Is there Any equivilant or closest carnatic ragam for hindustani Shree raga?
Thank you
Any equivilant or closest carnatic ragam for hindustani Shree raga?
-
vamsipet
- Posts: 55
- Joined: 29 Jan 2010, 07:22
-
Lakshman
- Posts: 14165
- Joined: 10 Feb 2010, 18:52
Re: Any equivilant or closest carnatic ragam for hindustani Shree raga?
There isn't one. shrI of HM is a janya of pUrvi (kAmavardhini)thAT and Karnatak shrI is a janya of KharaharapriyA (kAfi thAT).
-
Ranganayaki
- Posts: 1763
- Joined: 02 Jan 2011, 06:23
Re: Any equivilant or closest carnatic ragam for hindustani Shree raga?
Just reading about Hindustani Shree, it seems that the closest scale in CM would be Maruthi, a janya of Kamavardhini (Pantuvarali). Details:
SRMPNS-SNDPMGRS, technically the same as Hindustani Shri.
I have never ever heard Maruthi ragam. In Hindustani Shri, I read that while descending, they tend to skip the high S and the P.
-
MadhavRayaprolu
- Posts: 63
- Joined: 18 Jan 2018, 13:04
Re: Any equivilant or closest carnatic ragam for hindustani Shree raga?
Yeah I don't think there is an equivalent Carnatic ragam. Maybe there is one with similar notes as @RangaNayaki mentioned. Shree is one of those "hardcore" Hindustani ragas IMO. The glide from P to R is a key characteristic and usually those glides to R1 have a strong Hindustani flavor without Carnatic equivalents. Analogous to the kampita gandharam of Carnatic that doesn't translate to Hindustani.