Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
bhasi
Posts: 89
Joined: 19 Nov 2018, 13:41

Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by bhasi »

The Indian Fine Arts Academy of San Diego's annual week-long festival began today with a kacheri meant as a tribute to the redoubtable S. Rajam. And who better for this purpose than one of S. Rajam's prime disciples, Dr. Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam?

Artists
  • Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam - vocal
  • Shreya Devnath - violin
  • Vaikkom Gopalakrishnan - ghatam
  • Raamkumar Balamurthi - mridangam
Setlist
  1. chalamEla varnam - nattakurinji
  2. jaya jAnaki kAntha - nAttai
  3. manavyAlakincharAthate - nalinakAnthi
  4. madhurAmbikayam sadA bhaktim karOmi - hEmAvati
  5. kanakangaka shuka guha - kanakAngi
  6. pAlinchu kAmakshi pAvani - madhyamAvati.
  7. niddiraiyil vanthu nenjinil idam konda uthaman yarodi - jOnpuri
  8. sarvam brahmamayam - madhuvanti
Thoughts and ruminations

At the very outset I must confess that I have not heard much of S. Rajam's music - the little I know of him is that he was the elder brother of the eccentric genius Veena S. Balachander, and that he was a fantastic and much revered painter of universal renown. That last bit I gleaned from the excellent Facebook page, Rajam 100 that's been posting audio recordings of his music as well as his gorgeous, gorgeous paintings online in honour of his centenary.

Vijayalakshmy began with a medium-paced Chalamela. Opening with a Nattakurinji was a great idea, I thought, as it is such a lovely and feel-good ragam. This was followed by the sedate nAttai and everyone's darling, the nalinakAnthi kriti. These were executed in quick succession, almost like thukkadas. I was beginning to worry if this was how it was going to be for the entire concert.

She was gracious enough to announce the next song as "the sister" of the well-known Sri Kanthimathim in ragam Hemavati. Apparently S. Rajam was a huge fan of Dikshitar, which instantly caused me to like this Colossus of the arts that I'd never heard of until this year. I am partial to Dikshitar kritis as opposed to Tyagaraja's, mostly because the former composed mostly in stately Sanskrit, and he went about his business of bhakti in a very matter of fact manner - straight flowery descriptions and astutely crafted poetic encomiums - as opposed to the over-the-top mawkishness and possessiveness-based approach of the latter, which I do not care for as much.

Anyway, the Hemavati was elaborate, with a proper alapana and violin alapana. I rejoiced in discovering a second song in that ragam.

Up until this point, Shreya did nothing spectacular - her violin playing was very good, and she had adopted a style of closely following the vocalist's flights of inspiration. I was not particularly moved by Vijayalakshmy's singing either; the real treat was listening to Raamkumar's mridangam and Gopalakrishnan's ghatam and the excellent on stage chemistry they evinced. It was almost like they both knew every korvai and pattern that the other was going to play every step of the way. It is such a wonderful thing to see when this thing happens - it was like they were finishing each other's sentences! I can only stare and gape in wonder at the level of preparedness and training they must have undergone in order to recognize instantly the hint of a particular nadai or pattern, however arcane or complex (or simple!).

All that changed from the next song onwards, and I eventually left the hall feeling like Vijayalakshmy had earned my respect (ha! yes, me who knows literally nothing).

The main piece of the afternoon was the Madhyamavati kriti, which was handled quite well with an unhurried alapana, a violin response, a neraval at "... kAntamagu ponthithivi..." followed by swarams. Again, the percussionists showcased a very enthralling thani full of artistic sensitivity. By the way, Raamkumar is a local guru whom I've had the pleasure of listening to on multiple occasions - he's VERY good. I was actually wondering how the thani was going to be, for such a song which didn't really offer any room for thundering thani finishes (in my opinion), and Raamkumar surprised me by finishing his opening salvo quite early, sans any building up of tempo. Vaikkom Gopalakrishnan ("A Malayali! Yes!", I cheered him on mentally) was ON POINT with his playing that went into a few more rounds of call-and-response which ended in some slight kanakku-based but very accessible patterns and koraippus. I thoroughly enjoyed the thani. It was very measured, restrained and calculated in its effect.

As I was trying to figure out the ragam to the subsequent Tamil song, it hit me - Jonpuri. "Aha, a new jOnpuri song!". I couldn't have been happier. Few ragams transport me so instantly to a state of emotionality like jOnpuri. And the fact that it was a Tamil song was just the icing on the cake.

But she had a final trick up her sleeve. As she started the raga alapana, it struck me that this was a rare raga, and one that I'd loved and remembered as a Tanjore S Kalyanaraman staple (uruppadi). I immediately searched my Youtube history and found the song that was redolent of the raga - Kanda naal muthalai, in ragam Madhuvanti. Dr. Venkatachalam, who was in the audience, was beside himself with delight, with very animated hand gestures as he also enjoyed this rare raga and rarer kriti. I shared his joy at identifying the raga, and noted down "Sarvam brahmamayam" for revisting later on Youtube. Vijayalakshmy mentioned that this was a Sadasiva Brahmendra song that S. Rajam had himself set to tune, so that was great to know.

Overall, a rollicking start to this year's Festival. A fine tribute to a Carnatic great by a well-qualified and deserving disciple.

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by rshankar »

Bhasi: Keep then coming. I enjoy your honest reviews; the candid views are very refreshing. ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿฝ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿฝ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿฝ

As someone who shares your views on Sri Muttusvami Dikshitar, albeit unarticulated, I do think you may have opened a Pandoraโ€™s box of comments (my silence certainly came under the heading of discretion being the better part of valor)....๐Ÿ˜œ

If memory serves, the jOnpuri piece was something I had first heard from Smt. NCV...

rajeshnat
Posts: 10123
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by rajeshnat »

rshankar wrote: โ†‘08 Apr 2019, 20:22 Bhasi: Keep then coming. I enjoy your honest reviews; the candid views are very refreshing.
ravi
Indeed I really endorse what you said. Bhasi appears as a young lad with mohanlal-mammooty roots and is making a terrific impact. He is the best trajectory of discovering carnatic music , there is always a contextual state of comparision of where he is with every particular concert . Certainly a great substitute to the once naa jeeva dhara man of sandiego who is now hiding somewhere in the east coast.

bhasi
I think you are bit caged with kutti concerts in sandiego , drive north to either LA -Simala or better yet plan to hit either simala or sankritilaya so that you have more content to write. Keep them coming.

bhasi
Posts: 89
Joined: 19 Nov 2018, 13:41

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by bhasi »

@rshankar, @rajeshnat, Thank you for your kind words. I shall try to post more reviews.

I find that the IFAASD guys have more concerts per year than the LA folks. For instance, Sankritilaya has a paltry 4 concerts between now and September, while the IFAASD Festival has many multiples of that number just this upcoming weekend. Last year they brought over such diverse people as Ramana Balanchandran, Anahita-Apoorva, Mysore brothers, Sriranjini Santhanagopalan, Hemmige Srivatsan and his son, and many others I can't even remember. The only LA concert I attended last year was that of Ramakrishnan Murthy, who, in my opinion, is one of the best in the current generation, if not the best - and the arrangements they made for him were very subpar and left much to be desired, while the IFAASD guys do a brilliant job taking care of the artist as well as the audio. I am so spoilt for choice right here that I don't feel like driving two hours up and down to and from LA.

CRama
Posts: 2939
Joined: 18 Nov 2009, 16:58

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by CRama »

Bhasi, that was an expressive review from your end. Thank you for that,
Since you did not know much about Dr.VS, I would like to add. She is a very knowledgeable senior vidushi who has left her mark in thousands of concerts and lakhs of rasikas. Besides S. Rajam, she has learnt from many others including TR. Subramaniam. I appreciate her concerts mainly for the peaceful atmosphere she creates in the concert. She will not create a noisy crescendo in the last lap of neraval or swaras with the aid of the flamboyant pakkavadyams aiming a torrential applause. She is the repository of many rare kritis of Deekshitar, Koteeswara Iyer etc. I feel age is catching up with her showing in the voice nowadays.

Coming to this concert, that song in Hemavati- It is called Desi Simharavam in the Deeskhitar sampradayam- Madhurambikayam- It is very rare song. I have never heard this song. Dr. VS must have done an authentic portrayal of the song. That Nithirayil is a hit of NCV which is evergreen with music lovers. Now only I came to know that Sarvam brahmamayam in this version is tuned by S. Rajam.

Keep your reviews coming.

bhasi
Posts: 89
Joined: 19 Nov 2018, 13:41

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by bhasi »

Thanks @CRama for the info on Vijayalakshmy. I didn't know she was such a well known and well accomplished artiste.

I'm humbled to learn that I've had the chance to listen to a rare song that you haven't heard live.

I have never heard of NC Vasanthakokilam. Will check her out. Her Nithirayil rendition is fantastic - I heard on Youtube.

Thanks all for your replies and encouraging words.

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by sureshvv »

@bhasi

Your review brings a smile to my face, somewhat reminding me of my own reckless evolution with CM over the years :D
I am partial to Dikshitar kritis as opposed to Tyagaraja's, mostly because the former composed mostly in stately Sanskrit, and he went about his business of bhakti in a very matter of fact manner - straight flowery descriptions and astutely crafted poetic encomiums - as opposed to the over-the-top mawkishness and possessiveness-based approach of the latter, which I do not care for as much.
But there is certain quality in "poetry from the gut" that you could learn to savor and appreciate, Also, T has also composed many "stately" kritis - many of then even in Sanskrit.

bhasi
Posts: 89
Joined: 19 Nov 2018, 13:41

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by bhasi »

@sureshvv Touche. Of course, the spontaneous outpouring of emotion and the experiencing of rapturous ecstasy is as close to the numinous as one can possibly hope to get, for sure - I do agree with that - and what better impetus for creative endeavour (short of mind-altering substances)!

I did some more thinking, and realized what exactly it was that bothered me about Tyagaraja's approach, the matter of language aside. It is the repeated, ever more fervent and plaintive calls directed at his chosen God to come and deliver him from his so-called "mortal coil", to "save" him, etc. While I do not begrudge him his feelings, this idea of someone needing to save you, etc. is incompatible with my worldview, nascent as it is. This element of abdication of personal responsibility in life that has been glorified and enshrined in practically all of his songs is what I do not care for. Moksha may be the main purushartha, blah blah - I haven't advanced far enough to appreciate that stuff yet, I guess.

CRama
Posts: 2939
Joined: 18 Nov 2009, 16:58

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by CRama »

bhasi wrote: โ†‘13 Apr 2019, 12:24 @sureshvv Touche. Of course, the spontaneous outpouring of emotion and the experiencing of rapturous ecstasy is as close to the numinous as one can possibly hope to get, for sure - I do agree with that - and what better impetus for creative endeavour (short of mind-altering substances)!

I did some more thinking, and realized what exactly it was that bothered me about Tyagaraja's approach, the matter of language aside. It is the repeated, ever more fervent and plaintive calls directed at his chosen God to come and deliver him from his so-called "mortal coil", to "save" him, etc. While I do not begrudge him his feelings, this idea of someone needing to save you, etc. is incompatible with my worldview, nascent as it is.
Looking at the above view, how will you rate Syama Sastry kritis. :D

bhasi
Posts: 89
Joined: 19 Nov 2018, 13:41

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by bhasi »

@CRama Hmm, can't say that I have formed a definite opinion on Shyama Shastri's kritis. I haven't heard enough of them to do so.

Now that you mention it, somehow his kritis - the few that I've heard - didn't quite register in my mind with a distinct enough personality as the other two Trimurtis' did. I shall pay attention to his kritis from now on, as and when I encounter them. Thanks a lot, you've given me a worthwhile task to work on :)

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by arasi »

Bhasi,
A keen young rasikA with sensibilities and sensitivity is what you come across to me as. Enjoy your music in all the many coming years of your listening to it :)
At college, I loved Keats, Coleridge and Byron and preferred them to Milton. TyAgarAjA over MD? I started off the other way round, I guess! I appreciate MD tons of time more today, after my donkey's years. I guess it so happens that you have been listening to more of the plaintive songs so far. How many many songs T has sung, glorifying Rama's qualities! How much he celebrates Him therein! Let's not forget Purandara Dasa in all this, and all other mahAnubhAvulu :)

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by sureshvv »

bhasi wrote: โ†‘13 Apr 2019, 12:24 It is the repeated, ever more fervent and plaintive calls directed at his chosen God to come and deliver him from his so-called "mortal coil", to "save" him, etc. While I do not begrudge him his feelings, this idea of someone needing to save you, etc. is incompatible with my worldview, nascent as it is.
You should see this against the background of the sheer disdain that he expresses for the "elite" of his times and the contempt for the majority that toe their line.
This element of abdication of personal responsibility in life that has been glorified and enshrined in practically all of his songs is what I do not care for.
There is no abdication of personal responsibility. This is a call to the almighty - to the divine within and without. Not to any mortal being or force. This is taking responsibility at its most exemplary.
Moksha may be the main purushartha, blah blah - I haven't advanced far enough to appreciate that stuff yet, I guess.
Yep. That takes time. May have come a bit easier for a guy like T who dedicated his life to the creative pursuit. :D

bhasi
Posts: 89
Joined: 19 Nov 2018, 13:41

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by bhasi »

@arasi Ah yes, point taken. Tyagaraja's oeuvre is vast, and you've rightly pointed out that perhaps I've listen to only a small fraction of it. I'll seek out and listen to more songs of his.

Also, thank you for the warm wishes. I try to be honest to myself as much as possible and so I try to record my impressions as accurately as I can while still being open to new suggestions and ideas.
Last edited by bhasi on 14 Apr 2019, 22:32, edited 1 time in total.

bhasi
Posts: 89
Joined: 19 Nov 2018, 13:41

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by bhasi »

sureshvv wrote: โ†‘13 Apr 2019, 22:44 You should see this against the background of the sheer disdain that he expresses for the "elite" of his times and the contempt for the majority that toe their line.
I fail to see how his disdain for the establishment buttresses his desire to be delivered.
sureshvv wrote: โ†‘13 Apr 2019, 22:44 There is no abdication of personal responsibility. This is a call to the almighty - to the divine within and without. Not to any mortal being or force. This is taking responsibility at its most exemplary.
"Personal responsibility or Individual Responsibility is the idea that human beings choose, instigate, or otherwise cause their own actions" - Source.

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: Vijayalakshmy Subramaniam | 7 April 2019 | IFAASD, San Diego

Post by sureshvv »

bhasi wrote: โ†‘14 Apr 2019, 21:47 I fail to see how his disdain for the establishment buttresses his desire to be delivered.
He wants to be delivered from the tyranny of the Man made institutions.
"Personal responsibility or Individual Responsibility is the idea that human beings choose, instigate, or otherwise cause their own actions" - Source.
Are you suggesting that prayer is antithetical to Individual Responsibility? I don't see how you make the jump that T was abdicating personal responsibility. The wikipedia article doesn't help either.

Post Reply