2 Gayatris and a Ranjani

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
vijay
Posts: 2522
Joined: 27 Feb 2006, 16:06

Post by vijay »

Writing a review is an onerous responsibility. It requires the highest levels of technical knowledge and aesthetic sense. Fortunately for me, this is not one. I am neither a trained musician nor is my knowledge of music any better than that of the average rasika. That reduces the following write-up to a layman’s uninformed observations. Healthy doses of salt are, therefore, recommended as a digestive aid.

BVB 8/12/2007

K Gayatri
L Ramakrishnan (Violin)
Arjun Ganesh (Mrudangam)

Era Napai – Thodi Varnam – Adi
Sree Mahaganapathi – Attana – Adi (S) - ??
Karunajoodavamma – Varali – Misra Chapu – Syama Sastri (RNS)
Kripajuchutakuvelara – Chayatarangini – Adi – Thyagaraja
Sathatham – Kharaharapriya - Adi (RNST) - ??

Ranjani & Gayathri
HN Bhaskar (Violin) ???
Arun Prakash (Mrudangam)
S Karthick (Ghatam)

Brihandambika – Vasantha – Misra Chapu – Deekshitar (S)
Kanugonu – Nayaki – Rupakam – Thyagaraja
Kanthachoojumi – Vachaspathi – Adi – Thyagaraja
Thyagaraja Yoga Vaibhavam – Ananda Bhairavi – Rupakam – Deekshitar
Ninnada – Kannada – Adi – Thyagaraja
Enneramum – Thodi – Adi – Marimutha Pillai

Thanks to the superstar sisters scheduled to grace the stage after her concert, K Gayatri found herself singing to a full house. The crowds may not have to listen to her but her music deserved all those ears and hands and some more. The opener in Thodi revealed a strong voice that was in solid control even in the second speed. Both the alaapanas were well handled with her adventurous streak especially evident in the Kharaharapriya essay - this also led to the occasional slip as when a desired landing on the panchamam after some tara sthayi phrases overshot the runway. The rendition of the krithi was also an ordinary patch for the 3 artistes, all of whom had played their exceptionally well until then. Arjun Ganesh seemed somewhat insensitive to the structure of the krithi while Ramakrishnan appeared to be groping in the dark. Both however made up in the swara and tani avarthanam sections respectively. Gayathri is one of the juniors well on her way to prime-time as I suspect are her accompanists yesterday

Ranjani and Gayatri began brightly with a brisk krithi in Vasantha, sauteed with some quick swaras. The young woman on the tanpura nodded repeatedly, as if to convey the appreciation of her instrument - the sisters' enunciation is almost perfect leaving nary a blotch on the critic's book...The alaapana in Vachaspati continued the good work and while Thyagaraja Yoga Vaibhavam had a little more helium than appropriate, the mellifluous swirl of the resultant balloon was not without its charms. Kannada was yet another example of dazzling speeds handled with impeccable diction and absolute tonal fidelity but was should have been the launching point for the summit assualt turned out to be a gentle slope earthwards - the main piece needed more time and while I have nothing against abhangs one wondered about the advisability of setting apart 45 minutes for tukkadas in a 2 hour concert. The megh/megh malhar(??) was enchanting enough (prompting me to remark that the siblings would do well to make formal forays into HM - this is meant as a genuine compliment and is not to be construed as sarcasm) but the truncated Thodi and tani left one with a saccharine aftertaste where there should have been the full bodied headiness of draksha-rasa ;-)

The violiniist's Thodi was brilliant and Arun Prakash bamboozled the hands with his trademark brand of mathematical witchcraft which his partner on the Ghatam, the freshly minted Doctor, resonantly reproduced. Doubly disheartening then, to see such extraordinary skill being wasted on a dhinchak jhaptal that is more the bailiwick of the street drummer...The audience response was expectedly disproportionate with the tail-pieces fetching the maximum applause.

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Post by vasanthakokilam »

Nice review Vijay.
The audience response was expectedly disproportionate with the tail-pieces fetching the maximum applause.
It looks like a lot of people come to the CM concerts mainly for the thukkadas and grin and bear the pre-thukkada pieces. That also explains the 45 minutes set aside for the post main items.

vijay
Posts: 2522
Joined: 27 Feb 2006, 16:06

Post by vijay »

VK - precisely..and the sisters should probably start wondering whether they are getting the right kind of crowd - I for one think that their talent deserves better. Popularity is important but legacy, equally so...
Last edited by vijay on 09 Dec 2007, 14:30, edited 1 time in total.

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Post by arasi »

Vijay,
Well, you seem insistent on the disclaimer and make it your mast head too! The kalingA warrior is also lyrical. We all know that.
A tale on the season's progress unfolds. As ever, interestingly told.
Couldn't agree more about the disproportionate time allowance for the TukDAs! I have thought too that they would make excellent HM singers.
Will give the other Gayatri a try this year...
Last edited by arasi on 09 Dec 2007, 21:24, edited 1 time in total.

nadhasudha
Posts: 382
Joined: 22 May 2006, 06:40

Post by nadhasudha »

Vijay,
It is always a pleasure to read your reviews. Exceptionally written. Keep them coming

prashant
Posts: 1658
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:01

Post by prashant »

The last two times I heard the sisters, they seemed to have developed a marked tendency towards false-voiced crooning. A melodramatic hinaNmayIm earlier this year in Mumbai had me reaching for my handkerchief while making my way to the canteen. From Vijay's review, its very heartening to see that their singing had its previous punch - although their tendency towards making the post-main session an extended abhang-fest [a hallmark of my previous experience with their concerts] is not my cup of oolong.

ramakriya
Posts: 1877
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 02:05

Post by ramakriya »

vijay wrote:Sree Mahaganapathi – Attana – Adi (S) - ??

.
Jayachamaraja Odeyaru
vijay wrote:satatam - kharaharapriya - ?

.
I think Swathi Tirunal

-Ramakriya

vijay
Posts: 2522
Joined: 27 Feb 2006, 16:06

Post by vijay »

Arasi and Nadhasudha, thanks...will try to keep em coming too!

Prashant there didn't seem to be too much crooning so that is perhaps an improvement...it was short on punch however. I wouldn't complain too much about an Abhang-fest if the tukkadas took up 15-20 minutes...my crib is more about the length of the tail...and pray what is an "oolong"

vijay
Posts: 2522
Joined: 27 Feb 2006, 16:06

Post by vijay »

Thanks Ramakriya - the words "Mamava" or "Sathatham" brings ST to mind immediately!

ragam-talam
Posts: 1896
Joined: 28 Sep 2006, 02:15

Post by ragam-talam »

and pray what is an "oolong"
as in oolong tea

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Post by rshankar »

ragam-talam wrote:as in oolong tea
And here I was thinking it was something to reflect the 'oh too long' abho[a]ng section!:P

Vijay: Please keep your reviews coming: you have a way with words that takes us on a iSai payaNam with you. And regarding your disclaimer, there are lay rasikas, and there are lay rasikas, and then you get to people like me - so, it is all a matter of relativity as the masters that matter would say!
Last edited by rshankar on 09 Dec 2007, 23:17, edited 1 time in total.

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Post by arasi »

Ravi,
With a refreshing oolong, the tail piece will not seem sooo long...

sbala
Posts: 629
Joined: 30 Jul 2006, 08:56

Post by sbala »

I just hope they balance their popularity aspirations with weighty pieces and spend more time on swaras and neravals to get the nod from the experts. Experimenting with the concert format would also provide more variety. In an attempt to be perfect, it just seems like they overplan for a concert. In one of their concerts that I had attended, I was standing outside with a gentleman as the hall was jampacked. He remarked he just wanted to hear the viruttam and he is willing to stand just for that.

I felt Arun Prakash recedes into the background when it comes to accompanying for their slow songs (eg. y'days Tyagaraga yoga vaibhavam ). However, I also don't know if there is any other way to accompany such songs. I'm looking for some great percussion accompaniment for one of these slow pieces. MDR might not be a great example as he pauses quite a bit to give space to the percussionists to play some patterns. The one accompaniment that still rings in my mind is Trichy Sankaran to TNS. He played some very vigorous patterns even though the song was slow. Any pointers?

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Post by rshankar »

One of the nice things about R&G's music is the special designer viruttams penned by their dad - the perfect opener for many of their kritIs. Another is that they write most of their kritIs/notations in dEvnAgarI, and that may be one reason their pronunciation is good.

prashant
Posts: 1658
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:01

Post by prashant »

rshankar wrote:special designer viruttams
LOL rshankar. Nicely put :-)

vijay
Posts: 2522
Joined: 27 Feb 2006, 16:06

Post by vijay »

The Pazhani school is supposed to come up with great patterns for such songs - TNS himself had mentioned this once so it is hardly a surprise that you mention Sankaran. But beyond that I am equally clueless...I also greatly enjoyed Srimushnam's playing for Vijay Siva's Deekshitar concert at KGS...he seemed to be resonating with the sollu of the krithis...

Ravi thanks - sure will..

grsastrigal
Posts: 884
Joined: 27 Dec 2006, 10:52

Post by grsastrigal »

I still rate Malladi duo, the best in the same hall compared to RG. The song selections are bad. Now-a-days Vachaspathi and slow Anandha Bhairavi are not the raagas for a concert. Mini hall concert singers sing New Raagas and New krithis. I stunned to see unknwown singer in NGS Mini hall singing a full-throat 15 Minutes Kadhanakudhookalam Raag and sing a rare song. Another kid rendered a starter with Devamanohari on Ganapathi.

Just to compare- MB's Malayamarutham-Kannada-Deepakam with Nayaki-Vachaspathi-Anandhabhairavi. RG's Raaga selection and also song... not convincing. Apologise, if iam wrong. RG got double the crowd of MB.

RGs "Vidwat" is extra-ordinary. As Subbudu says- If the Vidwat is good, let them have it at home. In the hall, they should know how to keep the audience busy !!! with some new krithis and innovative Raagas.

sindhu
Posts: 132
Joined: 30 Oct 2006, 15:07

Post by sindhu »

What about DhanyAsi, Saraswathi (sub mains) & ShankarAbharaNam (Main) in a concert? How is the combo?

sbala
Posts: 629
Joined: 30 Jul 2006, 08:56

Post by sbala »

I find nothing wrong with Todi, Anandabhairavi and vachaspati. They just rendered the kriti in AB and did not sing an alapanai. Without comparing them with MB, the sisters deserve the crowd they get as they have forged a unique style that is appealing. I would be very happy if they reduce the length and bring more variety in the tukkadas (like singing a thillana, I've never heard them sing one) and give substantially more time for swaras and neraval, even if it's a 2 hr concert.

As fo kids singing rare ragas, I agree many of them do. IIRC, Abhishek sang a Devamanohari main the other day. Let's see how many of them retain that courage once they become stars.

prashant
Posts: 1658
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:01

Post by prashant »

sbala wrote:Without comparing them with MB, the sisters deserve the crowd they get as they have forged a unique style that is appealing. I would be very happy if they reduce the length and bring more variety in the tukkadas (like singing a thillana, I've never heard them sing one) and give substantially more time for swaras and neraval, even if it's a 2 hr concert.
Very apt comment.

meena
Posts: 3326
Joined: 21 May 2005, 13:57

Post by meena »

Without comparing them with MB,
Who is MB?

vijay
Posts: 2522
Joined: 27 Feb 2006, 16:06

Post by vijay »

Meena - MB = Malladi Brothers

meena
Posts: 3326
Joined: 21 May 2005, 13:57

Post by meena »

OH haha ok.
looks like the golden rule is broken.

rbharath
Posts: 2333
Joined: 05 Feb 2010, 10:50

Post by rbharath »

i personally dont like scales elaborated. I prefer a beautiful elaboration of shankarAbaraNam or bhairavi over an effort to pull out kadanakudukalam or mandhAra varshini for main, which might do nothing to me.

The old heavy ragams have got that status only because they have been time-tested and have something attached to them, to make them get that status. It is not easy to bring other new ragams get that stature.

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Post by vasanthakokilam »

RGs "Vidwat" is extra-ordinary. As Subbudu says- If the Vidwat is good, let them have it at home. In the hall, they should know how to keep the audience busy !!! with some new krithis and innovative Raagas.
grsasthrigal, first of all that is a very harsh thing to say especially when RG exhibit their vidwat to the extent they can. You are basically saying 'Shut up and stay home'. Also, why are you picking on RG on the 'new krithis and innovative raagas' complaint. Very few artists do it. Are you going to be complaining about every artist who does not sing any innovative ragas or sing a new krithi then?

sbala
Posts: 629
Joined: 30 Jul 2006, 08:56

Post by sbala »

Isn't this Todi Krithi rare?

rbharath
Posts: 2333
Joined: 05 Feb 2010, 10:50

Post by rbharath »

sbala wrote:Isn't this Todi Krithi rare?
yup!

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Post by vasanthakokilam »

Thanks bala and bharath. This makes grsasthrigal's comments/rant singling out R&G even more puzzling.

grsastrigal
Posts: 884
Joined: 27 Dec 2006, 10:52

Post by grsastrigal »

I use the simple funda for reviewing a concert. pre-Main, Main-RTP, tukkadas. Main-RTP is always excellant because now-a-days all the senior artists
excel in main as to elaboration, manodharma etc..... Tukkadas are always tukkadas.. half of the hall is empty when tukkadas start or Chits are thrown at the artist, No fun !.

Come to the first part. This 1 to 1.5 hour is the prime-time (for me), where people are very much attentive. They don't have, bus problem,apetitie/arthiritis (!). A senior artist, giving Kandachoodumi or Thyagaraja yoga, is not doing any justice for her/his talent. It is my humble opinion.. I have highest regards for RG. I compared Malladi Brothers because of the variety they gave. by taking Kannada (Raaga alapana) followed by Sree Mathrubhootham, unheared recently and followed by unknown raga (Deepakam). Malayamarutham added beauty to start with.

The same issue I have with Sanjay also. Why repeat the songs in Commercial releases ? Bring something new.

Just to see Vijay Siva's 2 concerts reviewed ... See his variety, number of kritis of unknown/rarely known Composers

ramakriya
Posts: 1877
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 02:05

Post by ramakriya »

vijay wrote:Thanks Ramakriya - the words "Mamava" or "Sathatham" brings ST to mind immediately!
except that Mamava sathatam is a kriti of Tyagaraja in JaganmOhini
:D

Just in jest

-Ramakriya

Jigyaasa
Posts: 592
Joined: 16 May 2006, 14:04

Post by Jigyaasa »

I agree COMPLETELY with shri grsastrigal... Even the other day, MB took up SuruTTi for main, GItArthamu? No! Dikshitar's BAlasubramhmaNyam... They strive to offer something refreshing every time while adhering to time-tested traditions... One needn't sing mandara varshini(never heard of it or heard it) to prove a point... I don't intend to pick on the sisters either. They're very good(in fact, I'm no one really to comment on them) Nor is it probably fair to compare RG with MB... It's just that I think RG tend to play to the gallery these days... They know what brings crowds and they'vw started doling out ever-increasing quantities of it... I myself have heard megh malhar twice in two of the concerts of theirs that I've attended this year, preceded by an artful description of what the song conveys in mildly accented English... I mean I for one wouldn't even mind if there were no tukdasat all... I guess that's goin too far... But nearly 45 min?! OUTRAGEOUS... As put euphemistically, they're not commanding the right kinda crowds from a purist's point of view...

Post Reply