STDS - Same Tune Different Song

[ajaysimha]

Hi rasikas,

Here is one more interesting topic to discuss.
We might have found many songs in Carnatic that have same tunes (Varna mettu )
Let's list them

To begin ...

Gananyakam bhajeham
Sri manini manohara
In rudhrapriya/purna shadjam

Singara velavan Vandana
Kanoonjal adi irundal
In andhabhairavi

Suma sayaka
Sarasa ninnu
In kapi

Bhaghyada Lakshmi
Sambandhi sappidavae
In madhyamavathi

Dasana madiko Enna
Bojonam seyya varungal
In nadhanamakriya

Nannu vidachi
Nannu brochutaku
In reethigowla

Jaya Jaya Rama
Jaya Jaya padmanabha
In manirangu

[HarishankarK]

Manasuloni Marmamulu
Thunai Purindarul
Both Varamu

Undedi Ramudu
Vandadum Solai
Both Harikamboji

[mohan]

Raghunayaka (Tyagaraja)
Karunai sevvai (Papanasam Sivan)

Dikshitar's nottu svara compositions
Various Western band tunes

[CRama]

Ninnu nera namminanura-Panthuvarali- Thyagraja
Ennaganu nama bhajana-Panthuvarali-Bhadrachala Ramadas
Ninnarul iyampalaguma-Panthuvarali-Papanasam Sivan-

[CRama]

Paritanamichite-Bilahari- Patnam Subramania Iyer
Nijam unai nambinen- Papanasam Sivan

Sringaralahari-Neelambari- Lingaraj Urs
Anandavalli- Neelambari- Swati Tirunal.

[ajaysimha]

thank you all for inputs

[MaheshS]

Sri Ramana Vibho [Swathi Thirunal] - Sri Sakala Ganadipa [BMK] - Arabhi

[HarishankarK]

Sringaralahari-Neelambari- Lingaraj Urs
Anandavalli- Neelambari- Swati Tirunal.

I don't think these two are same tune exactly - Anandavalli tempo itself is slower and it is more a padam. Sringaralahari is a kriti isn't it?

[sikhivahana]

Manasu karuga - Hamsadhwani - Patnam Subramania Iyer
Yuvati mana dAruN - Marathi natya sangeet

[ajaysimha]

Singara velavan Vandana
Kanoonjal adi irundal
In andhabhairavi

and paluke bangaramayena

[Ananth]

Birana vara and Himadri suthe.

[ajaysimha]

Venkatesh suprabatham
Kousalya supraja Rama - samskritha
vandhu udithai Rama - Tamil
Both in shuddha saveri

[ajaysimha]

nannu vidachi - thyagarajar
nannu brochutaku - mysore sadashiva rao
both in reethigowla ragam