Kiranavali Vidyasankar Narada Gana Sabha Mini Hall (15/12/09

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
uday_shankar
Posts: 1475
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:37

Post by uday_shankar »

Kiranavali V idyasankar - Vocal
Smt Neela Jayakumar - Violin
Shri V R Jayakumar - Mrdangam

Sarasiruhasanapriye amba - Nattai - Adi - ??
Manusuloni marmamu - Hindolam(D2) - Adi - Tyagaraja
Aparamabhakti - Pantuvarali - Rupakam - Tayagaraja
Aanandanatanaprakasam - Mishra Chappu - MD
Ambaparadevathe - Khanda Chappu - Tyagaraja
Shankaracharya - Shankarabharanam - Adi - Subbarama Dikshithar
TheerAdavilayattupilai - Khanda Gati - Bharathiar
SAramaina - Javali - Behag - Swati Tirunal
Tillana - Bindulamini - Adi - Chitravina Ravikiran

A very good concert...the main takeaway was the great restraint and consequent depth and melodiousness of the artist's voice. I wish the tambura were more audible to the audience - especially since there was a real one that was well-tuned and readjusted and fussed over whenever needed by the artist herself. That would have enhanced the tranquil experience even further.

I missed the Nattai kriti and walked in during manasuloni. When I hear a Tyagaraja kriti I am already prejudiced in favor of the concert and it didn't disappoint as we went along. Some other highlights:

* neraval (kapivaridhi dhatuna) and swarams in apparamabhakti were excellent and in the most optimal proportion.

* The majestic gait (or gati :)) of Ananda natana. It was superbly rendered.

* Rudrapriya swarams were reminiscent of a great sahodarar duo of yesteryear and delivered at ambaparadevathe, paradevathe and devathe. Interestingly, Kiranavali's melodiousness and tranquility were not perturbed even by this kriti which may have capacity to awaken the musician's inner aggressor :). Good show.

* Shankarabharanam alapana was very good, delivered along solid classical lines, lingering in the pUrvangam (Sa to Pa) as is my personal preference...in fact I might have liked even more of it. Violinist Smt Neela included some lighter phrasings in her alapana. The neraval and swarams were a tad shorter than I would have liked but I think that was inevitable given the time limits.

* The Bindumalini tillana is a Ravikiran classic that could have been delivered with a little more gusto in the charanam, I thought. Maybe not.

The violinist Smt Neela's support was uniformly good and unintrusive.

The mrdangam player Shri Jayakumar was mostly quite good and he caught the different kalapramanams very well, except during the slower neraval in shankarabharanam when the constant thekka didn't jell well. I hanker after the style of stalwarts like UKS, PR and TS who can "poshak" a slow neraval with a solid, slow thoppi-oriented rhythm. The tani was short and sweet and there and included some tishram variations.

All in all, the song selection was excellent (in other words, according to my taste :)). Also, the diversity of tAlas and rAgas was very good. Last but not the least, a handful of Tyagaraja kritis goes a long way in making a Katcheri experience wholesome.
Last edited by Guest on 16 Dec 2009, 12:27, edited 1 time in total.

ganeshkant
Posts: 963
Joined: 05 Feb 2010, 11:59

Post by ganeshkant »

Does not the D2 version of Hindolam has a name as Varamu ?

108talas
Posts: 120
Joined: 02 Nov 2006, 17:19

Post by 108talas »

Yes D2 version of Hindolam is varamu. The original 'Manasuloni' was in Hindolam/

Rishi Sharma
Posts: 42
Joined: 21 Apr 2009, 15:05

Post by Rishi Sharma »

Sarasiruhasanapriya Amba in Nattai is composed by Puliyur Doraiswamy Iyer.

uday_shankar
Posts: 1475
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:37

Post by uday_shankar »

108talas wrote:The original 'Manasuloni' was in Hindolam/
The "original" Hindolam is in fact "varamu" (I don't know where the word varamu came from).

So Tyagaraja composed the song in the raga called Hindolam, which at the time was sung with D2.

Sometime over the last 200 years, Hindolam has morphed into the D1 version that we are all familiar with. Perhaps people were enthralled by Malkhauns from the north and made this similar to that.

108talas
Posts: 120
Joined: 02 Nov 2006, 17:19

Post by 108talas »

The other trinity MD has used D1 in Nirajakshi. Varmu is the current version to my best knowledge.

108talas
Posts: 120
Joined: 02 Nov 2006, 17:19

Post by 108talas »

The very old 'tamil paN' INDALAM has D1 only. The placement of MK under which is it is being shown is 20 (nata bhairavi) and like NagumOmu (Abheri) the D2 version has edged D1 for Hidolam too.

ganeshkant
Posts: 963
Joined: 05 Feb 2010, 11:59

Post by ganeshkant »

Once during a question in Margazhi maha utsavam (Jaya TV) Hyd.Bros.told Varamu got imported from Hindustani and Saint Tyagaraja composed Manasuloni in Hindolam.

This makes sense since in another post here Rajeshnat has likened Varamu to Bhageshri kind of ragas.Varamu does have a hindustani flavor while D1 version can be sung in both styles without the other's influenze.

The better knowledged ones may comment on this and also someone may tell whether naming a scale has any standards & meaning.

108talas
Posts: 120
Joined: 02 Nov 2006, 17:19

Post by 108talas »

"The better knowledged ones may comment on this"

Means I should not comment. Like D1, I am being ousted :D :D

ganeshkant
Posts: 963
Joined: 05 Feb 2010, 11:59

Post by ganeshkant »

108 talas Oh.. what an intrepretation !

I only welcomed views of members who have better knowledge on this.

Member_First
Posts: 91
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 16:56

Post by Member_First »

108talas,
You have been busy throughout the day, surprisingly. Keep the momentum so forth too.

Do Comment
Don't COME to an END

smriti
Posts: 24
Joined: 17 Dec 2009, 02:20

Post by smriti »

My grandfather attended a concert of 108-ragas by Kiranavali a few years ago and gifted me the CD last year. Ever since then my family has become a fan of this musician. Thanks to jet lag, I missed this concert but my grandfather liked it a lot. He generally likes a traditional approach and format and thought this concert fit the bill perfectly in all respects.

Post Reply