST and Sanjay and they top at 12 minutes. So I thought it is not a krithi suited for main.

The brothers indeed show much mutual respect. In fact the elder brother was looking at his tammudu with admiration during the Saraswathi alApana. I noticed something else too. Sreeramprasad's efforts to bring out the best in him (He does bring out the best) show on his face. Ravi sings effortlessly with a smile on his face! Advantage being the younger one in a musical family? Just watch the elder one practice and absorb.

hamirkalyani123
Posts: 214
Joined: 09 May 2009, 22:29

Re: Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by hamirkalyani123 »

Thank you for the post, Enna_Solven. I have the BMK recording in Suryakantam of Ramadas compositoin "Thakkuvemi". BMK's good old gem.

I am curious about how Malldi brothers sang.. Is it possible to share a recording ? I would love to have the entire concert recording if possible offourse.

Enna_Solven
Posts: 827
Joined: 18 Jan 2008, 02:45

Re: Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by Enna_Solven »

Sorry, I am an ordinary rasika. Don't have access to the recording. Though the organizers recorded the concert, they don't sell it to members.

sivakami
Posts: 261
Joined: 07 Mar 2009, 14:03

Re: Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by sivakami »

"# 10 molari javvanamuna pUvaka-khamas? - I could neither get the words nor the rAgam"
It is the annamayya kriti, "polati javvanAmuna bUvaka pUce".... They sang in Karaharapriya it seems..

#12, takkuvemi manaku must be sowrashtram.
Nedunuri garu has released a CD, Bhadrachala Ramdas Navratna kirtanalu, in which this kriti is in that ragam. In addn to these, he has also included some more newly tuned Bh. Ramadasu kritis . My friend gave me that CD, in which the last one "entha pani chesithivi rAma" in Nadanamakriya is superb!
I was told that they all gather at Bhadrachalam on the Ramadasu Jayanti and sing these navaratna krithis......

Enna_Solven
Posts: 827
Joined: 18 Jan 2008, 02:45

Re: Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by Enna_Solven »

Thanks sivakami.

drohit
Posts: 16
Joined: 04 Aug 2007, 00:34

Re: Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by drohit »

Seems to have been a lovely concert from the review and I feel sorry to have missed it.

It is quite irritating to see audience treat these concerts with no respect to artists or the fellow rasikas.

The organizers need to make a real strong announcement before the concert begins to ask people not to get up mid pieces and not to make their presence felt by banging doors on top of that.

ragam-talam
Posts: 1896
Joined: 28 Sep 2006, 02:15

Re: Malladi Brothers @ Austin, Oct 16, 2010

Post by ragam-talam »

7. pAlinchu kAmakshi - madhyamAvathi (R, admonition, N, S)
R-A-N-S? :)
What were the organisers doing? They should keep a separate area for the transient crowd, close to the doors.
(Better still, outside the hall!)

Post Reply