2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
badari
Posts: 507
Joined: 14 Feb 2009, 10:03

2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by badari »

Vocal: Vid. Sanjay Subrahmanyan
Violin: Vid.MysoreMNagaraj
Mridanga: Vid. KUJayachandraRao
Morsing: Vid. B. Rajashekar

Occasion: RLKM SpringFest

01 satura kAmini dEva tamyati sakala (tv) kalyANi Adi swAti thirunAL

02 gIti chakra ratha stithayai guruguhAnuta shyAmalAya kannaDa Chapu m.dIkshitar (O, S)

03 vana durge vanaspati vanaspati rUpaka muttiah bhagavatar (A, N, S)

04 kAlai tUkki ninrADum daivamE yadukulakAmbOdhi marimuttu pillai

05 koluvamaregadA kOdaNDapANi tOdi Adi thyAgarAja (A, N, S , T)

06 maneyoLagAdO gOvindha abhOgi Adhi puranDharadhAsa

07 rAga tAna pallavi kEdAragauLa. khaNDa Eka
Pallavi Line: tANDavam Adum tillai naTarAjam ... tajham takhajam... takiTajham
Ragamalika - Anandabhairavi, pantuvarALi, kadanakutUhala

08 nirupamAna sAmi nI nA nilayamunaku bEhAg RUpaka pUchi shrInivAsa IyengAr (O)

09 ennAmo vaghaiyai varugude mane khamAs Adi Ghanam Krishna Iyer

10 palukute nela talli AbhEri k.cApu aNNammAchAryA

11 rAmanai bhajittAl mAND Adi pApanAsam sivan

12 nInAma rUpamulaku mangaLa sourAshtra Adhi thyAgarAja

This concert needs a special review and cannot be done in haste. The concert will remain in the minds of Rasikas for a long time to come :)


gardabha_gana
Posts: 1033
Joined: 24 Dec 2006, 07:44

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by gardabha_gana »

Fabulous concert. Thoughts:

1. Nice to see Nagaraj, one of my fav accompanists join Sanjay. So nice to see someone other than Varadu/Venkatesh accompany Sanjay. I am a fan of V/V - but it is nice to have variety. Sabhas should regain control over the team IMO. It was a delight to see Nagaraj/Sanjay applaud each other...
2. Thrilled to hear Koluvamaragadha - my fav thodi krithi, especially the last sangathi, rarely sung these days. Also, Sanjay usually pulls out even rarer krithis. I was worried that there may not be a neraval as it happened the last 2 blr concerts.
3. As usual, Sanjay started with a new (at least to me) varnam. Starting with a varnam is a taboo these days.....You can witness that today :)
4. Not so common songs in Kannada and YK, YK itself is not common. Vanaspati was a welcome elaboration
5. Very nice RTP in a beautiful KG. Thodi and KG - Nagaraj and Sanjay were outdoing each other (in a good way)
6. Percussion support Jayachandra Rao/Rajshekar was very apt.
7. Krishnaprasad sir announced that next year, the national award will be conferred on Sanjay!
8. Met arasi m'am at the end

Overall as badari said the concert will be in memory for a long time....

kvchellappa
Posts: 3636
Joined: 04 Aug 2011, 13:54

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by kvchellappa »

Fringe comments:
Sanjay's first stroke of Alapana brought the entire raga before you. A commoner like me could identify the raga at the first stroke (Thodi, KG, Abhogi). The singers must be perfect in swarasthanas and that is what makes their music appealing. Doyens like DKJ, Nedunuri, Voleti did nothing for effect, just stuck to singing true to grammar, and their music lingers in our minds.
Sanjay started the concert at 5.46, the time shown by the clock in the auditorium. Somehow I am a stickler and Sanjay pleases me by his keeping time, which is a mark of respect to the audience. It was straight into varnam, no fuss about anything.
Sanjay is all action and appreciation on the stage. He reads the minds of the audience. When he started on vanaspati, I thought there was a flash of KHP, but it was not. My wife said rather confident-looking 'Ganamurthi'. As she spots ragas better, I acquiesced. Sanjay ended wrong guesses and announced the name of the raga. Similarly, when in RTP he started on PV, he either saw quizzical looks on some faces or heard some whisper in front row, and announced 'PV thaan'. It was so melodious and there was something new he did, which perhaps only he can.
He tore Thodi to myriad pieces and the beauty was each piece had the full thodi in it (reminding me of poornamadh poornamidam..). His jerks and shrugs of shoulders appeared to herald what gamakams to expect.
When thani started, there was no noticeable shuffling one normally encounters, for two reasons, I thought. One was it was at the mid-point, and the other, who would want to miss Sanjay after Thani, particularly his trademark RTP? I wonder why all artists cannot make way for thani in the middle of the concert. When it is at the end, people who come from a distance and have no private conveyance, have to leave. There is no point in blaming the audience. Thani was short and good. The entire concert had a sense of proportion. Sanjay paid tributes to Ariyakkudi as it were by presenting a soulful, aesthetic (in my lay understanding) and creative concert within the format. I am less and less convinced that the format affects the music one has to offer. Rasikas who attend today may have something different to say.
Sanjay's music was so absorbing that the seasonal Bangalorean throat clearing and cough around, and the audible whispers of some ladies behind did not get into the mind quite.
Thalaivar thalaivar thaan (remembering Mudaliar).
Possibly, even Harimau might have enjoyed it as tup tup did not figure!

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by arasi »

Even if I were Harimau, even with a few what he calls 'tup tups' (which were not there), I can't in the world imagine what he finds wanting in a concert of Sanjay. Knowing his stringent standards in good CM, it escapes me. As we read the above reviews, it only reassures me that a thalaivar we have, in vidvat, imagination, diligence and hard work. A practicing professional in the fullest sense.

The Swati varNam simply rocked (again, how many have taken up something which most of us weren't even aware of, a mega piece). Prince Ramavarma was there, relishing it as much as we did. It was a kalyANi sung with all the respect it commanded.
Just varNam, and already it was a filling fare.

KannaDa charmed, as always. tODi, I have no words to describe its quality (please, spare me the expression 'nAdasvaram piDIs'). It was like listening to a nAdasvaram (not in its imitative sounds) but in its grandeur and depth. Yes, depth is the word and the very thing we sometimes take for granted with Sanjay who shines in it.

Ragams simply cascaded out of Sanjay, and neraval and svarams.

That vanaspathi was butter unto bAla krishnA! The first few strains made me think of gAnamUrthi too, but pariyAchakamA? came to mind. And the svarams! muzhangai vazhivAra? (tiruppAvai, ghee dripping down one's elbow with sakkare pongalu :)

kEdaragowLa was an essay in all its appealing aspects. No getting carried away with gimmicks or far out flights. Its beauty was contained, and yet was as fresh as you could imagine.

To sum up, the concert had every ingredient you expect and hope for in a concert. Content, concentration, creative mode which didn't flag, a judicious combination of rAgAs and compositions.

My only regret: not even one vitutham :( Thalaivar (leader)'s tAnam and viruthams are most looked forward to by many.

Nagaraj's expertise cannot be questioned, and I had not heard him in a while as a violinist in a vocal concert (the brothers are busy playing duets and fusion these days). He was his sparkling self, but I have to admit, I went back a decade or more ago, when his violin had honey sounds, making a concert that much more special. The bhAvam part of it naturally is a bit less now, because of all the speedy playing which his present day concerts demand. Still, a masterly player.

I liked the mridangam sound, like Rajashekar's morsing, but really missed a khanjari or ghatam in the concert. Yes, I did. Rajashekhar would have been a welcome addition, but the morsing alone didn't wing it for me. How much more the concert would have appealed to us, I thought with either. On the other hand, just Venkatesh's mridangam would have been sufficient for me, my not missing a khanjari or ghatam.

Thanks to Sanjay for making my (farewell?) concert a treat, before I head back home...

Badari, missed you again, and Chellappa and your wife too :(

gardabha_gana
Posts: 1033
Joined: 24 Dec 2006, 07:44

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by gardabha_gana »

When Vanaspati alapana started - I was reminded of Pariyachakama (Santhanam version especially) didn't know it was vanaspati :) I do agree with you m'am. There were occasions where Nagaraj was on the "speed" mode - and it was like a flip to his duets. I do hope he accompanies more often - in the 80s he was a regular and did raise the concerts to a different level. I do remember Sanjay saying in Nadasurabhi festival few years back - "Ivar vasikkira madari yenakku paDa mudiyadu" (pardon my tamil) :) I was indeed very happy to hear him with Sanjay y'day. All in all - a fabulous concert, these are the times I wonder that staying in India has its pluses.

gardabha_gana
Posts: 1033
Joined: 24 Dec 2006, 07:44

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by gardabha_gana »

Also, I think the varnam was a pada varnam.

hnbhagavan
Posts: 1664
Joined: 21 Jun 2008, 22:06

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by hnbhagavan »

As learned Rasikas have pointed out,the concert was an exceptional and one that even lay rasikas could enjoy.One cannot fathom why Harimau has a problem in Sanjay's concerts.
The accompaniment of Sri Nagaraj to say the least was fantastic and was a welcome change from the usual combination with Varadarajan.Varadarajan also is an a very good accompanist and only one looks it as a change when someone else equally competent but with a different style.
Jayachandra rao on Mridangam and Rajasekhar on Morsing gave good support.
I could not spot any tup tup ,but once there was a dadada sound heard.
He made the concert very lively even after the main song - in Todi with RTP starting in Kedaragowla .
I spotted Prince Ramaverma when he turned up minutes before the concert and stayed till the end.

munirao2001
Posts: 1334
Joined: 28 Feb 2009, 11:35

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by munirao2001 »

HNBhagvan,

I was not able to attend the concert of Sri SS, yesterday. I do not agree that Varadarajan is 'equally competent' to Mysuru Nagaraj. Mysuru Nagaraj is a much more accomplished Violinist and Vidwan and also very much Senior to Varadarajan.

HNB,ARASI, BADARI, OTHERS, IF ANY

I have planned to attend to-day's concert. Can we meet over a coffee, after securing and reserving the seat, well before the commencement of the concert? If yes, we meet at the coffee shop at 5.15 p.m.

munirao2001

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by arasi »

Munirao,
I am afraid I have some other commitment today :( I missed seeing Bhagwan tooyesterday.

Gardhaba_gana might be there, and by the cofffee/badam milk, tiNDi counter (he knows I kid him about it!).
KPJayan is out of town perhaps, and squims wasn't spotted either. Sappri was there yesterday, so was gnaanam :)

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by arasi »

Another thing I noticed. There was a considerable number of young folks in the auditorium, making the balding graying majority a little inconspicuous. A good sign :)

hnbhagavan
Posts: 1664
Joined: 21 Jun 2008, 22:06

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by hnbhagavan »

Dear Sri Munirao,

Mysore Nagaraj definitely is a more accomplished violinist,but i tend to agree with Madam arasi that there is a tendency for speedy playing.This may be the effect of fusion concerts and the violin duet concerts with Brother Sri Manjunath.My feeling is that it used to very melodious a few years back as compared to the present style.But overall his accompaniment to sri Sanjay was of high order and accurate anticipation.
Today i will not be attending due to some domestic engagement,but will attend Sri Abhishek's concert on Feb 6.
I would have loved to meet Madam Arasi and others,but there was hardly any scope for mobility as the hall was full.

gardabha_gana
Posts: 1033
Joined: 24 Dec 2006, 07:44

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by gardabha_gana »

I will not be attending too.. Re: thindi - y'day the quality of thindi was a bit down. The masala vadas were taken out a little early - thanks to the demand. The bajjis were good. The thindi is the (main) attraction for my kids (and me) in addition to the concert :) - In fact, I asked for which singer did they sell the most bajjis - the winner (a few years back) was TMK. Now probably it will be Bombay Jayashree/Abhisek/RaGa

munirao2001
Posts: 1334
Joined: 28 Feb 2009, 11:35

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by munirao2001 »

Arasi and HNBhagvan

On the 'fast' playing of Mysuru Nagaraj, this technique was intended primarily for commanding the applause, even though it show cases the mastery of the instrument technique. The tro of LS/LV/LVM, with their learning and achieving mastery in plying western music, adopted it to CM and achieved immense popularity. Their popularity resulted many aspiring Vidwans to achieve popularity, taken to this ( "thalai suthra-PMI" ). This is even resorted to by the Vidwans-mridangam. Ganesh and Kumaresh, Nagaraj and Manjunath, Ambi Subramanyam have shown a great obsession to this aspect, joining their role models, rasikas excited and supporting. Only discerning rasikas, like you, humble self and many more, truly are disgusted and dejected.

Few years back, VVK's Ramanavami Sangeetha Utsava at Basaveshwaranagar, Mysuru Nagaraj and Praveen Godkind's jugalbandi concert took place. MN was indulging in this new found love, affecting aesthetic, uncaring with focus only on rasikas applause. I simply walked out, MN & PG taking note.

munirao2001

Rsachi
Posts: 5039
Joined: 31 Aug 2009, 13:54

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by Rsachi »

When a concert elicits such an aesthetic discussion and appreciation by some many great rasikas, it surely scores big on concert success! Kudos to Sanjay the superstar among present-day stars.

I have found Mysore Nagaraj intolerably harsh/rough on occasion. But he can still produce honeyed sound if he wants. Listen to the recent Parvathi upload!

Rsachi
Posts: 5039
Joined: 31 Aug 2009, 13:54

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by Rsachi »

When a concert elicits such an aesthetic discussion and appreciation by so many great rasikas, it surely scores big on concert success! Kudos to Sanjay the superstar among present-day stars.

I have found Mysore Nagaraj intolerably harsh/rough on occasion. But he can still produce honeyed sound if he wants. Listen to the recent Parvathi upload!

braindrain
Posts: 587
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 09:25

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by braindrain »

arasi wrote:Munirao,
KPJayan is out of town perhaps :)
Not really. I was there, high up , almost hitting the roof, in the balcony... After a long gap back to attending concerts , the first of the year, and what a way to begin.

I echo your take on morsing. It probably wasn't sufficient yesterday and that made KUJ to chip in more often. Also, I may be the only one among here who did hear some of the MMI inspired alapana phrases in thODi and a few 'tagugugu' in tAnam. But, a fabulous treat indeed.

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by arasi »

MMI surely was there for a fleeting moment, no 'harimau heard' sounds.I noticed it too. And how we as kids loved those phrases when MMI indulged in them! The 'tagugugu's as you aptly put were there in the tAnam. Had the violin been a bit mellower, the tAnam would have been even more absorbing.

Another thing. 'A violinist as an accompanist' is what I had in mind. Varadarajan is one of the few who fits that role perfectly. A violinist in a vocal concert as an ace accompanist depends upon how he supports the main artiste (which Nagaraj did so well) and how he follows and inspires the vocalist (which Varadu excels in). I heard Varadu several times this season--playing for Sanjay and for his guru TVG. What mellifluousness!

Jayan,
Sorry, I missed you--may be because I didn't have to wait at the curbside for long...

gardabha_gana
Posts: 1033
Joined: 24 Dec 2006, 07:44

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by gardabha_gana »

Ahan.... I looked around for you Jayan - and also checked your website - no review, assumed you have taken a long break. I did see badari - he was on the other half in the same aisle. Jayan - do post if you attend any of the others this week.


arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by arasi »

Thanks, Kunthalavarali. Sanjay's newly chosen (?) piece for the Swathi festival this year.

It sounded even better,as he sang it yesterday.

kvchellappa
Posts: 3636
Joined: 04 Aug 2011, 13:54

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by kvchellappa »

Review in The Hindu today:
The most striking thing about a Sanjay Subramaniam concert is the investment he brings into his music. Totally bowled over by the beauty of the raga, the brilliance of the composition, the possibilities it offers, Sanjay is constantly reacting to the essence of music not merely as a practitioner, but also as a connoisseur of music. As a listener watches Sanjay involved in the essence of music, it is impossible to disengage from the intensity of his interest.

Sanjay sang the fourth melakarta Vanaspathi, a raga of highly vakra nature. The raga, which bore close resemblance to Ganamurthe in its descending scale, was rendered with passionate intensity. The refreshingly charming raga, replete with gamakas was uplifted by Mysore Nagaraj’s extraordinary violin support. His treatment was nuanced and unhurried enhancing the beauty of the kriti “Vanadurge Vanaspathi”, which Sanjay sang beautifully. Sanjay’s exposition of Todi was breathtaking – chaste, detailed and unswerving from the idiom of tradition. As a musician Sanjay is capable of enormous virtuosity, but this musician hardly succumbs to moments of temptation when intelligence overshadows emotion. His “Koluvamaraigada” was a rendition to remember, with the neraval at “Jeluvanda badacu”” being a volley of ideas. The commitment of musicians like Sanjay to the Carnatic music form is something that the listener feels grateful for.

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by sureshvv »

Review in The Hindu today wrote: Sanjay sang the fourth melakarta Vanaspathi, a raga of highly vakra nature.
Hmm... Looks like the street usage of the term :-)

arasi
Posts: 16873
Joined: 22 Jun 2006, 09:30

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by arasi »

You are saying, isn't it more like soft 'vasanpathi' than a rAgA of 'highly vakra nature?' :)

Other than that, a very good review.

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: 2015 Feb 03 Sanjay SUbrahmanyan and Team @ SRLKM Spring Fest

Post by sureshvv »

The raga, which bore close resemblance to Ganamurthe in its descending scale
Another dubious description. But otherwise good :-)

Post Reply