Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
kedharam
Posts: 419
Joined: 28 Sep 2008, 23:07

Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by kedharam »

Sanjay Subrahmanyan
S. Varadarajan
Neyveli B. Venkatesh

maLavi – ninnekori, KSK
Kamas – sujana jeevana, T, S
Abhogi - Maneyolagado Govinda, R, PD
Varali – ETi janmamidi, N@ sATi lEni mArakOTi lAvaNyuni , T
Anandabhairavi – poomEl vaLarum annayE, mazhavai chidambara bharathi
Shankarabharanam – sundarEshwaraya namasthE :), MD, R, S
Thani
Begada – thandhadukkum neer vandadukkum, Papavinasa Mudali
RTP
Brindavanasaranga, kanda triputa
UNmai arindhavar unnai gaNipArO mAyayE mAyayE, Bharathi
mAnd – ramanai bhajithAl, PS
sri venugOpAla – Kurinji, MD
orumaiyudan ninadhu sung as virutham – karaharapriya, sindhu bhairavi, mand – Ramalinga swami
orumayudan - kapi
paninyin vinthuli - thirupugazh

Just have to share my thoughts :)

The concert was a magisterial study of varied composers, highlighting Sanjay’s diverse repertory.

NinnE kOri in malavi, a KSK rarity was the concert opener.
With his voice in total command of the raga’s notes, abhogi came with a musician’s insight reflecting it’s nocturnal hues and Varadarajan brought out filigree details in his assured reply. Then the outpourings of anguish came in the form of PD’s Maneyolagado Govinda interspersing pensive lyricism with cadence and conveying the composer’s idioms.

Then Sanjay explored the turbulent throes of longing in Thyagaraja’s ETi janmamidi, with neraval at 'sATi lEni mArakOTi lAvaNyuni' by bending and interpreting it with lyrical pliancy, with melody and pathos bleeding into each other in the refrain making the composer’s despondent plea authentic with Varadarajan and Venkatesh responding to every tug and pull of his phrases with nuanced expressivity.

After the wrenching varali, came the unnervingly bucolic piece of Mazhavai chidambara bharathi’s ‘poomEl vaLarUm annayE’ with a hardy gait with Sanjay reveling in it’s folksy idiom...

Sanjay shaped shankarabharanam with expressive depth and meditative dignity hooking listeners to every phrase and inflection and Varadarajan spun the melody with lucidity.
As I was dreading the usual suspects in shankarabharanam and fingers crossed for Anai Ayya’s mAnam vaitharuL, Sanjay embarked on the unjustly overlooked work, the MD marvel, the SK/Sanjay classic, kindling a sense of nostalgia. SundarEshwarAya namasthE - taken at a stately pace, emphasizing its reflective lyricism and the teeming rhythmic patterns revealing MD gravity making the most revered of works feel new all over again followed by swarams with swinging bursts of energy. And it was enhanced by the musicianship of Varadarajan and Venkatesh balancing individual virtuosity with an air of democratic spirit followed by Venkatesh’s thani with rhythmic precision and tonal subtlety eliciting cheers.

RTP –
With his voice filling out and allowing the music to build inexorably in sound and intensity as the magisterial elegance of brindavana saranga came through well matched by the intelligent craftsmanship of Varadarajan.
Then he organically built up the incisive thanam with premeditated care and careful accretions of intensity. It unfolded fading from an enigmatic whisper to bursts of soaring intensity and Varadarajan recreated his interpretive ideas in depth. Bharathi’s poignantly poetic outpouring, “UNmai arindhavar unnai gaNippArO mAyayE mAyayE” set in kanda triputa rolled exploring the potential lying within by hitting the technical buttons in teasing out the rhythmic undercurrents in the wordplay as the improvisations became conversations between them. Then he created an evocative tapestry by languidly unfolding sahana, huseni, sama and mand and Varadarajan and Venkatesh helped these contemplative characteristics to unfold with firm allegiance to rhythm ending the RTP on an exciting note. Followed by the ruminative account of ‘Orumaiyudan ninadhu’ by melding the mythic and pathos with an evangelical fervor. You have to have the Mylapore blood to sing this composition with such plangent vigor, I think.

The team reached the finish line with the thirupugazh bringing the concert to a close.
Last edited by kedharam on 27 Apr 2015, 02:36, edited 6 times in total.

Purist
Posts: 431
Joined: 13 May 2008, 16:55

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by Purist »

I am in a fix, whether to savour 'kedharam's ' review or dwell on Sanjay's exploration . ;)

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by arasi »

Purist, :)
Here at Rasikas.org, we have heard fans rave about the music they hear many times. However justified or not their praises, they are still worthwhile to read because music which is presented on the stage has to be appreciated besides being dissected by the audience.

In Kedharam's glowing reviews, we see something very different. If the vidvAn or vidUshi presented a concert with excellence in mind, delivering the goods in the best possible way, weaving their hard work into every phrase and doing it all intelligently, then there are those among us who know and feel that it should be spoken of and shared .

Sanjay has worked hard and continues to do so on his talents and on what he has inherited from the family and has gained from his gurus. With all his intelligence and his intellectual approach too, bhAvA is never shortchanged by him. Every time folks criticize him about his sometimes intelligible words, I wonder--would they rather have the words ringing in their minds without the kind of rAga bhAvam and lyrical bhAvam one gets from listening to Sanjay?

There is no perfect artiste (and the one who knows it and works on his craft is the one to be commended). There have not been perfect artistes in the past either. The strove for perfection, the great ones (today, we celebrate them).

The music scene has changed so much, and we have new young musicians who are making their mark. CM is not only alive and well, it is growing and glowing in health. I hear many of them, seasoned artistes too, picking songs from Sanjay's repertoire (which is vast, and is still expanding). Credit goes to him for that.

As a child, pardon me for that, I thought the great SS was nasal and boring (didn't appeal to me--now, don't get at my throat for that!). I realized later, how silly a child I was in my rasanai, of course. I am tired sometimes of folks not acknowledging the merit of what they have at hand (they can't shut up about the greatness of a musician who is gone :(

Just because we have some excellent artistes today doesn't mean we have to take them for granted and have to wait to heap praise on them once they leave us...

Kedharam,
Seems as though you are not going to follow the master to the rest of his concerts :( Well, it was difficult enough to be present at each of his concerts so far, and that was admirable (practically speaking, tough!). How we love your reviews! They are a study in how one can also emotionally give expression to the rasA in the music we hear.I bet, admirers of Sanjay's music everywhere empathize with all that you say. That apart, many of us like the lyrical quality of your expression, a definite sign of a true rasikA. Thanks :)

Other reviewers, please continue from Seattle and from the coast.

The list is, as expected, sparkling. Some of my favorites there. Grand rAgAs, great compositions, Varadu and Venkatesh for companions on the musical journey!
Last edited by arasi on 27 Apr 2015, 03:38, edited 2 times in total.

kedharam
Posts: 419
Joined: 28 Sep 2008, 23:07

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by kedharam »

Purist, I bet you found “Sk/Sanjay classic” unnerving. And many more…

I do empathize with you since I feel the same when I read some reviews. I am just too sensitive to make a remark like you.

Music appreciation is subjective. That said, I can give you objective metrics on why I found the Bhairavi pallavi in Sanjay’s Detroit concert impressive or geek-out abt the one minute phrase by the S. Kalyanaraman in abhogi before he starts srI maha ganapathe. I am ready to take the discussion thru the forum mail with a caveat that my objective evidence will come out of my subjective interpretation. It is not an absolute measure since after a threshold it becomes subjective.

Fanaticism abt certain music is all abt personal preference with respect to aesthetics, nostalgia, interpretations, prejudice, familiarity, nurture etc beyond objective metrics. To put it simply, music appreciation exists in context. In this respect, I think sheer joy is the only measure of music.

CM is a pretty big place. Besides the ramblings of mine, there's enough space for us to co-exist peacefully.
"Live and let live" :)

Oh, let me try to fix the “fix” you are in.

Kedharam’s reviews are ramblings that rightfully belong to my diary. I just mess around with words not worth “savour” ing :(

Go for Sanjay’s music. I mean, “dwell” on it. Good luck :) :) :)

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by rshankar »

Detroit to Toronto to Houston - if that's not being a groupie, I don't know what is!! Anyway, thank you Kedharam for being a groupie (and racking up frequent flier miles, I hope), and for (in equal measure):

a) sharing with us a wonderfully expressive outpouring of your thoughts and not confining them to the anonymity of your diary, and
b) sparing us references to 'talaivA/talaivar' as some others are wont to!

PS: I was shocked to hear you say (on another thread) that you were old - reading your reviews, my mental picture was that of a much younger (in years) person!
PPS: My tongue is now firmly stuck to my cheek....

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by arasi »

How young is young, Doc?

I imagine kedharam to be a man about town with sensitivity--fortyish, a professional who is able to fly away for the weekend once in a while. He is not shy of attending concerts of musicians other than his favorites when they come to town. Just that a Panthula Rama or a Sanjay are worth it for him to take these weekend trips.

May he continue to do that, for his sake and our sake...:)

Purist
Posts: 431
Joined: 13 May 2008, 16:55

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by Purist »

kedharam wrote:Purist, I bet you found “Sk/Sanjay classic” unnerving........

Oh, let me try to fix the “fix” you are in.

Kedharam’s reviews are ramblings that rightfully belong to my diary. I just mess around with words not worth “savour” ing :(

Go for Sanjay’s music. I mean, “dwell” on it. Good luck :) :) :)
My intention was to compliment you for your riveting reviews, that said, viewing through your prism of analysis I gather
some insights that run back of my mind as and when I listen to Sanjay. :) Though not a big fan of Sanjay's music, I greatly admire his sincerity and commitment & the awe he creates in bringing out so many new and newer compositions.

kedharam
Posts: 419
Joined: 28 Sep 2008, 23:07

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by kedharam »

Purist, to my sleepless eyes the emoticon sounded like a snide remark. Sorry abt it. Anyway it felt good to be confessional. :)

arasi, “fortyish”?
That number sounds too babyish, relatively speaking :) ‘been there done that’ kind of feel...

I had work in Austin on Friday, so went to the temple, food there being an added attraction :)
They had wellness week going on with the Chithirai festival, the only temple that replicates Madurai temple, ritualistically. And i have a strong affinity towards this. So had early lunch, late lunch, dinner and more dinner :) (all in the name of prasadam) and the most hospitable committee members i have ever encountered in US :) who pampered my gluttonous soft spots musically/foodily :)

rshankar, looking forward to collecting social security. So doc, do the math :)
Hope you are not an ageist and continue to read my thoughts :) now that I am out of the closet :)
No, I am not a hero worshipper.
God worshipper I am - of the 2 gods MLV and S. Kalyanaraman :) :)


Sorry, for meandering :(
Enjoy this on the presiding deity :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QAKQWE8nHTc

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by rshankar »

kedharam wrote:Hope you are not an ageist and continue to read my thoughts :) now that I am out of the closet :)
Kedharam - why would I not read your views and thoughts? They are so ebullient, they belie your age. I was just pointing out how your remark (about your age) came at me from the left field, and brought home to me how my ideas could be so wrong!
kedharam wrote:God worshipper I am - of the 2 gods MLV :) :)
Sort of ' anrOr kOvil AkkivaittEn, adil ambikaiyAi unnai tUkki vaitten', eh?

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by rshankar »

At the cost of blaspheming, lovely as this is, I prefer this composition, rendered by another son of madurai - Sri TNS!

kedharam
Posts: 419
Joined: 28 Sep 2008, 23:07

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by kedharam »

“anrOr kOvil AkkivaittEn, adil ambikaiyAi unnai tUkki vaitten”

AmAm, pretty much. For an agnostic, they come quite close. :) 

Here is the one on Mr. :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qM_uM2-T72A

Sorry, couldn’t resist being relentless. :)

maduraimini
Posts: 477
Joined: 22 Sep 2009, 02:55

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by maduraimini »

I am another one who reads Kedaram's reviews. Thanks. They are very interesting and full of fun and pun! He is a music /Sanjay Music lover and flies around. Shocked to hear he is at an age to collect Social Security. I was imagining him about fortyish, ready to fly anywhere Sanjay goes (as much as he can). I feel good he can follow good music and write reviews for us to enjoy. Also, nice to hear about the Chithrai festvial in Houston (or is it Austin). As a former Madurai person (once you have lived in Madurai, you can never forget the town) it is good to hear Kedaram enjoyed the food as well as the music and their hospitality. Keep on writing reviews, Kedaram!

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by arasi »

Maduraimini cannot but respond when her home town is mentioned. Look at her name :)

Yes, Kedharam's reviews are awaited eagerly by many. As you say, good music moves him, makes him write his one of a kind reviews about Sanjay and a few others. He is not alone in flying and driving to concerts which are held in other states. I hear that many do it, but not all of them write reviews :) Last year, when we went to listen to Sanjay in the Boston area, I met some from NJ, California, Canada and elsewhere. Don't we all converge in Chennai for the season from many places?

Madurai mini, when we were young, we did that, in the Tristate area (NY, NJ, CT), covering a few hundred miles.
Sundararajan, though he is way past Kedharam's age, does go driving for a few hours to listen to concerts. Lakshman does. You attend several concerts because your younger friends take you with them :)

gardabha_gana
Posts: 1033
Joined: 24 Dec 2006, 07:44

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by gardabha_gana »

I drove a rental car as a student to listen to the great KVN in the Bay Area

Rasikapriya2013
Posts: 146
Joined: 13 Dec 2013, 22:23

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by Rasikapriya2013 »

Very nice review Kedharam ji.
Read it again to enjoy the beauty of your words.
Thank you !

sirsub11
Posts: 87
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 22:51

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by sirsub11 »

Dear Kedharam,

The rave notices your reviews attract are nothing short of well deserved. You've been doing it consistently over time, and the muse is particularly strong when it comes to Sanjay's offerings. It can truly be said that your effulgent, stream of consciousness style of description, almost matches the musician's own creative ardour.

For a person whose command over the language and musical idiom is so well entrenched, I have to point out, with considerable hesitation that you have an Achilles' heel when it comes to apostrophes. You keep inserting them where none is required. The word its and it's mean two very different things. Normally I would put it down to a misprint, were it not for the fact that it keeps appearing on a regular basis, like an unwanted rash. Please take this superfluous comment as a compliment, because i would not have bothered had it been just another run of the mill hack.

Finally Kedharam, you may or may not recall, but many years ago you came over to my place in Koramangala, Bengaluru for coffee and bhajjis, post a Sanjay concert at Odukatthur Mutt in Ulsoor. This is by way of assuaging the preceding remarks.

Do keep writing, apostrophes notwithstanding.

kvchellappa
Posts: 3636
Joined: 04 Aug 2011, 13:54

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by kvchellappa »

It's American perhaps!

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by arasi »

sirsub,
Good to hear from you after a long spell ;)

Now, bajjis at that hour? Kedharam isn't all that young to eat them so late at night :)
Last edited by arasi on 01 May 2015, 01:17, edited 1 time in total.

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by rshankar »

kvchellappa wrote:It's American perhaps!
No fair! And purposefully spelled...

kvchellappa
Posts: 3636
Joined: 04 Aug 2011, 13:54

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by kvchellappa »

I do not understand the comment. Mine was in lighter vein, picking on the American flair for doing the opposite way whatever the English have been doing. My sentence is grammatical in English. It's stands for 'It is'.

sirsub11
Posts: 87
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 22:51

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by sirsub11 »

Arasi,

Yes, it's (note the apostrophe) good to stray in unexpectedly and then stay low for a while. ".....post a Sanjay concert...." did not literally mean partaking of b & c close to midnight, after the event. It meant a couple of days later, but you were probably just taking the mickey. It must be read in its (no apostrophe here) proper context.

As for Mr. Chellappa's comment, I can do no better than to quote Prof. Henry Higgins in My Fair Lady, regarding Americans and the English language - "Well in America, they haven't used it for years".

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by arasi »

Kedharam might say...

'I post trophie's of reviews without a pause--
Imagine all the distances, by road, sky way
'I pass through f''ields and filling stations--
I s'uppose traff'ic tie ups count, don't they?

Above all, 'a post rough'ly around midnight
I see not why should deepen the divide
Between England and the new world!

Sirsub,
:)

rajeshnat
Posts: 10123
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by rajeshnat »

Bottomline
Kedharam few years back did attend many concerts of sanjay in midwest .This year also kedharam attends lot of concerts in chennai. There was a question that i asked another reviewer some time back where i made a mention that reviewer words and style matches kedharam . I asked a question in the forum few months back -- no response to that question. Now sirsub1 mentions about kedharam in bangalore and bhajjis . I have almost nailed out who that kedharam is ?

What matters is how wonderfully kedharam writes and his love for particularly sanjay music is great whose songlist is always impressive .

Kedharam,
Just a suggestion , i am sure you attend other concerts of other artists, please write other concerts too . Age never matters in our forum. Keep it coming - kedharam. You just rock though would love to attend a concert with you and perhaps write a counter review after you have written a review.

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by arasi »

Rajesh,
Kedharam's reviews about Panthula Rama last year are something to savor...

rajeshnat
Posts: 10123
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by rajeshnat »

arasi wrote:Rajesh,
Kedharam's reviews about Panthula Rama last year are something to savor...
Arasi
Apart from pantula , i do recollect long time back a review of bhushany and hyderabad brothers. My point is they are all too scanty. I would love to hear his/her views on others who are travelling right now. Artists have time in US and we get to know more about artist capability when they sing in us .Hopefully he/she will do it.

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by arasi »

Rajesh,
Are we complicating things by saying he/she? To me, the man in a white kurta, with a notebook and a pen conjures up our Kedharam's image. You and I know many rasikAs in the Chennai, Bengaluru and the US turf put together. Somehow, since Kedharam has not attended any of the Rasikas.org meets or has said 'hello' to us in any of the concerts, I assume that he is a very private person, in spite of all the effusiveness which is transmitted in his reviews. Why spoil it? We had young Srinivasaraghavan who wrote the lovely story of the music contest and a few great reviews, and for personal reasons stopped posting :( :( I missed him at the CD releases in January :(

I don't want to upset Kedharam in any way--if doing so will make him withdraw from writing his reviews. Let's just enjoy the reviews as they come, is what I'd say. One day, who knows, he may even have tea with us or coffee and bajjis, and when I say tea, how can I not think of Nick? ;)

Did you overlook my poem which had to do with the misplacement of a mere ' ' ' ?

rajeshnat
Posts: 10123
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: Sanjay Subrahmanyan @ Houston Meenakshi temple

Post by rajeshnat »

arasi wrote:
I don't want to upset Kedharam in any way--if doing so will make him withdraw from writing his reviews. Let's just enjoy the reviews as they come, is what I'd say. One day, who knows, he may even have tea with us or coffee and bajjis, and when I say tea, how can I not think of Nick? ;)
Time to move on Arasi. I certainly did not upset and certainly enjoy what is written .

Post Reply