Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
suma
Posts: 516
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 23:56

Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by suma »

Ranjani gayatri concert
vasanthakokilam wrote:Some Additional info

- Started with Evari Bhodana - Abogi varnam
- The Aarabhi song was "Sri Saraswati namOsthuthe"
- The third song was in raga mandhAri. ninnu jeppa kAraNamEmi manasA, Patnam Subramanya Iyer.
- missed these songs - Thanks Vasanthakokilam.

came in during this alapana:
raga mandhAri. ninnu jeppa kAraNamEmi manasA, Patnam Subramanya Iyer.
Putnam subramania iyer song, swaram, electrifying swarams
vazhi maRaittirukkudE- nattakurunji
Keeravani alapana
Kaligiyunte, niravel, swaram
Thani avartanam
Ninnada - kannada
RTP - khamas alapana
Tanam
Kanda jati triputa tala
Brocheva revarura ninu vina raghuvamsa deepa o rama

Battery almost gone
Rest later

Full house. Jam packed spellbound audience. Pindrop silence. Great concert
Last edited by suma on 25 Oct 2010, 19:49, edited 4 times in total.

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by arasi »

Suma,
Waiting for the next part! Your song list and the short dramatic note reminds me of the telegraphic messages of war time correspondents ;)

vazhi maRaittirukkudE

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by vasanthakokilam »

Some Additional info

- Started with Evari Bhodana - Abogi varnam
- The Aarabhi song was "Sri Saraswati namOsthuthe"
- The third song was in raga mandhAri. ninnu jeppa kAraNamEmi manasA, Patnam Subramanya Iyer.
I did not know any thing about mandhAri and during the alapana I thought it was pantuvarAli, silly me!! But later found out it is dha-less pantuvarALi. Felt not so silly. The alapana for mandhAri was fairly elaborate and well done. The song itself did not have much of an overlap with pantuvarali but since it was sung in a brisk pace, it is hard to tell. It was like many of the fast desAdi tala songs of Thyagaraja. It is interesting they chose to sing an elaborate and leisurely alapana for this song. No complaints, the alapana was done well. As Suma mentioned, the swaras were quite brisk in line with the pace of the song.

Continuing with where suma left off

- Viruththam - kAdalahi kasindu kaNNIr malhi

( my phone went dead with zero battery power left, so no further notes )

From memory
- kA vA vA - varALi ( based on audience request )
- Thukkaram abhang - raga bhatiar
- mangaLam

The sisters have a very pliable voice and they put that to great use. They are very easy on the ears. I think they specially work on voice dynamics, when to project it and when to hold back. Then Panan wondered about this in another thread and I suggest he checks on the sisters to see if that is a good example on the CM side. Their voice modulation was quite different for Vazhi maraithirukkude and kA vA vA ( appropriately so resulting in good aesthetics ) where they held back considerably whereas in other places especially in RTP neraval and swara sequences they let it loose.

The mridangist (Delhi S. Sairam) knows how to play for them!! He builds up the crescendo as the two keep rolling with swaras and kOrvais. The audience responds very well to the overall effect provided by such build up augmented by mridangist of Sairam's kind. As a case in point, after the sisters got a rousing applause for one such segment in the RTP ragamalika swaras, the violinist H.N. Bhaskar responded very well but of course he does not have the overall power of the singers, but Sairam sensed that and compensated for that with his loud and brisk strokes and the audience again responded with much appreciation.

In terms of depth of effort, kiravANi alapana and the song stood out.

A very good concert. Very stylized presentation. Quite entertaining with a couple of 'a ha' moments

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by vasanthakokilam »

Two concerts in one day is quite rare for me. ( the other one today was Vijayalakshmy Subramaniyam ). I do not even remember if I had sat through two in one day, ever.

Interesting to note that in both concerts, there were no songs from the big five ragas, for main or for RTP but still they managed to portray full fledged concert experience. ( there was no sub-main which some may quibble about but RTP is the reward ). And with navaraga malika varnam and various ragamalikas, they probably sang around 30 ragas counting both concerts. Quite a tapestry and palette of melodic motifs. Only in CM!!

ganeshkant
Posts: 963
Joined: 05 Feb 2010, 11:59

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by ganeshkant »

arasi wrote:Suma,
Waiting for the next part! Your song list and the short dramatic note reminds me of the telegraphic messages of war time correspondents ;)

vazhi maRaittirukkudE


To me Suma's reviews look like "Pudhu Kavidhai" ( modern poetry)

rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by rajeshnat »

vasanthakokilam wrote: Continuing with where suma left off

- Viruththam - kAdalahi kasindu kaNNIr malhi

( my phone went dead with zero battery power left, so no further notes )


.....
Quite entertaining with a couple of 'a ha' moments
Spring Cuckoo (If I am allowed to borrow that from arasi)
YOu guys are listening too few concerts , you need to take a paper and pen and leave the gadget and battery at home. Now I am worried why concerts are slowly getting reduced in time, because the rasikAS battery goes to zero. My Laptop has only 20 minutes charge ;) , possibly that will be the norm in the year 2025.

Just interested in that last phrase of yours , was that "A hA" or just "a ha". You are one of the best communicators in this forum , I am assuming you are holding your explanation of couple of 'a ha' .

vasanthakokilam
Posts: 10958
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 00:01

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by vasanthakokilam »

Rajesh, :)

it was A hA indeed, or more of 'ch ch ch.. inducing'. One middle-aged gentleman on the next aisle one row back just about lost it in rapture when the sisters announced the abhang and again upon the first nano second of them singing that abhang!! That alone is hundred times more in intensity than a few of my 'A hA.. ch ch ch' moments in other places. That gentleman also had many non-rapturous 'A hA' moments throughout the concert.

My own were a couple of places in Vazhi maraiththirukkude where they sang with some emotion in their voice ( not done artificially or overdone ), and kA vA vA where they held on plainly and steadily to a 'close enough to Sa' note beautifully before resolving to Sa.

There were a couple of places in kIravANi alapana as well which attracted my attention. That is more because I look for some romanticism in the interpretation of this raga (hard to explain, that is the closest word ). Not that this raga is normally sung that way since the songs in this raga adapt it for different emotions, but I always felt this raga has that potential. In their alapana, I saw some glimpses of that possibility.

Overall, their impeccable swarasthana suddham, singing to their strengths, voice dynamics, just about maximizing the 'power of duo' to good effect carried them through.

If I nit-pick, it will be their kamAs. There were definitely places where the well known phrases are sung where kamAs was alive and well, but there were quite a few stretches where it was quite generic. Especially the thAnam.. May be it is difficult to bring out kamAs in thAnam singing.

Their kalpanaswaras for kamAs can be better, though they made up for it plenty with their sheer energy and enthusiasm in their singing aided by an equally adventurous and boisterous mridangist.. Being a duo, it helps a lot in that energy department and they can string together long stretches of kalpanaswaras at high speed since they alternate even at that high speed ( not that it is easy and they execute it well ). There was also a bit of novelty ( for me, may be not for you all, I do not attend a lot of live concerts ). In that high speed kamAs kalpanaswara section, they sang the word 'raghuvamsa' at the right place in the thala cycle where raghuvamsa would have been. Hope you get the picture, otherwise I will explain further. It all added to the excitement and entertainment value just on the mechanics of it and the overall sound environment it created. But kamAs itself was not the focus during those sections.

rajeshnat
Posts: 10121
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 08:04

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by rajeshnat »

vasanthakokilam wrote: it was A hA indeed, or more of 'ch ch ch.. inducing'. One middle-aged gentleman on the next aisle one row back just about lost it in rapture when the sisters announced the abhang and again upon the first nano second of them singing that abhang!! That alone is hundred times more in intensity than a few of my 'A hA.
Two kinds of bang happens in the last 100 years from ariyakudi days, both happens in the first nano second.

One is a truck driver overtaking in a road in the middle of the night where there is a bang when he collides with another opposite vehicle in that first nano second.

The other is the middle-aged gentleman that you are referring to when he hears that a bhang in the first nano second.

just kidding vk ;) ;) , by any chance was arun sitting one row in front of you so that he can tell us the real exact intensity of the rasika one row behind him :)

bhavarasa
Posts: 75
Joined: 11 Nov 2009, 02:57

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by bhavarasa »

Sairam's mridangam was good for the carnatic pieces but I think he could have been a bit more subtle for the abhang. I like Arun Prakash's mridangam in that scenario. He knows when to tone it down and when to drive home the point.

Ninnu Jeppa is a favorite of Lalgudi mama. He too renders it at quite a brisk pace.

suma
Posts: 516
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 23:56

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by suma »

Felt like giving a running commentry during the concert like how they do for cricket :-)
So tried it yesterday.

For me, the khamas was very neatly done. Althougth the kalpana swarams for the unfamiliar raga was also captivating.

cmlover
Posts: 11498
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 22:36

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by cmlover »

VK
I find quite a bit of similarity with their very well-recieved Ottawa concert which Our Rasikas enjoyed thoroughly. For example the arabhi, khamas and even the abhang (I am sure Ranjani even took time to explain the meaning !). I am sure they tried to repiicate and succeeded. The keeravani must have been divineespecially with the voice potential of Gayatri! I have difficulty distingushing the ch.ch.ch from che.che.che :D ; if it was the latter then it must have been the ghost of Harimau :D
I can understand your Ahas since I was in thhe same phase throughout their concert. The team has the magic of getting the audience involved through their music as well as stage manners. My only complaint about Sairam is that he gets carried away and then he matches in decibels Bhaktavatsalam which even my poor hearing cannot tolerate!

cmpassion
Posts: 8
Joined: 06 Apr 2010, 19:38

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by cmpassion »

Quote
"Continuing with where suma left off

- Viruththam - kAdalahi kasindu kaNNIr malhi
"

You missed the mesmerizing "idhu dhaano thillai sthalam" (behaag) after the Viruththam.
Fabulous concert, as usual.

bhavarasa
Posts: 75
Joined: 11 Nov 2009, 02:57

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by bhavarasa »

KeeravAni was very good. Gayatri's AlApanai was bright and filled with brisk brighAs. Neraval at bhAguga shrI Raghu rAmuni pAdamUla was apt - though not as elaborate as I'd have liked. Every time I hear that, I yearn for KVN's neraval (12/30/1967 MMA). That was ethereal.

suma
Posts: 516
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 23:56

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by suma »

Although I am a fan of Ranjani Gayatri and look forward for their concerts, for vazhi maRaittirukkudE, when they sang, I missed Sanjay Subramaniam. I heard him live last year singing this song in chicago and I can still feel the song. It was so beautifully sung by Sanjay Subramaniam.

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: Ranjani Gayatri, Chicago, 24th Oct. 2010

Post by arasi »

Suma,
You mean, 'Subrahmanyan'?
Hope you get the drift. 'Endless ways of spelling a name' was talked about in another thread, even Lakshman joining in the fun ;)

CML,
Will surely miss you during the season :(
As for me, I count my lucky stars and hope to have the energy to take in as many concerts as possible.

Spring Cuckoo,
Rajesh is right. How many details go into that bound note book of his!

As for R&G, the first time I heard them sing bhUt mOTE, I was swept away by the emotional impact of the piece, and yes, Gayathri's intro leads you into the mood of the song.

Post Reply