Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
mahavishnu
Posts: 3341
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 21:56

Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by mahavishnu »

Smt Pantula Rama - vocal
Sri MSN Murthy - violin
Sri Patri Satish Kumar - mridangam

about 3 hours.

1. palukavEmi nA deivamA - poornachandrika - T
2. heccarikagA rA rA- yadukula kambhOji - T
3. chentanE sadA - kuntalavarALi - T (S)
4. ardhanAreeswaram - kumudakriyA - MD (AS)
5. pArvati ninnu - kalgaDA - SS
6. vidamu sEyavE - KharaharapriyA - T (ANS)
7. RTP mOhanam - tisra jhampa Sankirna nadai (ATNST)
srirangapatE chaturangapatE kasturirangapatE / sripatE sArangapatE sEshasayana (sri) rAgamAlika swarams in nAyaki, hamIr kalyAni, brindAvana sArangA
8. marulu konna dIra - senjurutti - jAvaLi
9. madhurAshtakam (brief) - sindhubhairavi
+ pasyati disi disi (jayadEvA)
10. tillAna - atANa - NC KrishnamAcharyulu
11. nI nAma rUpamulaku - magaLam - sowrAshtram

I was simply blown away by the music of Pantula Rama. She was extraordinary today, not just because she performed a technically perfect and amazing concert. But she did so with the poise, composure, grace and elegance that only comes with someone that is extremely comfortable in their own skin. From her countenance to couture to the dignity of her presence on stage. No frills, just pure music. There is a "measured ease" about her, a term that I use to refer to someone that seems calm and unhurried even when they are rushing to catch the last bus. Don't get me wrong, there is a lot of complexity and vyavahAram in her music. But she is breaks it down to make it appear facile.

I enjoyed the briskness with which she began on palukavEmi. Her telugu diction is impeccable and her sAhitya suddham is praiseworthy. After a soulful and gentle heccarika, she changed the pace with the joyful steps and jumps of kuntalavarALi. Rama's alapanai of kumudakriyA had notes of melancholy, although Murthy's return captured the same spirit, his response sounded more like the dark notes of the minor scale. I wonder if Murthy has any training in W. Classical music. There were many elements of his bowing and note grouping patterns that seemed like someone with equal felicity in Stravinsky/Schumann as with the music of the east Godavari.

I wish Rama chose a more spritely piece after kumudakriya; I am not a huge fan of kalgaDA or pArvati ninnu. But by that time, I was so surprisingly taken by the music that I was lapping it all up. I am so used to hearing Semmangudi and his several generations of followers treat karaharapriyA, that it was very interesting to see Rama's refreshing expressions in this rAgam. And full points to her for her choice of vidamu seyavE. No one sings this anymore! And this is not my selective sampling. The last time I heard someone sing this was Prof. S. Ramanathan!

The RTP was brilliant. Rama handled a very complex pallavi in tisra jhampai (sankirna nadai) with considerable repose. First of all, sankIrna nadai is hard for most people to just keep tALam to, but she handled it like it was a ripe banana; doing trikAlam, stretching and folding the pallavi line (composed by MSN Murthy) as its prosody of the melodic line fell in with the 9:4 metric structure.

But despite all I have said about Rama and her great music, the real star of the day for me was Patri Satish Kumar. What a wizard! He even looks like he just stepped out Hogwart's school. His energy and spontaneity make him one of the most desirable accompanists of today.

Despite the intricacies that he was serving up, the concert had all the placidity and gentleness; almost going to show that rhythmic complexity and musical sowkhyam are not orthogonal dimensions. They can co-exist. And they can get along famously!

Patri created perfect gaps for himself to display his skill. He anticipated sangatis with great skill and when playing for sahityA, he embellished them with a lot of creative energy and perfect use of thoppi. His tirmanams had such a gorgeous sense of symmetry about them that it was hard to be believe that much of it is improvised.

Patri's tani in sankIrna nadai was a class apart. It is hard to get a sense of his vidwat as a laya vidwAn, as his accompaniment is very tabla-esque and he makes the valanthalai/thoppi balance look so simple. But today he played a keezh kAla sankIrnam of the kind not attempted by any of today's mridangists; something that would place him in the line-up of all time greats. Since the generation of TS/UKS/PR and their gurus, I have not heard many attempt keezh kAla sankirnam as a matter of course. Today, Patri was handed a sankIrna nadai tani and he rose to the occasion. Patri's playing represents a paradigm shift in modern mridangam playing.

Rama ended with some beautiful pieces as tail enders. The tillAna by NCK was especially lovely. And as is now her trademark, she sang the mangalam with all the charaNams, except ironically for prahlAda nAradAdi bhaktulu pogaDakuNTE :)

A top shelf concert by a very scholarly artiste with the finest taste and a refined sense of aesthetics, with very talented accompanists who more than supported her today.

:namaste: This ends a wonderful and nourishing music-filled weekend for me. Feeling refreshed. And you?

Sindhuja
Posts: 162
Joined: 31 Mar 2010, 11:11

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by Sindhuja »

Couldn't agree more. No fuss, no frills, no maniacal handwaving (pun intended) even during a sankeerna nadai, a mandara sthayi voice to die for, and a demeanor so pleasantly calm, you wonder if they don't make them like her anymore - such genuineness, Pantula Rama!
Patri was brilliant but I thought the mridangam sound could have been a tad softer.

rajeshnat
Posts: 10123
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by rajeshnat »

mahavishnu wrote: 6. vidamu sEyavE - KharaharapriyA - T (ANS)
...
I am so used to hearing Semmangudi and his several generations of followers treat karaharapriyA, that it was very interesting to see Rama's refreshing expressions in this rAgam. And full points to her for her choice of vidamu seyavE. No one sings this anymore! And this is not my selective sampling. The last time I heard someone sing this was Prof. S. Ramanathan!
Mahavishnu,
IIRC This krithi has not found that much of takers from the belt of Tanjore / Palakkad /Mysore based musicians . Voleti used to render this exceptionally well and I am assuming Pantual Rama has taken it from there. This krithi is more found more with musicians from vizianagaram belt is my best guess(I may be wrong).

Sindhuja - You have to move to San Diego or Toronto - Mahavishnu and sindhuja in just one place just does not make sense for reviewers spread. I could not agree with your - couldn't agree more reviews.

Rasikapriya2013
Posts: 146
Joined: 13 Dec 2013, 22:23

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by Rasikapriya2013 »

I do not know whom to vote for, the concert or the connoisseur !
Loved reading both your reviews. Thank you :)

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by arasi »

My morning begins beautifully.

An expressive tree of dancers signifying the value of a family/community greeted me on stepping into Rasikas.org, and then, this review!

Mahavishnu,

Your review is one which matches the elegance and substance of an artiste and her ensemble. A fine poet singing the praise of an exemplary ruler!

I don't want to get carried away, but Panthula Rama's singing is for pAmarAs (newbies), in-betweens like me, and refined and so-well-informed rasikAs like you alike.

I wanted to quote you here and there, but gave up on that. Everything you have written is worthy of that :)

She is one elegant lady with depth of knowledge and who is naturally given to elegant presentation as well. When I say her name, she comes as a pair with an equally proficient violinist (vocalist too) husband. They are an asset together.

Patri has always appealed to me (and your writing is a dossier for laya terms and techniques!).

Wishing them once again, a grand tour in the US.

Are we happy you are now in the busy CM center of CM in north america! Hope the work load comes down and you take in more concerts...

Sindhuja,
Our no nonsense man who calls a spade a spade and is a super rasikA, Rajesh said it. Your reviews are also eagerly awaited :)

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by rshankar »

Ramesh - may your grant get such expressive, erudite, and lovely reviews! You seem to have the perfect ending to a protracted grant-writing process!
Smt. Rama's music is awesome, and I personally have to thank Kulkarniji for introducing me to a pair of incredible musicians from AP - Smt. Rama and Smt. Sudha Rani (IIRC, they have performed together on a wonderful recording of the geya nATakam, prahlAda caritamu).
And Sri Murthy is Smt. Rama's husband, right?

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by arasi »

Ravi,
Didn't you see meenaakshi's review and 'wow' photographs of the couple, Patri and our man :) and his mate in her concert review at the end?

CRama
Posts: 2939
Joined: 18 Nov 2009, 16:58

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by CRama »

Thanks for your scholarly review, Mahavishnu.
Vidamu seyave- TNS used to sing this frequently- but always as a filler only. I have wondered why he is treating this majestic song as a filler.

manisubramaniyan
Posts: 58
Joined: 10 Apr 2009, 23:28

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by manisubramaniyan »

Eloquent and erudite review; thanks Mahavishnu.

Here are a few photos taken at the concert: https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set ... 543&type=3

Regards

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by rshankar »

Beautiful pictures...
Yes, Arasi...I do remember the pictures from the South Bebd concert!

Sindhuja
Posts: 162
Joined: 31 Mar 2010, 11:11

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by Sindhuja »

However cliched this might sound, I think she is a true example of an artist who becomes invisible in her art. I could see no Pantula Rama on stage - only her pristine music. I wonder how she manages that.
Thanks rajeshnat, rasikapriya, and arasi :) But as long as I'm in the bay area, I will only follow the master reviewer :)

mahavishnu
Posts: 3341
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 21:56

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by mahavishnu »

Sindhuja: Pity I didn't get to see you yesterday. Would have been nice to say hello!
I look forward to hearing your thoughts on these musical events, as much as Rajesh and Arasi do.
rshankar wrote:Ramesh - may your grant get such expressive, erudite, and lovely reviews!
Ravi: From your mouth to the NIH reviewers's ears!
And thank you all for your kind words and comments.

Sindhuja
Posts: 162
Joined: 31 Mar 2010, 11:11

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by Sindhuja »

Yes - I was in one of the last rows. I will be there for the big one on 26th :) Hope to see you then.
And your review echoes almost all my thoughts - and does so wonderfully well. So not much to add here...

harimau
Posts: 1819
Joined: 06 Feb 2007, 21:43

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by harimau »

rshankar wrote:
Smt. Rama's music is awesome, and I personally have to thank Kulkarniji for introducing me to a pair of incredible musicians from AP - Smt. Rama and Smt. Sudha Rani (IIRC, they have performed together on a wonderful recording of the geya nATakam, prahlAda caritamu).
And Sri Murthy is Smt. Rama's husband, right?
Sri MSN Murthy is indeed Smt Pantula Rama's husband.

He is also a vocalist and Smt Rama is an accomplished violinist too. A year ago, there was a concert in Chennai with Sri Murthy singing and Smt Rama accompanying him on the violin.

As to excellent musicians, Andhra has produced quite a few who are completely blacklisted by Chennai sabhas. A friend of mine who spent his formative years in Andhra listening to such singers dismisses the current crop of abhang-flingers as "hysterical women", a quite appropriate description considering the banshee-like wailing that these abhangs evoke in the singers.

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by arasi »

When abhangists sing...
'bhang' hit as if, the audience swing
Singing is so action-packed that
Listening seems more sedate--

Music can be serene, actions held back
Audience too, placid and pleased
'pankthA' and pleasing is Panthula RamA
'pathi sahita, pANDitya sangIthamE' :)

tanapp
Posts: 81
Joined: 30 Mar 2010, 08:04

Re: Pantula Rama @ San Jose, CA Sankritilaya 5, Oct 2014

Post by tanapp »

As elegant the concert and Music made, so is the review by mahavishnu. What pleasure!

Have been lying low on the concert scene here for sometime. Hope to catch a few in the coming weeks.

Post Reply