The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Miscellaneous topics on Carnatic music
Post Reply
KSJaishankar
Posts: 109
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 07:01

The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by KSJaishankar »

Been wondering (tearing my hair out in frustration, actually :) ) for a long time ... why do almost all carnatic musicians, sing / play Sindhu Bhairavi in almost all their concerts? If they feel the need for a light / hindustani type raga towards the ned of the concert, why not include Darbari Kaanada, Malhar, Basant, Bahaar, etc. more often? Why this "koladeri" passion for Sindhu Bhairavi? I mean .. it is as is a pedestrian raga (disclaimer: purely personal taste / bias!), and carnatic musicians don't even handle it so well - a good hindi film music director (of the Shankar-Jaikishen, Naushad variety) does a MUCH better job of it.

The latest example of this was Pantula Rama's concert at Unnati in Bangalore.... a supremely classical concert with a phenomenal Bhairavi and she somehow felt the need to include SB in the thukkada section! Thank god she followed that up with a purely carnatic Athana thillana... I would have hated to walk away at the end of the concert with the SB piece as the final one.

On an every more tongue-in-the-cheek note ... the way the rash of SB is proliferating, soon enough most rasikas will assume that it is a rule to sing SB at the end of a concert.... some day, we will have a discussion wherein the "traditionalists" will be berating some poor performer for not including SB in his / her concert ... "How dare s/he do something like this? I mean, does s/he have no respect for traditions and our classical values?? X(" :D

arasi
Posts: 16877
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by arasi »

Wow! That's 'some' high degree of no tolerance for the rAgA! There are some who love it, others like me who take it or leave it. If it's a great concert, it signals the end, and I'm not happy with it. For a 'so so' concert, it's a good thing!

I agree with you--the rAgA has been over-used in CM concerts as an end (or nearly end) piece, but it has been so for a long time--not a recent development! I don't think it has become an inevitable end piece, as it is in HM concerts.

Seriously, SB has its own charm. As in kadamba strands of flowers, it may not add fragrance, but some color. It's a universal rAgA in that you hear hints of it in various genres of music--this middle eastern import.

Still, there are a few songs in the rAgA which fall flat on my ears ;)

Rsachi
Posts: 5039
Joined: 31 Aug 2009, 13:54

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by Rsachi »

Sir,
Your extreme aversion, to the ubiquity of this Hindustani import in the end section of a CM concert, is akin to my aversion to certain dishes ever present in the dinner buffet these days in a south Indian wedding.
Just goes to show that what began as a lofty, mood- elevating, short but impactful, melodically packed, and poignant raga, introduced by the greats like KVN, has been pedestrianised by perfunctory handling by all CM practitioners of today as another tukkada.
You have sounded the alarm to draw attention to feelingless mechanical mish mash of HMish tukkadas. Even very able musicians are culprit in this regard. And Sindhu Bhairavi would stand out as the best example of this phenomenon.
My solution: sing it if you can, with feeling and conviction, not like 'ok, now that SB'.
Last edited by Rsachi on 17 Aug 2013, 08:05, edited 1 time in total.

arasi
Posts: 16877
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by arasi »

'Ok, now it's SB', to be followed by 'get that envelope, and then--catch that train'!

arasi
Posts: 16877
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by arasi »

'The Tyranny of Sahitya' kept us busy and occupied for a long time, thanks to Jayaram who started it all. He rarely posts now, but we do see him during some seasons. Miss your posts, Jayaram!

sukumar
Posts: 67
Joined: 27 Dec 2012, 11:28

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by sukumar »

My friend said recalling his experience, that In Mysore Palace Concerts, at the end of his concert, Sri. T. R. Mahalingam was flooded with requests to play different pieces. He played Sindhu Bhairavi for 2 minutes. It became the highlight of the concert. :-!

kunthalavarali
Posts: 426
Joined: 03 Mar 2010, 01:30

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by kunthalavarali »

Oh! an amazing ragam immortalized by such greats as MSG, Bismillah Khan, ARI, Karukurichi Arunchalam. Many present day artistes handle the raga equally beautifully.

arasi
Posts: 16877
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by arasi »

What you say is true too.

cmlover
Posts: 11498
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:36

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by cmlover »

ODE To The Death of Sindhubhairavi

O! Sindhubhairavi Bye Bye!
For your demise no tears in our eye
Thou art a b* born out of HM
And many novices today do mayhem
CM'll survive without you in RTP
As we've learned to shun the imported poppy
:(

harimau
Posts: 1819
Joined: 06 Feb 2007, 21:43

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by harimau »

KSJaishankar wrote
If they feel the need for a light / hindustani type raga towards the ned of the concert, why not include Darbari Kaanada, Malhar, Basant, Bahaar, etc. more often?
Musicians don't need suggestions like this from you. [-x

What ragas do you think they sing abhangs in? Anandabhairavi?

And consider the alternative to Sindhubhairavi: Karnaranjani :((

varsha
Posts: 1978
Joined: 24 Aug 2011, 15:06

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by varsha »

and carnatic musicians don't even handle it so well - a good hindi film music director (of the Shankar-Jaikishen, Naushad variety) does a MUCH better job of it.
here is cm musician playing a good hindi number - SB on SB
Could not resist putting up a TRS classic - such perfect diction !!!!!
No offense meant to the OP in the selection of the TRS krithi ... :-!

pattamaa
Posts: 750
Joined: 22 Nov 2009, 10:24

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by pattamaa »

Jaishankar, please do listen to this, and i'm sure you would change your opinion...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-fiLCRWV6Y

venkatakailasam
Posts: 4170
Joined: 07 Feb 2010, 19:16

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by venkatakailasam »

A brilliant RTP of this raga on flute by by Shri. TR Mahalingam...Around half an hour concert..

http://mfi.re/listen/4x5yhmd22dd2dv9/00 ... airavi.mp3

Another feast by Shri KVN..

KVN-Manathirku-Sindhubhairavi-Adhi-Thanjavur_Sankara_Iyer.mp3

http://mfi.re/listen/wd7dhazfd6wqx9x/00 ... a_Iyer.mp3

Rsachi
Posts: 5039
Joined: 31 Aug 2009, 13:54

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by Rsachi »

Mid-80s, KVN sang a Sindhu Bhairavi in Shastri Hall. His raga delineation that day is a highlight of our lives.
He used to render this song superbly and you will find many fecordings in Sangeethapriya:
http://bit.ly/KVNSindhuBhairavi

Varsha, don't know if I saw the link to TRS SB or SB SB.

VKLSM, our posts crossed!

girish_a
Posts: 455
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 13:33

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by girish_a »

How many of you honestly think that Swathi Tirunal's composition "Vishweshwar Darshan Kar" is pure crap? While I do agree that repeated renditions of the same song can get tiring, the suggestion that Sindhu Bhairavi itself is a pedestrian raga is difficult to swallow. It can't be compared to Thodi or Bhairavi, but it has its place in a concert.

That said, I do groan at "Venkatachala Nilayam", for I have heard it so many times that it no longer stirs any emotion in me.

venkatakailasam
Posts: 4170
Joined: 07 Feb 2010, 19:16

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by venkatakailasam »

Post # 7..

Here is a RTP BY SKETHA RAMAN...

http://mfi.re/listen/5p256oyp16ff8wq/00 ... airavi.mp3

varsha
Posts: 1978
Joined: 24 Aug 2011, 15:06

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by varsha »

Varsha, don't know if I saw the link to TRS SB or SB SB.
Sorry
http://archive.org/details/04KaKaroonSa ... huBhairavi

arasi
Posts: 16877
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by arasi »

Girish,
Now that you name names, the first and foremost song which came to mind 'was' viSvEsvar darSan! The 'blah' most in that rAgA for me as well. VenkatAchala nilayam sounded good, many many years ago. This also means that repetition of even a good song becomes monotonous after a while in SB.

Yes, we have some very well-sung SBs by stalwarts and newbies, but when it is mindlessly and mechanically sung (like part of a winding up ritual), we want to switch off).

purush
Posts: 15
Joined: 17 Feb 2011, 06:50

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by purush »

Any one who has had the privilege of listening to a 15 minute RTP of TNS in MA sometime in early 90s in Sindhu Bhairavi would have a story to tell. The raga alapana though short, had some ecstatic moments and to me remains as one of the best listening experiences .

Sreeni Rajarao
Posts: 1290
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 08:19

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by Sreeni Rajarao »

I am not a big fan of the two songs mentioned in Girish's post #15 because of too much repetition.

But, I am a fan of the 2min 48sec clip here!

https://archive.org/details/SindhuBhair ... Kinhal.mp3

KSJaishankar
Posts: 109
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 07:01

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by KSJaishankar »

The OP by the OP (self) was intended to be tongue-in-cheek and provocative :) I am not disputing the fact that the various pieces mentioned by the rasikas are great examples of good SB ... it only goes on to underline my point IMHO - SB, like any other raga, some great renditions, several passable ones and a majority where one asks why?? Because it is rendered so often, the sheer number of the last category is overwhelming.

I have already put in the disclaimer that my taste for SB as such is low, and that is purely my personal preference / bias - I am sure every rasika has some ragas that they really could give a miss, whereas others swear by them!

Anyway - as if to "rile" me further, the Malladi brothers also decided to pay ritual obeisance at the altar of SB yesterday. After an outstanding Kambhoji, it was totally uncalled for :(... it took the saint's sublime harathi kriti in Surutti to purge the distaste!

cmlover
Posts: 11498
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:36

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by cmlover »

WELCOME To The Resurrection of Sindhubhairavi

O! Sindhubhairavi Come Come!
For your return with tears we hum
Thou art a bonny baby born out of HM
And you're the darling always of FM
CM can't survive without you in RTP
As we've learned now we're very happy
:)

arasi
Posts: 16877
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by arasi »

Verse makers can get away with two extreme ideas :)
However, they speak the minds of rasikAs in their disparate ways!

cmlover
Posts: 11498
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:36

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by cmlover »

I was thinking of Kalidasa and Bhoja, the verses
" ATHYA TARA NIRATARA NIRALAMBA SARASWATHI;
PANDITHAHA KANDITHA SARVE BHOJRAJA DIVAM GATHE "

" ATYA TARA SADHA TARA SADALAMBA SARASWATHY
PANDITHA MANDITHA SARVE BHOJ RAJA BHUVAM GATHE "

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by vasanthakokilam »

The OP meant it as a tongue-in-cheek.. OK I see your tyranny of SB and raise you:

You Know You're a CM Elitist When:

10. You snicker at Kurai onrum illai
...
...
...
...
1. You consider Sindhu Bhairavi tyrannical

Others can fill in the 9 through 2
:)

arasi
Posts: 16877
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by arasi »

VK,
You see, endless repetition of a song, even a good song--worse, sung by all and sundry (don't call me a snob for that!) makes us sigh and say 'oh, not again'!

Even the best of songs are not exempt, when they become a craze and performers delight in singing them over and over again...:(

Rsachi
Posts: 5039
Joined: 31 Aug 2009, 13:54

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by Rsachi »

2. You groan, 'oh no not one more Hamsadhwani song on Ganesha'
3. You crave for Nasikabhushani RTP.
4. You croak, 'oh, where art thou, my Mishra Jhampe tani!'
5. You insist that every concert should have a fair mix of pre Trinity and neo composers.
6. You turn up your nose and tell your neighbour no, it is not Shanmughapriya, it is Dharmavati.
7. You have a stomach upset after an Abhang.
8. Your after-dinner conversation features Dwimadhyama ragas.
9. Your phone ring tone features TNRP Todi.
Last edited by Rsachi on 22 Aug 2013, 14:27, edited 2 times in total.

CRama
Posts: 2939
Joined: 18 Nov 2009, 16:58

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by CRama »

This entire arguement of tyranny against Sindubhairavi is sheer waste of time. As rightly pointed out by Arasi, endless handling of same song whatever may be the song is expected to cause boredom in the initial stages of listening. In may case, Vathapi is the classic example. In Kerala, thanks to the Chembai-Yesudas popularity, any concert will start with Vathapi. More so all the KJY concerts I have heard. So, I used to hate that song and soon any piece in Hamsadhwani, will make me uncomfortable in my seat. Similarly, one's preference for any ragam. If somebody takes Kalyani for the main, I will think he should have taken Thodi or Bhairavi for the main. Your arguement of over use aptly applies to Behag. But we can not ban Behag or Sindubhairavi or Kalyani from the concert stage. I also see that as you go on graduating in your appreciation of the music per se, you will enjoy all ragams. I am now able to enjoy all ragams when rendered well. Even at the cost of repetition I will place on record here, I heard three RTPs of Sindubhairavi by TNS and one by TVS in the 80s when such ventures were not common. That showed me the potential of this ragam. TNS also showed its another colour comparing with Bhairavi phrase to phrase in his two raga RTP Bhairavi and Sindubhairavi.

mahavishnu
Posts: 3341
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 21:56

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by mahavishnu »

2. You groan, 'oh no not one more Hamsadhwani song on Ganesha'
3. You crave for Nasikabhushani RTP.
4. You croak, 'oh, where are thou, my Mishra Jhampe tani!'
5. You insist that every concert should have a fair mix of pre Trinity and neo composers.
6. You turn up your nose and tell your neighbour no, it is not Shanmuhgapriya, it is Dharmavati.
7. You have a stomach upset after an Abhang.
8. Your after-dinner conversation features Dwimadhyama ragas.
9. Your phone ring tone features TNRP Todi.
Brilliant!

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by vasanthakokilam »

yes, good ones Sachi. I had a good laugh, especially at number 8 :)

cacm
Posts: 2212
Joined: 08 Apr 2010, 00:07

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by cacm »

[quote="CRama"]This entire arguement of tyranny against Sindubhairavi is sheer waste of time. As rightly pointed out by Arasi, endless handling of same song whatever may be the song is expected to cause boredom in the initial stages of listening. In may case, Vathapi is the classic example. In Kerala, thanks to the Chembai-Yesudas popularity, any concert will start with Vathapi. More so all the KJY concerts I have heard. So, I used to hate that song and soon any piece in Hamsadhwani, will make me uncomfortable in my seat.
I would like to point out that MMI used to sing it all the time & My class,mate S.S.Venkataraman & I used to visit him practically after every concert ofhis to discuss new nuances he attempted. He used to not accept all the great innovative things he executed but instead point out & demonstrate what he attempted & where he failed! Once a young student came to his house-we were students then too- & bluntly asked him why he was singing Vataphi hundreds of times when he knew so many other songs. MMI told him: Thambi, not hundreds but thousands of times. I am trying to see if I can render it ONCE AT LEAST in my life time to the level of perfection the COMPOSER has endowed to the kriti & I am yet to succeed! SSI also used to say that one need not do more than PROPERLY render the trinity's compositions. Mali said that he mostly played Thyagaraja's compositions becuse ONE cannot do more than what Dhikshithar has already embedded in his compositions.
ULTIMATELY it is NOT THE RAGA BUT WHO RENDERS IT that makes it whatever it is.After all the 12 or 22 notes between the two octaves are well defined as well as other nuances for any system of music.....VKV
Last edited by cacm on 23 Aug 2013, 02:43, edited 1 time in total.

arasi
Posts: 16877
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by arasi »

VKV,
A quick comment (I am busy with family at the moment and don't get time to read many posts):

I only want to say that MMI is one of the few exceptions in that we 'waited' for him to sing one of 'his' (ours too?) songs. Never got tired of them. We lived in them with the same spirit with which he sang them, each and every time we listened to him sing vAtApi, sarasa sAma dAna or eppO varuvArO?!

cacm
Posts: 2212
Joined: 08 Apr 2010, 00:07

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by cacm »

Arasi, SO TRUE! Just some one like you recalling our great moments lifts my spirits. VKV

cmlover
Posts: 11498
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:36

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by cmlover »

Oh! Those good old days with MMI/GNB/CVB/TNR/....

Ramasubramanian M.K
Posts: 1226
Joined: 05 May 2009, 08:33

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by Ramasubramanian M.K »

Oh for those halcyon days!! Koi Lauta De mere bete Huey Din!!
PMI used to say by repeating the same song in several concerts after some time you start to find new nuances to the song and start liking it!! --in Tamil he used to say Merugu Erum!!!

cacm
Posts: 2212
Joined: 08 Apr 2010, 00:07

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by cacm »

Absolutely true! VKV

arasi
Posts: 16877
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by arasi »

"chitthiramum kaip pazhakkam, senthamizhum nAp pazhakkam" applied in their cases--the more you paint, the better you get, the more you speak in lovely tamizh (telugu, kannaDa, hindi!), the better you sound :)

CRama
Posts: 2939
Joined: 18 Nov 2009, 16:58

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by CRama »

I fully agree with posts 31 to 37. I have also said that once you mature your rasikathvam, you will enjoy all ragams if they are presented well. Be that is the case, why this attack on Sindubhairavi and why many support for this attack on Sindubhairavi

cacm
Posts: 2212
Joined: 08 Apr 2010, 00:07

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by cacm »

I guess its a free country as they say here in USA and one is free to express whatever their views for any reason whatever! VKV

rajeshnat
Posts: 10144
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by rajeshnat »

CRama wrote:Even at the cost of repetition I will place on record here, I heard three RTPs of Sindubhairavi by TNS and one by TVS in the 80s when such ventures were not common. That showed me the potential of this ragam. TNS also showed its another colour comparing with Bhairavi phrase to phrase in his two raga RTP Bhairavi and Sindubhairavi.
Crama
I have heard the dual bhairavi-sindhubhairavi combo pallavi for sure and also vaguely recollect TVS. You say three rtp's of tns, if possible can you post the other two in the TNS vidwan thread (not here).

Ks jaishankar
On the main topic, most of the tukkadas in general(not all) are generally what I call as time adjustors to nearest hour clock for musicians to for eg clock has to move from 08:53 to 09:00 and in general sindhubhairavi takes a lions share of those (krithis especially manadirkku ugandadhu and venkatachala nilayam are of those types ) prior to camphorous perumale(thirruppugazh) or thrillnana .

I have heard two single raga rtp (Not multi raga)of sindhubhairavi- one in annanagar and other in NGS of abhishek raghuram, some day some time if you get access do listen to it and then revisit this thread with those takeaways.

varsha
Posts: 1978
Joined: 24 Aug 2011, 15:06

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by varsha »

All this talk of tyranny brings to mind , a beautiful evening in Krishna Gana Sabha , a few years ago.
ajoy Chakraborthy had started his concert after a big ticket CM concert and yet there was an exodus as he started .
More started to leave as Charukesi unfolded .
By the time he had come to the end , we were only twenty left . As we mulled over the thought he might have been disappointed , he asked his accompanist to lend him the harmonium . And started and playing (HM) Bhairavi
This bit of gold dust is here
https://archive.org/details/AjoyChakrab ... amBhairavi
One of the finest Expositions of this rAga .
I knew that he had given a concert in Pakisthan with Bhairavi as the main and the lighter stuff in Malkauns , Yaman and Kedar - just too prove a point .
But this was a magical evening .
One of my Gurus in rasikathvam would always say : You want to know the difference between hm and cm ? in cm one can be technically correct but aesthetically wrong.In hm it does not work that way . If you are aesthetically wrong , there is no way the artist can be right .
Ajoy treated us to something very special that evening , mimicking a mullah saying prayers ( Irani bhairavi ) and sometimes a church choir too.
He made SB look like a raga with many possibilities
Last edited by varsha on 23 Aug 2013, 11:32, edited 1 time in total.

Rsachi
Posts: 5039
Joined: 31 Aug 2009, 13:54

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by Rsachi »

Varsha,
What a fine story and post,
Yes, I also think that SB has immense emotive depth and possibilities, and that is why as Bhairavi it holds the pride of place in HM.

Once I was a guest at a lovely home of a famous cardiologist in NJ. The sardarini lady cook told me she would make her special muLi paratha for breakfast. She put in the care, love and recipe of a great North Indian sensibility and its result was unforgettable.

I do read that parathas are the rage these days in Madurai but doctors warn of its bad effects.

" No same Paratha. No same SB. "

Suji Ram
Posts: 1529
Joined: 09 Feb 2006, 00:04

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by Suji Ram »

I heard Abhishek Raghuram present a beautiful Sindhu Bhairavi- "Bhavani" for 20+ minutes- just vocal and violin and then followed by mridangam. Was just beautiful.
here's a small version of the same- but in HM Bhairavi and CM Bhairavi mix.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mkhe_NYWo2k

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by vasanthakokilam »

Thanks Suji for the link. Very nice to hear Abhishek dealing with both ragas.

These two ragas are quite different of course. Is there an explanation as to why they are called the same. I recall the discussion with SangeetRasik long time back about Adana vs Atana. Though the two do not sound the same, he was putting forth the thesis that Atana can be traced back to Adana. That required some re-orienting of the default CM thinking of Syntax ( Aro/Ava ) based relationship of ragas. I am invoking it to see if there is such a case can be made for these two ragas or the name similarity is just accidental. ( I have the same question about Thodi as well, why they are named the same when they have such vastly different aesthetics. Incidentally, SB and CM Thodi seem to be related, one can cast SB as a lighter version of CM thodi in the sense if you play thodi in a lighter way it sounds like SB but that does not mean that is all SB is about .)

The HM Bhairavi has documented folk connections, the songs of the wandering camel herders of Rajasthan is pretty much SB. And CM bhairavi also has some folk connections ( like the kummi pAttu ) but not as widespread. Just wondering if they have some common origins in the common people's music before they got refined and made into the classical form as we know them now.

Lakshman
Posts: 14213
Joined: 10 Feb 2010, 18:52

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by Lakshman »

The scales of CM sindhubhairavi (mELA 10) are given as: (1) MPDNDSRGM/GRSNDPMGM (2) MPDNSRGM/GRSNDPMGM
(3) MPDNSRGM/GRSNDPMG
HM bhairavi uses all the 12 notes of the octave.
HM aDANA, derived from asAvri thAT (naTabhairavi) has the following scale: SRMPDNS/SDNPMPGMRS
CM aThANA (mELA 29) scale: SRMPNS/SNDPMGRS

varsha
Posts: 1978
Joined: 24 Aug 2011, 15:06

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by varsha »

https://archive.org/details/BhairaviThu ... halathMori

Here are some andidotes for getting over a poor sindhu bhairavi . The listener should be able to resume normal concert experience within 24 hours .
Severe cases can use the tnk-bale khan-uks-yavagal potion concocted milesaway from a metro.
Listeners with no symptoms should be careful in listening to these . can induce a mood of pathos - like pining fora lover who has just crossed the sarhad ( boundary ) even if it is just the boundaries of the house .
Then it is better to stay with this iqbal bano track and not graduate to siddeswari devi.
One can also listen to the magic of a MSG OR N Rajam , again in settings far away from a metro
There is a dainty track from a vidwan member too , lest he concludes that many dont like SB and stops playing it :)
For the devoted who break into dance on hearing SB there is a Vinayak Torvi classic.
For the rasika looking for odd and curious angle - 180 degrees from cliched thoughts , there is a track from a concert by that genial Afghan - Sarahang
Sit back and enjoy.
Been inspired by RSachis methods of posting . They have have left me tired today :-!
Last edited by varsha on 25 Aug 2013, 16:40, edited 1 time in total.

venkatakailasam
Posts: 4170
Joined: 07 Feb 2010, 19:16

Re: The "tyranny" of Sindhu Bhairavi!

Post by venkatakailasam »

Can anybody post an Obituary for SB even aftr hearing this one.....

Pt. Ravi Shankar & Pt. Kumar Bose - Raga Sindhi Bhairavi....

" t is simply awesome. Everytim i listen to Pt. Kumar Bose, he takes me on away on a pleasant drive and

everytime I listen to Pt. Ravi Shankar he takes me on a flight.

And this combination of theirs took me to a voyage out of space somewhere else.

They are indeed a gift to mankind which all of us should cherish. "


Listen it here..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V7NisVEE0oM

Post Reply