Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
Venkataraman
Posts: 24
Joined: 13 Aug 2015, 22:30

Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by Venkataraman »

Shankar Narayanan - Vocal
V Sanjeev - Violin
Patri Sathish Kumar - Mridangam
BS Purushottaman - Ganjeera

1. Innum En Manam (Pada Varnam) - Charukesi - Adi - Lalgudi Jayaraman
2. Maha Ganapathe - Natanarayani - Adi - MD (S)
3. Devadi Deva - Sunadavinodini - Adi - Mysore Vasudevachar (R,S)
4. Ninnu sevinchina - Yadukula Kamboji - M Chapu - Subbaraya Sastri (R)
5. Vara Narada - Vijayasri - Adi - Thyagarajar
6. Sri Krishnam Bhajamanasa - Todi - Adi - MD
7. Muralidhara Gopala - Maand - Adi - Thooran
8. Samudita Madane - Misra Sivaranjani - Adi - Jayadevar
9. Mangalam

One of the perks of retiring is .... you can actually sit and write a review at 9 AM something that i couldnt dream off a few months back! But that feels absolutely fantastic :D. I went to Shankar Narayanan's concert @ NGS for a brief while. it was a vivadi raga concert and his style of singing did want me to attend to a normal concert. Things fell in place yesterday since Vani mahal is a stone'e throw away from my brother's home and i could just walk down along with mami and my brother's family!

Shankar's voice is a sheer pleasure to hear. Its so well rounded and pitch perfect at every note. He is at ease with his voice, never gave an impression that he is stretching it and it obeys his every command.

The concert really set-in right away when he started the varnam. Lalgudi has made charukesi his own whether he played Kripaya Palaya or adamodi or this varnam of his. The rendition was excellent Maha Ganapathe that followed also had some phrases that show the distinction between this ragam and Sama which is very similar. In fact i have heard some versions that clearly sama dominated in some sangathis.

Sunadavinodini alapanai really highlighted the voice aspects that i highlighted earlier. Really well done and crisp. Krithi was well rendered and a round of swaras to finish off.

Ninnu sevinchina that followed a short ragam was delivered at a slow pace capturing the mood of the composer may be. Patri Sathish gave excellent support here as well as the next piece which was a contrast at a fast clip. Patri's left right balance is something that not many have and he should use it well by adopting some traditional mridangam playing patterns.

Sri Krishnam Bhajamanasa was the main item. Looks like Todi and TNR are inseparable and flashes of the nadaswaram came to the fore in the ragam. Krithi, neraval and swarams were well rendered. korappu was neat and very engaging with patterns in charustram and tisram that clearly went over me.

Tani by patri & BSP seem to take cue from the patters in the korappu and the entire tani was built around that. To a lay person like me, that seemed clearly overwhelming as to how someone can so quickly calculate the patterns on stage!

Tukkadas seem to his fore as well and he should focus on this. His voice changes from a deep traditional one to a - if i may call it, a light-mode" when he delivers the post tani items. The last piece needs special mention. The ashtapathi tuned in misra sivaranjani was so moving that we just couldn't leave the auditorium even if we actually wanted to. I cant really express the feeling thru words here.

In all a very superb performance that we all felt very satisfied attending. The fellow looks very smart and presentable on stage without any mannerisms as well. The entire team looked fresh and happy on stage and it was nice to see them enjoying the music.

hnbhagavan
Posts: 1664
Joined: 21 Jun 2008, 22:06

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by hnbhagavan »

Which sankar narayanan - could u clarify?

CRama
Posts: 2939
Joined: 18 Nov 2009, 16:58

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by CRama »

It is V.Sankaranarayanan. Not TVS.

CRama
Posts: 2939
Joined: 18 Nov 2009, 16:58

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by CRama »

Venkatraman, You are lucky that you could hear Sree Krishnam bhaja manasa. I attended many concerts in this Gokulashtami festival. But I could not hear once this song. I heard Balagopala a number of times. Also I longed to hear Sree Rajagopala.

Thanks for your review. VS always gives a largely satisfying concert. I have heard many.

HarishankarK
Posts: 2217
Joined: 27 Oct 2007, 11:55

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by HarishankarK »

I don't think even one of the songs in the list features in the TVS repertoire. :lol:

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by sureshvv »

Mods... Pls. correct the title of thread to use the correct name of the artiste furnished by CRama above.

Meera
Posts: 49
Joined: 16 Oct 2012, 17:20

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by Meera »

HarishankarK wrote:I don't think even one of the songs in the list features in the TVS repertoire. :lol:
Yes.TVS has been singing for the past 4.5 decades with hardly 45 kritis ! Can't someone recommend a Guinness for him !

harimau
Posts: 1819
Joined: 06 Feb 2007, 21:43

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by harimau »

Venkataraman wrote:Shankar Narayanan - Vocal
Next, it will be Shankar Narayan.

After that, it will become Shankar Narain.
CRama wrote:
It is V. Sankaranarayanan
Yes, that is the name as given by his parents.

There is absolutely no need to change the spelling just to agree with the dummies from North India.

I was reading a book by one of the aides to Lord Mountbatten about the transition of power to Indian leaders.

The Indian names on a document were uniformly prefixed with "Shri".

Mountbatten looked at the document and corrected it to "Sri" for Rajagopalachari and "Sree" for some person from the Telugu region.

What is good for Mountbatten is good enough for me!

PS. The greatest offender in this area has been Carnatica. From Bharath Sangeeth Uthsav, it has now morphed to Bharat Sangeet Utsav. Do they get even one person from the north of the Vindhyas to attend this program? If they do, the bloody North Indian can lump the South Indian spelling.

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by sureshvv »

@harimau...

Your North vs South paranoia seems to be clouding an objective evaluation of the situation.

Changing the spelling of a person's name is not correct. Basic courtesy demands that you spell it as he wishes it to be.

Removing extraneous 'h's from the English spelling of Indian words is perfectly alright. This is not a case of transliteration and spelling does not have to reflect every vocal nuance involved in mouthing the word.

kvchellappa
Posts: 3636
Joined: 04 Aug 2011, 13:54

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by kvchellappa »

Harimau may be right about the spelling of V.Sankarnarayanan, the way it ought to be acc. to VVS.
I would like to know an instance in English where 't' is pronounced soft (த). How does the h become redundant? Why should it not be close to how the English letters will reflect the Tamizh (Thamizh rather) sound?

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by sureshvv »

Because spelling does not translate directly to pronunciation in English. The 'h' after the 't' can be left to be filled in by the educated reader. Works this way for many foreign words that have made it in.

kvchellappa
Posts: 3636
Joined: 04 Aug 2011, 13:54

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by kvchellappa »

What if it is there?

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by sureshvv »

Just added baggage.

hnbhagavan
Posts: 1664
Joined: 21 Jun 2008, 22:06

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by hnbhagavan »

Posting No7 _Meera

Yes.TVS has been singing for the past 4.5 decades with hardly 45 kritis ! Can't someone recommend a Guinness for him !

This comment is out of context and it is all the more creditable if TVS held his forte with just 45 Kritis!
Srt TVS has his own unique style and revered in carnatic music circles.

harimau
Posts: 1819
Joined: 06 Feb 2007, 21:43

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by harimau »

sureshvv wrote:@harimau...

Your North vs South paranoia seems to be clouding an objective evaluation of the situation.

Changing the spelling of a person's name is not correct. Basic courtesy demands that you spell it as he wishes it to be.

Removing extraneous 'h's from the English spelling of Indian words is perfectly alright. This is not a case of transliteration and spelling does not have to reflect every vocal nuance involved in mouthing the word.

There is no paranoia, only extreme annoyance at the behaviour of North Indians who assume every Indian must know Hindi and starts talking to them in that language. One North Indian friend, on his first visit to Chennai, expressed his astonishment that signs were not in Hindi and said he felt like he was in a foreign country. I told him the signs are in English in addition to Tamil as a courtesy to non-Tamilians, something which is not reciprocated in Delhi or Bombay. I added gratuitously that we were foreigners invaded by the Northies.

And I feel sorry for those who feel inferior to people raised on buffalo milk -- against which our mothers guarded us as they felt it would dull the mind -- and attempt to ingratiate themselves by adopting the spelling used by them.

The Bengalis treat them with the contempt they deserve: if you asked a question to anyone in Calcutta in Hindi they wouldn't answer though they will respond if the question was asked in English (of course taking pity on the guy who wasn't fortunate enough to be born a Bengali). All North Indians were dismissed as 'Hindusthanis', barbarian invaders from a distant land.

By the way, the Bengalis pronounce 'S' with the sound found in 'Sri'.

kvchellappa
Posts: 3636
Joined: 04 Aug 2011, 13:54

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by kvchellappa »

I have been pronouncing Hindi as 'd' not ;dh'. A hindiwala tried to correct me and I said, 'The day the hindiwalas pronounce Tamizh correctly I would pronounce Hindi also correctly.' Most of us pronounce Hindi, Hindu and Modi with hard 'd' as the way we transliterate has ingrained it in us. There is nothing to feel right or wrong on this. Much of what we do is by rote. A friend was mispronouncing many Samskritam words in an ashtakam. When I pointed out, he said, 'It will be difficult to correct it now just like that.' We can carry on as we do without feeling we are doing something wrong or that what we do is divinely sanctioned.

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: Shankar Narayanan @ Vani Mahal 06Sep15

Post by sureshvv »

harimau wrote:

There is no paranoia, only extreme annoyance at the behaviour of... <snip>
Of course just because you are paranoid doesn't mean that "They" aren't out to get you.

Some counselling may be in order. This may be the reason why you are also taking the battle
to some ragas which may be preventing you from enjoying the "Dogeshri".

Post Reply