SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by rajeshnat »

SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Vocal : suryaprakash
Violin : Dr narmadA
Mrudangam : neyveli skandasubramaniam
kanjirA : pApanAsam sethurAman
Concert duration : 2 hours and 40 minutes

1A. slOkham "vakrathunda mahAkAya" - mandAri
1B. varnam "vanajAkshi ninnE kOri" - mandAri - mysore vasudevacharya
2. intakannAnandamEmi(R S) - bilahari - T
5 mins alApanai 3 mins violin return
3 mins swaras

3. karuNAlaya nidhiyE (R S)- hindOLam - VedanAyagam Pillai
6 mins alApanai 3 mins violin return
6 mins swaras
4. shree mAthrubhUtam (Raga sketch) -kannada - MD

5A. rAmA neeyeDa(R N S T) - kharaharapriyA - T
14 mins alApanai 8 mins violin return
9 mins neraval in "tana saukhyamu tAnErugaka yorukalu tanu bOdhana sukhamA "
12 mins swaras
5B. tani for 16 mins

6. RTP - dEsh in tishra gathi triputa talam
pallavi line "semmOzhiyAna thamizh mozhiyAm vAzhi vAzhi"
rAga alApanai for 7 mins
tAnam for 8 mins
pallavi with swaras for 8 mins

7. oRu nAl Oru pOzhudAgilum - mishra kamAch - Psivan
8A.narAyaneeyam slokham "yOgEEndranAm" in shyam kalyAn + kAnadA + yamuna kalyAni + navarOz??
8B.krishnA mukundA murArE - navaroz - psivan

9A. viruththam "kunram eRindhaDum" - sindhubhairavi + bhimplAs -thirumurugAtrupadai
9B. kandaN karunai puriyum - bhimplAs -guhan

10A. viruththam "manadhil uRudhi vEndum" - brindAvana sArangA?? + shuruTTi - mahakavi bharathi
10B. shivaperumAn kripai vEndum - shuruTTi - psivan
11. nee nAma rupamulaku - sowrAshtram - T

The month of april and may kind of extended a bit into jUne in chennai , there was a dry spell of concerts . To an extent it has picked up well only from this week end , I could see there are about 3 concerts in yesterday saturday edition of the hindu and about 5 concerts today at sunday.

This sabhA nAyaki is a very nice sabha , it was started about 8 or 9 years back if I am right , they held it at different venues most notably at rAga sudha and for the past 3 or 4 years they have got a very nice hall in a fairly sleepy place of kotturpuram , nice always to see that chennai is spreading away from the mylapore and mambalam. The sabha is nice , with always heavy dose of Airconditioning and there is quite a bit of parking.

This concert of suryaprakAsh had its moments of ahA feel for most of the time , but there were few hiccups that were there in this concert.

Few hiccups:
---------------
1.The sabha patron after giving introduction said his usual mike man is replaced by a new person and to an extent that inexperience was costing the quality of what could have been a better concert. The first varnam with the slOkham was really well done though the violin and vocal was bit loud , the lines of the varnam was in the most overcrowded lines "vanajAkshi", I always wonder how in general musicians sing varnams with this starting lines where there are atleast 5 to 6 varnams in circulation .This varnam is in a rare rAga mandAri , I get so easily confused with amrithavarshini , perhaps as it did not rain outside I made up my mind as mandAri ;) .

2. The choice of bilahari and very close to that the kannada is perhaps not my cup of tea. To me personally this zone of rAgas is not that great and incidentally I also believe ThyagarAja and Dikshitar did not give their best in these two krithis intha kannananda(especially) and shri mAthrubHutam (just a nice one )when compared to so many of their other krithis. I liked the bilahari alApana of Suryaprakash and swaras a lot , but the support of Dr nArmada was bit too rough here. shri MAthrubhUtam was in vilamba kAla mode.

3. Perhaps the biggest hiccup was the play of skanda . He usually plays well , for him the combination of his mike (I wish he had swapped the mike of kanjirA player) and may be he did not tune that well his mrudangam. I found his play not that good, kind of sarvalaghu touch was missing and his anticipation was bit offkey.

Moments of AhA feel:
-----------------------
1. Musicians have a standard rule of thumb.For centuries they either take a single rAga rtp in rAgas that have elaborate scope like say keeravani or shanmughapriyA or when they take few rAgas of little less scope they jump into the bandwagon of rAgamAliga swaras to give the sense of completeness . But suryaprAkash expanding only Desh is indeed bEsh. The emotive syrup and perennial lazy hues of desh was well presented .rAga alApana was very well done with Dr narmada coming up to full form there (the mSg that was missing throughout come out in full swaroopam in desh).TAnam was really superb in all counts , parur discontinous or cut bowing gelled superbly with torrents of sangathis in tAnam .Tanam was non metered for about 3 minutes and then metered for another 4 minutes it was really superb and brilliant.While I was expecting pallavi line "bharatha desam enRu peyar solluvar pagai velluvAr" that he usually sings, he surprised me with this creative line of pallavi , more to the occassion that was nearing .Trikalam was well done in "semmOzhiyAna thamizh mozhiyAm vAzhi vAzhi" with nice round of gripping and fast swaras, the vAzhi vAzhi was used to display a lot of dashing charm in desh.

2. HindOlam krithi was the most complete from r to s with the krithi rendition all uniformly top notch.The style was perhaps taken from GNB where the emphasis was little more in high speed brigha uruttal especially in the line sarva vedha nivotha kArana?? , but during those 7 minutes swaras his manodharmam was in full throttle with very minimal violin return at the end , the creative patterns was at its best not a shade of either mmi or tvs or say other popular hindolam singers like santhanam.His swara kalpana manodharmam easily asserts in each concert

3. Kharaharapriya as a main is generally sung as a XL biggie main and the touch of the rAga here was more like a typical nAdaswara touch , good momentum with no moment of sAg . The neraval and swaras were really superb with some great anticipation and reply by narmada, I would have wished little better support from the mridangist , i didnot hear that much and his anticipation was bit offkey

4. All tukkadas were well done , he kind of went with slokham and viruththam at the beginning of each and every one ,personally the yOgeendrAnam slokham was very well done and it was the best pick(kept me wondering how shyam kalyan is different from hameer kalyAni) . In the murugAtru padai before the start of the resplendent kandan karunai in bhimplas , he took few artistic liberties in singing few viruththam lines like skanda subramaniam(with mridangist in mind) and was well done without sacrificing musical aesthetics. The tukkadas success is typically gauged with minimal or zero audience exodus , all of them stayed to hear them all

Accompanists:
-----------------
Dr narmada showed her class the most in desh , very very fast bowing and her glides were at times superb . One keeps wondering her class in a typical cm-hm boundary rAgas are not matching that much with pure CM rAgas like bilahari.

SkandA , usually plays much better than what he did ,mediocrity bug bit him , sethurAman provided support that was good most of the time. I did not enjoy their tani that much

pallavi especially tAnam, hindoLam entire krithi, neraval and swaras of kharaharapriya were the top picks.Overall a very good to excellent concert for 2 hours and 40 minutes.

Nick H
Posts: 9472
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 02:03

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by Nick H »

I always enjoy Suryaprakash's performances, and this was no exception, so any criticism is in the context that I came away happy and well satisfied!

As rajeshnat commented, the sound engineering (as is so often the case) gave some problems in the initial part of the concert, but I have heard very much worse, even continuing throughout a program! The engineers mixing board is a bewildering array of knobs and sliders, and I only know what some of them do. The greater number of sound problems are caused by too much or too little volume, or by bad balance of the microphones, either hurting our ears, or, perhaps, sending the vocalist into the background. Intuition would suggest, even to us novices, that the sliders would be the thing here, and I think that is right, although there is an important little knob on each channel called "gain".

Less recognised is the importance of the tonal controls, eg treble, mid, bass. Often the problem is a booming sound, with no clarity --- too much bass. In this concert, the mid and bass were lacking, at first, making SP's voice sound light and shallow. The bass remained too high on the kanjira for the whole of the concert, and too low on the right side of the mridangam: we got the rhythm, but not the tonal quality of the instrument.

It is far from unusual for the first couple of songs to be spent adjusting levels: let us not be too hard on yesterday's engineer!

For me, the first part of the concert was superb, my favourite being song no. 3. I only wish SP had extended the alapana for this one by 50%!

I always welcome an RTP, and some time ago, when we met at another program, SP told me that he always includes one. I wish it had been longer! I have been wondering about RTP recently: I love the R and the T, and of course, the S, and N if present, but have been wondering how to better appreciate the P itself! It seems to me to be so much an exercise in mathematics. Perhaps one has to have a better understanding of lyric and raga to truly appreciate it. I am not fond of the recipe tanam+tala+mridangam: the tanam has such a unique presentation of melody and number, I would rather not see it tied down by tala, and I would rather hear it free of accompaniment. That is my preference and it does not mean I didn't enjoy SP's tanam --- in fact, his free-flowing voice seemed particularly suited to the way he chose to present it. I wish the swara section had been 50 to 100% longer!

There was no single song in the last part of the concert that I did not enjoy, but I did feel a slight lack of coherence in this part. I notice a few As and Bs in Rajeshnat's listng, and I wonder if this is what gave me that impression.

I have been regularly missing Suryaprakash's concerts this past year or so: mental not made not to do this in the future! :)

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by arasi »

Rajesh and Nick,
Thanks for the review.

Rajesh,
Surya's voice and verve are his assets. A concert with RTP and nearly three hours of a concert! He can certainly sing an emotive dES. I do not remember which song he sang last season in dES to Dr. Narmada's accompaniment, but he sang it so well and Narmada's playing was impeccable. I hear strains of her playing even now in my mind.

Nick,
Bless you, you're blossoming into a full time critic. If you say, 'I wish I had started appreciating CM as a kid', I'd say it's never too late. Take heart that at my age, I'm still trying to learn more. Your sound ideas are very sound. May be, we should use Rajesh's scale for sound too: if it reaches the 'good' point in any concert, we luck out! Wish others can emulate your stoicism too (which you possess alongside your impatience!) in the enjoyment of a concert riddled with plaguing sound problems!

rshankar
Posts: 13754
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:26

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by rshankar »

Rajesh - 9a - kunRam erindADum? or kunRam ninRADum? or kunRam ERi ninRADum?

bilahari
Posts: 2631
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:02

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by bilahari »

Thanks, Rajesh and Nick. I have a high opinion of Narmada's playing and don't think her class is limited to HM-esque ragas either, so I'm surprised she wasn't up to the mark in this concert. Everybody has off days, though.

Nick H
Posts: 9472
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 02:03

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by Nick H »

Arasi... what about my unsound ideas?

I have a few... ;)

I just got back from hearing Amritha Murali sing, and it was one of the best concerts I have ever heard. I wish the team had been there to post the details.

I have had a great musical weekend!

Enna_Solven
Posts: 827
Joined: 18 Jan 2008, 02:45

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by Enna_Solven »

Nick H wrote: I have had a great musical weekend!
:envy:

rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by rajeshnat »

Nick H wrote: The bass remained too high on the kanjira for the whole of the concert, and too low on the right side of the mridangam: we got the rhythm, but not the tonal quality of the instrument.
....
There was no single song in the last part of the concert that I did not enjoy, but I did feel a slight lack of coherence in this part. I notice a few As and Bs in Rajeshnat's listng, and I wonder if this is what gave me that impression.
Nick
With your knowledge and you being soundphile,I wish you walked up and adjusted atleast the right side of the mrudangam .

Nick on A and B .I just put numbers like 8A and 8B so that I dont double count the numbers , viruththams (in thamizh)or slokhams(in sanskrit) or ugabhoogas(in kannada) are without percussion and more showcases the language and emote with only rAga bhAvam.

cienu
Posts: 2392
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 11:40

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by cienu »

Great review Rajesh .

fduddy
Posts: 243
Joined: 07 Jun 2010, 18:16

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by fduddy »

rajeshnat wrote: 2. The choice of bilahari and very close to that the kannada is perhaps not my cup of tea. To me personally this zone of rAgas is not that great and incidentally I also believe ThyagarAja and Dikshitar did not give their best in these two krithis intha kannananda(especially) and shri mAthrubHutam (just a nice one )when compared to so many of their other krithis. I liked the bilahari alApana of Suryaprakash and swaras a lot , but the support of Dr nArmada was bit too rough here. shri MAthrubhUtam was in vilamba kAla mode.
I am not sure what is your level of understanding / authority to make an open ended statement on these 2 kritis. shri MAthrubhUtam is a MASTERPIECE of MD. Perhaps you are devoid of not having the opportunity to listen to some of the spectacular rendition of these kritis especially by old masters or it is your own assessment / conclusions in stating so ;(

Sugegst you listen to SSI to appreciate this kriti better :tmi:

Also in Suryaprakash's music, I doubt if there is any influence of nagaswaram style. Any takers !

Why should Karaharapriya be treated like an XL biggie !!. The beauty of the raga can be showcased in a matter of 5-10 minutes (listen to Ariyakudi's renditions) or with a rendition over 30 minutes you would not know what the musician is singing (I do not intend naming artists for this :) ). I think it is a myth that beauty of a raga can showcased only by singing for 20 mins or 30 mins or so. Great artists like Ramnad, Ariyakudi, Voleti, SSI, MSS, MDR have sung alapanas in an extremely measured manner and brining out the complete spectrum of the raga in that limited time.

Nick H
Posts: 9472
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 02:03

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by Nick H »

rajeshnat ... I have to confess that it is easy to talk and pretty tough to do... once one gets involved with those knobs, a great mess can so easily result!

Also, because my hearing is bad for high frequencies, I tend to demand more in that area, and also find it very hard to hear what someone is saying to me, if music is going on --- not to mention my language deficiencies.

rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: SuryaprakAsh@nAyaki(kotturpuram)on June 19th,2010

Post by rajeshnat »

fduddy wrote: Why should Karaharapriya be treated like an XL biggie !!. The beauty of the raga can be showcased in a matter of 5-10 minutes (listen to Ariyakudi's renditions) or with a rendition over 30 minutes you would not know what the musician is singing (I do not intend naming artists for this :) ). I think it is a myth that beauty of a raga can showcased only by singing for 20 mins or 30 mins or so.
I was only talking about the concert and typically all musicians detail out kharaharapriyA as a main little more than other main krithis .Hence I called it as XL biggie. That is all.

Post Reply